Village Square Pizza - Midtown
Village Square Pizza - Midtown
Pepperoni Square Pizza
a slice of pepperoni pizza
outside
outside
outside
Pepperoni, buffalo chicken
Pepperoni Square Pizza
The Margherita Pizza Grandma Pizza Bruschetta Square Pizza (Vegan) Garlic Knots
menu
food, pizza
food, pizza
pizza, food
the inside of the restaurant
a slice of pizza on a serving tray
Pepperoni Square
two pizzas cooking in a brick oven
food, pizza
Maya V.
Jan 31, 2025
White pizza: with the hot honey they provide... fire. Straight flames. There are multiple types of cheese on the pizza, and the honey and spice really round out the flavor and fattiness of the cheese and bread. Worth the $5. 9/10.Service is satisfactory, nothing extraordinary, vibes are absent but there is *very* bright lighting inside.Love how I can rely on Village Square Pizza for a quick slice at a reasonable price.
Read More
Vivek S.
Nov 25, 2024
Life changing. I've never been a huge pizza fan, and this was my first time having pizza in NY. Sauce, crust, cheese: perfect. I understand it now.
Read More
Clara S.
Sep 16, 2024
Popped into this pizza place when I was in the neighborhood. This was my first square pizza, so I didn't know what to expect. The guy at the counter was super helpful and nice-- he recommended I try their signature pepperoni slice!The pepperoni square slice with a drizzle of honey was fantastic-- the honey balanced out the saltiness of the pepperoni.
Read More
Linh N.
Feb 20, 2025
Was craving pepperoni pizza and this hit the spot! I love square pizzas because of their thickness- this one is super crispy on the bottom layer but soft on the inside. I love the generous topping of pepperoni cups! They are soooo flavorful! This location is new- the inside is very clean. The staff are very polite and helpful. Would definitely come back!
Read More
Jill S.
Nov 18, 2024
Deep dish pepperoni with hot honey was a winner!! Hot and very tasty- pizza by the slice
Read More
Martha V.
Apr 26, 2024
If you're in midtown and want to get a quick slice, this is your place. They have classic cheese, margherita, pesto and marinara, pepperoni, pepperoni and sausage, cheese vodka, three cheese, buffalo chicken, eggplant, veggie and sausage. The buffalo chicken is really good, they have the buffalo sauce on the counter so you can add to your liking. The pepperoni and sausage pizza had an amazing portion of pepperoni, most places skimp out but here at village square pizza they know how to please their customers. For those who love marinara, the grandma slice is the one as it has a lot of sauce with some cheese and pesto. The crust is nice and crisp, pizza is warmed upon request and served writhing 3-5 mins. Came in on a Thursday and the guy helping out at the front was pretty cool. There's plenty of counter space to eat at, really quiet but good music playing in the background.
Read More
Alyssa R.
Aug 10, 2023
Village Square has verrrrry quickly become one of my favorite slices in the city. What's not to like, right? Sicilian style with that thick crust, loaded with sweet tomato sauce, just the right amount of mozz and allllllll the pepperoni could dream of. The balance is near perfect with that thick dough and those pepperoni cups. Gosh, I love a spicy pepperoni cup.This new location is perfect for those who can't get down to the village but craving a delicious slice. I walked in a few weeks after they opened and was greeted by the friendliest guy behind the counter. We chatted for a few about those pepperoni cups while he heated up a couple slices for me.The place isn't too big but there's a counter along the one side if you want to stay in and have your slice, no stools tho. And be warned -- both sides of the place are lined with mirrors. Makes the space feel bigger than it really is and super bright but if you don't like seeing yourself eat then you may want to take your slice to go. :-P Either way -- it's going to be the best $$ you spend all week.
Read More
Huong P.
Jan 17, 2024
Sooooooo goooooood! I always stop by everytime I go shopping in the area. The pepperoni and grandma are my favsss
Read More
Sunny Y.
Nov 23, 2024
Ordered at Village Square Pizza on 35th Street, right next to Macy's, and had a fantastic experience. I ordered a slice of True Meat Lovers square pizza, which came loaded with pepperoni, premium sausage, and crispy bacon definitely a meat lover's dream. The flavors were rich, and the crust had the perfect balance of crispiness and chew. I also ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza, which was equally delicious. The combination of tender chicken, savory bacon, and the creamy ranch sauce made for a really satisfying bite. My server Tom was incredibly helpful, friendly, and attentive throughout my visit, making the whole experience even better. Overall, a great spot for pizza and great prices. Definitely recommend.
Read More
Kevin L.
Aug 1, 2024
Food: A pepperoni slice with hot honey was ~$7. Thick, crispy crust with copious cheese, sauce, and pepperoni.Service: The cashier was friendly.Ambiance: Brightly lit, befitting a pizza restaurant near Times Square.
Read More
