The Pie Guy Pizza

This place had a 4.9 on Google reviews, which is crazy higher than any place else in the area. I will say it has very good pizza. Crunchy and crisp. Very tasty. There is only a few seats at the window, but that is a New York thing.

Walked in & ordered a margarita pie for take out. Pie Guy guy says "gimme 15 minutes". No problemo. In the meantime I observe the slice window & everything looks copacetic (except the fried chicken rolls looked pretty tired).12 minutes later I get the "Hey Buddy". $24 & a $3 tip later I'm on my way. Open the box at home & have a still warm slice. The sauce is delicious & the crust has an excellent flavor (properly proofed). I guess my only thought is that it could have used another couple minutes to crisp the edge a bit more? All in all this hole in the wall Pie Guy is making the real deal! I recommend a visit!

Disgusting. Inedible. They took 1.5 hours to deliver, freezing cold pizza. The delivery man was rude.

This is a tiny takeout place in Chinatown just south of Canal.Food (4/5) - very interesting menu of items you don't see in many places. Got a chance to try out two of their slices:- Margherita- it was ok - thin and decent crust maybe bit too flimsy and needed a bit more burn. Sauce was good balanced tang.- Spicy Rigatoni- a novelty pizza and interesting for sure... the spicy rose sauce was pretty good Rigatoni was bit overcooked. Hard to eat this one without a fork and then it's hard to cut tbh.Service (4/5) - not all slices are available at all times so try and time it around their peak times. Friendly servers. Atmosphere (3.75/5) - not much too it... basically pick up place with some wood tables out front.Overall (4/5) - ok place and worth trying out for some of the novelty pizzas.

Great selection of different pies and slices with a variety of toppings.Had a meat lovers slice with a great assortment of toppings was a heavy filling slice a little salty thoAlso had a vodka slice with a special sweet tart slice with creamy cheese flavor smooth combination of flavors with the added saltiness from ham that cuts thruThe margarita is always a classic slice used as the measurement of how good a pizzeria is The sauce is a great combination of sweet and tart adding a refreshing punch. There could have been more basil on the margarita tho

I recently saw this place on Baxter street and decided to try their pizza. I ordered two large cheese pizza pies ($18) to go. The two cheese pizza pies came out different. One was overcooked and dry and the other pizza was soggy (cheese was all over the place). I ordered their pepperoni pizza ($24) a week later. It was better. So it might have been their cheese pizza or I went on an off day.

Incredible NY style pizza for a great price! We came in on a snowy Saturday evening and the owners were welcoming and warm. The margherita pizza was $24 for a whole pie. The dough was chewy and had great flavor. The pizza sauce was slightly sweet and very fresh. There was plenty of mozzarella cheese and fresh basil. The pizza was piping hot and the owners put it on separate plates for our party.

FAKE AND PAID REVIEWS.The pizza at here is worse than a $1 slice. The crust was soggy, the sauce was bland, and the cheese tasted rubbery. Save your money and order elsewhere.

The pizza itself is good but the service is borderline unethical. I ordered delivery and when the food arrived things were missing. Ordering through Slice, an intermediary I called and said there was something I paid for that was missing. The restaurant claimed they tried to call me to offer a refund (they certainly did not) and refused to issue a partial refund.The pizza is decent but the business seems a bit shady.

This has got to be the most underrated pizza!!! Idk how its so good i think its the sauce ! I get the supreme and my goood its definitely delicious!!!! Highly recommend! Born and raised in Queens