Pepporoni Slice
Grandma pizza with Vegan Pepperoni
Cheese slice -- perfect cheese to sauce ratio
Grandma pizza with vegan pepperoni
the outside of the restaurant
the menu of the restaurant
Grandma pizza
Grandma and Calabrese. Grandma was my favorite. Calabrese has a strong pork flavor
margherita, tartufo, garlic knot
Vegan Pepperoni
IG: @cheylovesfood
Drinks
Vegan Pepperoni
Vegan Pepperoni Slices
Cream Soda, unopened bag of Pepperoni Knot (1) and Pepperoni Slice.
Brooklyn and Margherita. Brooklyn was one of our faves!
outside
Garlic Knot / IG: @mwy.eats
The way to my heart. IG: @cheylovesfood
Pizza
Margarita Pizza, delicious.
Garlic knot with marinara sauce / IG: @mwy.eats
Moussa K.
Dec 31, 2024
Solid NYC pizza place, polite and efficient help from the staff, had me a cream soda for the first time awhile and it hit the spot per usual lol. Good pizza hit the spot, had a pepperoni knot too and it was too good. Once I saw there was create your own pie I saw the unlimited potential of this place! Ate inside with friends before we checked into our hotel room and liked the dining room.
Read MoreJames F.
Nov 10, 2024
A solid slide shop with a cozy interior.We got the apple bacon slice and the bianco slice with ricotta cheese. The apple bacon slice was unique but we could tell it had been sitting out for a while. The garlic knot was delicious. The Bianca slice was perfect.We went on a Saturday night and it was about a 10 - 15 minute wait in line and then to get out food.Overall 7.79 / 10
Read MoreIan M.
Oct 3, 2024
They say NYC has the best pizza. Williamsburg Pizza is on the top of it!Best crust, and juicy slices! Dine-in or to-go, consistent quality!
Read MoreBenjamin S.
Feb 17, 2025
Unfortunately I got super sick not long after eating here. Would avoid, plenty of other options.
Read MoreVal M.
Feb 7, 2025
Very very good had two slices the Sophia Loren and a pepperoni piping hot and great taste great crisp. Def up there for a great slice
Read MoreDonna M.
Nov 10, 2024
A neighborhood late night pizzeria. They offer many unique slices but they're a little dry for my liking. Margarita slice is my personal fave. Regular cheese slice is a pass for me. They also offer garlic knots and pepperoni knots. Have only tried the garlic knot and it's pretty good. You get 1 for $1.50 but it's pretty large.
Read MoreMaddi B.
Oct 7, 2024
Williamsburg Pizza has the perfect sauce to cheese ratio! Love this place for a perfect plain slice!
Read MoreKeiana P.
Feb 21, 2025
Great experience. One of my favorite spots in NYC. Love that they are open late and they have the nicest staff!
Read MoreNancy A.
Feb 25, 2024
Not sure as to why this place has some bad reviews. Came here a couple of times and pizza is really good. Tastes very fresh! Not too oily or overly seasoned. You know you're getting your moneys worth! I always get margherita and grandma slices and they taste so delicious! it tastes authentic and the pepperoni and ingredients are very fresh and authentic.Place has enough tables to grab and dine in. The last time I got there all the tables were filled so that was a bummer although there was outside seating but it was too cold to do that so I took it to go. You can also stand by the window to eat but then it's weird so I took it go to. Condiments like cheese and pepper were readily available.
Read MorePhan H.
Jul 4, 2024
Man, I love me some zah. I think I've tried almost every pizza join in manhattan already and needed to step outside of my comfort zone and try some of the Brooklyn pies. Heard a lot of good things about Williamsburg pizza and those things were absolutely correct. I was in the area and looking for a spot for some dinner. Unfortunately, there aren't a lot of options, so when I saw this place, I thought I was saved. Walked in near closing time so it wasn't too busy. Was greeted immediately and ordered a Grandma's and a regular. They were very quick and I was out of the door try these slices at home. I at first wanted to stick around and dine-in but it didn't seem like the best place to enjoy the food, but then again I came in near closing on a weekday, so it might not be the best gauge of the vibes or atmosphere.Overall, very tasty pizza.-cheese pull? Check-firm crust with a little flop? check-not too greasy but full of flavor? check check-chewy and soft interior dough? checkThis place hits my already high ny slice standards and that's really saying something.
Read More