The Mayfly
The Mayfly
Kale Salad
a bowl of french fries with a side of dips
a person holding a fork over a dish of macaroni and cheese
a plate of food on a table
food, chicken wings and fried chicken
Grilled Cheese
Turbulence cocktail
interior
Exterior
outside
Bar area
burgers, burger, food
Brunch burger with an egg
French toast, sour cream & onion dip, BLT with egg
Bar sign
a bar with bottles of alcohol
Bar area
Cheeseburger
outside
Eggs Benedict
We love all the cocktails
Burnt chicken tenders not crispy!!!
interior
Brunch menu
D R.
Feb 18, 2025
Absolutely LOVE The Mayfly! This spot is an absolute gem--great vibes, killer drinks, and some of the nicest bartenders in NYC. Seriously, they make you feel like a regular even if it's your first time. The cocktails? Immaculate. The beer selection? On point. The energy? Electric.
Read More
Tywana J.
Feb 14, 2025
I asked for crispy not burnt music was ehh late menu was trash just wings fries and tenders. Drinks average just a local bar depends on your crowd.
Read More
Amanda D.
Jan 11, 2024
This review is solely for their Happy Hour. Finding a good happy hour deal in the city doesn't seem like a daunting task but sometimes it can be! Came here for an after work happy hour with some friends and their menu had me once I saw espresso martini. The inside is cozy and a little small and there are bar tables alll along the middle of the restaurant. Their drink specials included a few speciality cocktails for $10 and then well drinks and beers (the basics). Outside of that they also offered happy hour food specials that came with a HH cocktail for $16. (Such a steal bc it's not just the bar snacks, it's like a full meal). The food was nothing spectacular, in fact I wasn't a fan of the dry rubbed wings I got but because I was hungry I ate It anyway. We got wings, flatbread and tacos. Our waitress was super nice and attentive -- loved her! Overall, i'd def return and have already added this spot to my running list of HH spots to visit.
Read More
Carmen M.
Jun 2, 2024
I recently had the pleasure of dining at Mayfly, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience from start to finish. The food was simply outstanding, with every dish bursting with flavor and beautifully presented. The service was impeccable; the staff were attentive, friendly, and made us feel right at home. The ambiance was enhanced by the great music ( a little loud) that created a lively and enjoyable atmosphere. If you're looking for a place that excels in food, service, and ambiance, Mayfly is the perfect spot. Highly recommended!
Read More
Phoebe A.
May 8, 2024
My friends and I were looking for a spot to hangout and came across this really nice sports bar. We got some cocktails, which were really refreshing and delicious. And we also got the truffle fries, which were quite tasty. All in all, the bar has good vibes, and seems to be a great spot for friends to have a casual night out.
Read More
Joan S.
Aug 13, 2024
Came here for a party that a friend hosted! The staff were nice and the drinks were decent. The ambience is a chill, low key place - good for catching up or a hangout!
Read More
Keyla P.
Dec 4, 2023
Cozy and cute. Peach Bellini was the favorite drink. Truffle fries were very tasty. Eggs benny was also very good. Friend loved his grilled cheese.
Read More
Hannah T.
Jan 5, 2025
Went for brunch and food was pretty good! Only drawback was that for the bottomless drinks the whole table had to participate
Read More
Jazmin Z.
Jan 26, 2025
Food was freshly made, it wasn't packed at all we went during the day and they sat us no problem. The music made it such a vibe and I would visit again next time.
Read More
Christina G.
Jan 12, 2025
We ordered the a few things off the menu and shared, everything was AMAZING! The staff is incredibly kind and welcoming! Highly recommended!
Read More
