The Original Little Italy
The Original Little Italy
Spicy Sausage Robusta Pizza
Pepperoni slice
Menu
1 outdoor table
Open Now!!
the original little italy pizza
Small interior
a poster for the restaurant
Grandma slice
food, pizza
a pizza in a box
Grandma Slice
Sharyn L.
Sep 25, 2024
I had a perfectly decent slice of veggie pizza for lunch. The crust was delightfully crisp, and the ratio of cheese to sauce was good. It wasn't quite warm enough or fresh enough to warrant 5 stars, but solid. Service was efficient and the place was clean.
Read More
Christen M.
Sep 13, 2024
Popped into The Original Little Italy Pizza after seeing a full lunch counter of non-tourists and was not disappointed. Opted for the Spicy Sausage Robusta instead of a traditional NY slice, and it was delicious! The crust was amazingly crunchy, and the flavors were perfect. The service was fantastic and made me feel welcome in the big city. Definitely worth a visit!
Read More
Sadri B.
Jul 3, 2024
A very good pizza joint on 39th St off 5th Ave that's a bit hidden but worth finding . Good pizza , good squares , good grandma pizza , decent heros and pasta dishes . Not much seating inside , but some side counter area for the standing types . Got a large pie and garlic knots for my slacker office staff and empty pizza box with no crumbs left means the crew enjoyed another free lunch courtesy of me. Will order a few pies in a few days and will expect the same results , nothing will be left the the 2 pizza boxes open . Good pizza shop that deserves more business from the locals .
Read More
Shanna L.
Dec 12, 2023
Solid grandma slice! The crust is crispy. The pizza tasted fresh. The inside is minimal but it is a hole in the wall pizza shop. No bathroom. The slice was $4 which is a little expensive but for the location and quality it's deserving. The staff was nice. The man handling the pizza had his head covered and I saw him changing his gloves which I appreciate. Def a solid neighborhood addition.
Read More
Ronald K.
Mar 16, 2024
They have a large selection of pizza slices and all the customers I saw bought slices. There is one table with four chairs and a wall ledge with stools for about eight more people. It's very clean and tiled like a washroom. I've had better pizza but this is about location. The clean look is nice and the price is okay. The cheese did not have the chewy consistency that I am used to having with mozzarella - it's more like a mild cheddar. The sauce was hard to discern. It's okay if you are on your way to a show but it's not a destination.
Read More
John M.
Oct 5, 2023
I Love this place!! The Pizza is Amazing! Especially The Grandma Special!!!! The workers are Great as well. I Feel like this is the best Pizza in The City!!
Read More
Eric S.
Apr 25, 2023
Very good slice of standard cheese pizza. Liked the crust - was satisfied with the amount and quality of the cheese. Sauce was tasty. Place is clean. Staff is great.
Read More
Patricia A S.
Dec 4, 2023
Prices different in store than on the menu online. Example - Snapple marked as 2.75 on menu but I was charged 6.77 for two Snapple's in the store. Gets really crowded around 3 pm weekdays with students from the HS. Pizza is ok
Read More
Daniel S.
Nov 14, 2023
Great pizza! Crispy crust. Can't wait to go back. Exactly as described. Must try if you are in NY.
Read More
Al A.
Mar 17, 2023
Nice place for quick bite, good portion size, very accommodating to an addition I made, and reasonably priced
Read More
