Village Square Pizza - West Village
Village Square Pizza - West Village
Vodka and Pepper & Sausage
Vodka and Pepper & Sausage
Regular cheese slice
the menu
outside
Pizza
a hand holding a slice of pizza
Signage
Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Square Pizza
White square
Regular cheese slice
interior
Pepperoni
Interior
interior, pizza
Classic Sicilian Pizza (Cheese Square)
Grandma slice
Menu
Regular cheese slice
Outdoor seats
Shine H.
Dec 8, 2024
Love the food but a bit oily. The service? Haha!! The only reason I come here.The Spanish lady at the counter with glasses, whistle to call me when my order is ready. How rude!!
Read More
Michele D.
Oct 29, 2024
I came to try L'Industrie, but in my judgement the line was too long, and this is on a 'best of' list, so here we gooo....I would get the pepperoni square here with one caveat. A good half of the pepperoni cups were not crisped. I don't expect pepperoni slices to be crisped, but I think it's valid to expect that of pepperoni cups. It's the entire point, well done at the edge making a tiny cup of oil. Cholesterol schmolesterol. Ask for it crispy, and hope it doesn't ruin the rest of the slice.Decent dough, nothing life changing. A solid slice sans pepperoni.
Read More
Jacky C.
Mar 3, 2024
Stopped by this pizza shop after L'industrie Pizza decided they don't want to serve anyone after 10PM, which is not a smart business decision IMO. You do you.As you probably suspect from the name, they only serve square pizza. Not complaining as long as I get the corner slice. I got the Pepperoni and Sausage ($6.50) and Margherita ($4.50). Both are solid choices and I enjoyed both of them. They only have one set of condiment shakers, so if you can't find it, someone's hogging them at their table.
Read More
Kimberly N.
Dec 5, 2023
We stopped by here for a quick, late lunch recently. Their Eggplant Square is one my daughter's favorites in the city so I wanted to give it a try. It is made with fresh mozzarella and fried eggplant with basil and a slightly sweet tomato sauce. It was absolutely delicious! If you are a fan of eggplant parmesan, you would like it, too. And it was very filling! My husband had a Pepperoni Square -- he knew he would like it because he had it at another of their locations. There was only one guy working behind the counter when we came by. He was very friendly and appreciative of the business. The pizza was ready fairly quickly. And while it's a small place, there are some counter seats available.
Read More
Marian S.
Nov 27, 2024
Delish!!! I went with a Marinara slice and it did not disappoint! I could eat one of these every day. The place down the street draws the long lines, but why wait when you can get equally good pizza for less and with no wait here?
Read More
Jordan A.
Nov 13, 2024
This place is great! My friends and I walked in here late night after a fun night at Rockbar for some late night food. If you're into grandma slices this is your place. We got the buffalo chicken, vodka, margarita, and pepperoni and all weee amazing. Vodka was probably the best with how rich and flavorful the sauce was. If you're in need of late night pizza in the west village this place is solid.
Read More
Apolonia E.
May 28, 2024
The pizza here is fantastic! The flavors were rich and satisfying. I tried both the buffalo chicken and pepperoni pizzas. Each slice was generously sized, making it difficult to finish, but I couldn't resist sampling both. They did not disappoint in the slightest; the buffalo chicken had a perfect blend of spicy and tangy, while the pepperoni was classic and flavorful. Definitely worth trying if you're in the mood for some hearty, delicious pizza.
Read More
Fern Gale E.
Dec 13, 2024
The grandma pizza was excellent. Not only a thin crisp crust but the sauce and pesto were beautifully seasoned. It's small so do keep that in mind. I am sure they have been impacted by another shop further east on the same block. Give them a shot for quick service by a nice staff and excellent pizza.
Read More
Emily C.
Apr 5, 2024
Tucked away in an unassuming corner of the West Village is Village Square Pizza, where, accurate to its name, you can find these square slices of crispy goodness. We came here as a fairly large group on a Sunday evening, and were able to fit comfortably inside the walls that were adorned with glowing reviews from online journals.The pizza had a bready crust that was chewy but crispy on the outside for that satisfying crunch. We shared a number of different slices and my favorites were the vodka slice (creamy sauce that balanced well with tomato I assume?) and the white pizza slice. The latter had gobs of ricotta (I wished they could be spread a bit more evenly throughout) that melded so well with hot honey drizzled over it.All the pizzas were nostalgic for me in a way with a homey comfort that money can't buy!The staff was friendly and provided good service.Visiting from out of state, I honestly felt this pizza wasn't what I imagined in terms of the kind of pizza New York is known for. However, it was a flavorful journey nonetheless and worth the try! (Don't forget to ask for the hot honey!)
Read More
Jonathan C.
Dec 23, 2023
I love the unique, thick cut square slices here! They're filling and a perfect snack or quick lunch. Very simple store front with some outdoor seating - the staff are great here.
Read More
