The Gather Inn Again
The Gather Inn Again
Blue cheese burger and tater tots.
Where's the Blue cheese crumble, it's not there because it's dressing!
Loaded Tots
Loaded Keto Cauliflower Nachos
a roast beef sandwich
The Gather Inn Burger.
Our New Lunch and Dinner Menu. Check out our daily specials at www.thegatherinnagain.com
Lunch and Dinner Menu
a bar with many bottles of alcohol
Dunno
This so called Veggie Wrap is $9.50, pathetic.
Chili Cheese Bowl $6.50 half filled and swimming in puddles of oil that seeped through container.
Disgusting Chili Cheese Bowl
The rhinoceros logo alludes to the mascot of the owners father's former bar, "The Gather Inn."
Bar Area
Huskie Burger.
$2 basket of tots!!! Spinach mushroom and cheese omelet!! Yum!
Neighborhood bar.
Puddle of oil in Chili Cheese Bowl
Beer Battered Onion Rings, Eggplant Parmigiana Plate & a Samuel Adams Summer Ale Lager. delicious & terrific customer service.
Husky Burger with perfectly done Tots. That's pub eats!
Veggie Wrap in a stale bland wrap filled with raw onions and green peppers. Despicable
Beef Sliders and Grilled Cheese in the background
Nice Bloody Mary. Finished.
Danny V.
Sep 28, 2022
Very small local bar. It has a family like atmosphere kinda like Cheers. Everyone knows your name. I don't know if that's a good thing sometimes. Either way we were treated well as we were with some locals.
Read More
Timothy D.
Feb 22, 2025
I'll keep this short but honest. Absolute worst burger I have ever had in my 44 years of life!!! I order the blue cheese burger with tater tots. The meat is a frozen patty and they used blue cheese dressing rather than the actual blue cheese crumble. The tater tots are hard as a rock. It's almost impossible to ruin a tater tot in the whole tater tot existence. I can't believe somebody actually works in a kitchen and produce this disaster of meal. Don't ever try this place!
Read More
Wanda E.
Apr 6, 2022
We decided to order from this restaurant because of the great reviews. But I was sadly disappointed. The food arrived warm. I ordered the chicken BBQ nachos (sorry folks, don't like sour cream). The avocado was not a bright green, but ok, it was the evening & avocado does not like to be left out. The BBQ chicken was very good. BUT...I was halfway through my meal when I found a used diabetic test strip and lancet in my food. I was mortified! That is just disgusting. It is also a health and safety issue.My son immediately called The Gather Inn Again, had to leave his name and number. The owner did get back to him today. Unfortunately the owner #jaimedenardomicucci (Instragram name) was extremely rude. We also call Uber, though we know they only deliver and they were floored that such a thing even happened! And P.S. Uber called us back today to see how things were and inquired about any health issues. A shout out to Uber for being kind and considerate throughout this ordeal. Unlike the owner. Thank you Uber.I posted the same picture here on Instragram and the owners response was totally unacceptable. I was going to copy & paste her response, but then I thought better of it and screen shot her accusations and my response. She accused me of photoshopping the pic. And basically that I was lying. Why in the name of all the G-ds & G-ddesses would I make up such a thing? I never ordered from you before. And it is not like I was a "Karen" and b*tched about a piece of hair in my food. This is appalling! This is a health and safety issue. This is not something that happens all the time. Hair in the food -- yes. Used test strips & needles -- a hard NO!!! I was so sick about this all night. I went to the doctor's today and he was very angry that a restaurant would just disregard something like this. He immediately tested me for HIV (highly unlikely but better safe then sorry) and Hepatitis A, B & C (highly likely). I have to wait 6 weeks to see if any symptoms start to appear. So while she is accusing me of lying, I have wait 6 weeks to see if I am sick with something.So to sum up this drama....A). I will NEVER order from this place againB). The owner is rude and totally disrespectable toward their customersC). Clearly they do not give a crap about their business
Read More
Regina S.
Apr 9, 2022
I had my son's birthday party at The Gather Inn Again & everything was perfect. The staff is friendly & the food is always good. It's always my go to when I order in.
Read More
Samantha M.
Apr 11, 2022
The Gather Inn again has been my place to go with my family for many years now! Food is always amazing, the owner is always there to make sure everything is perfect! Anytime I go into Brooklyn New York it's one of my first stops. Neighborhood place with top of the line service and great people.
Read More
Maryann M.
Apr 14, 2022
Another delicious meal for dinner tonight. Daughter home from college and it's a must have for her. Loaded Keto Nachos out of this world. Caesar wrap so fresh. Breakfast Burger is one of a kind. Topped it off with a slice of New York cheesecake to complete. I would add a photo but it's all gone
Read More
Elizabeth Danielle Sima V.
Aug 18, 2024
Owner Jamie and staff especially Kaitlyn the other ladies who serve and bartend as well as the male staff...Brian for one are the nicest bunch of folks I ever met in any bar dining entertainment event venue.The comfy atmosphere creates laid back family friend gatherings that make me, and will make you want to keep returning to GATHER INN AGAIN! BUT THE MAIN DRAW TO THIS FAB BROOKLYN BUSINESS FOR ME ...IS THE ONE AND ONLY PART TIME FIREMAN BARTENDER , GORGEOUS,HUNKY HANDSOME CHARISMATIC CHARMER ...MR FREDDIE G.‼...The food is excellent the beverages the same it is clean reasonable a hidden jewel ....go give it a shot tell owner MY GAL PAL JAMIE....that EliZabeth V. sent you and be prepared to laugh smile sing dance meet people and just enjoy yourselves.Kid friendly events private parties and KARAOKE NIGHTS are all part of the GATHER INN AGAIN UNFORGETTABLE EXPERIENCE .... AaaaaaaaaaMEn ‼love this place . Period nothin' more need be said
Read More
Sara M.
Oct 26, 2023
Amazing food and service!!! Ask Kaitlyn about the new home made dip. It's delicious!
Read More
Leslie A.
Apr 10, 2022
Went to the Gather Inn yesterday for lunch with a friend. The food was amazing. Fresh, and delicious. Had the bbq chicken cauliflower nachos and loaded tater tots. Staff was friendly. Very attentive and company was great. I would absolutely recommend going in. Getting some food. A few drinks and just have fun. It was a good time
Read More
Gabrielle G.
Apr 21, 2021
Ordered through Uber eats and am absolutely disgusted. The "French dip sandwich" is boiled roast beef that I wouldn't even give to a dog to eat. The sliders came with cheese when they specifically ask if we would like to add cheese since they are not normally supposed to come with it. The onion rings look like they were cooked so many times they are almost black and taste like pure oil. The wings are dried out and burnt like chicken jerky and were bare wings instead of the buffalo wings we thought we were getting.
Read More
