Sushi by M

WOW! I had an amazing time here. This was my most memorable/top restaurant during my NYC trip from the Bay Area! Originally, we were going to get the $69 omakase but ended up with the $100 omakase. There were a few tables and a row of bar seating. Great service and the staff (both server and chefs) was super friendly. Great quality for every piece and amazing price. I would come back for sure!!2 Appetizers + 15 pieces + 1 Handroll - everything from this course was incredibly fresh and exquisite. To highlight a few - the toro melted in my mouth, uni was creamy, wagyu was charred to perfection, truffle went well with tuna, and salmon with a fascinating sauce on top. Server also offered us sake to drink with the chefs!

My friend, her mom, sister and I decided to walk into Sushi by M for an impromptu dinner and wow, it was such a fantastic experience! I always love a place where we could keep ordering more as we wanted, almost a la carte, which made for a relaxed and enjoyable night. The service was friendly and attentive, and we really enjoyed trying both the hot and cold sake options, which paired perfectly with each course.My top three pieces were the toro with caviar--rich and indulgent, the chu-toro with that perfect buttery texture, and the lightly seared hamachi, which was tender with a hint of smokiness. This spot is a must for any sushi lover and I think their menu changes, and they're known for their omakase, so I'd like to return.

Really love this spot. Super fresh food. Great service. On the smaller side which is nice for a more casual dinner!

Food, service And ambiance is great here!!!! Will definitely be returning and to both locations. It is still BYOB

I went here for my birthday and it was the BEST time.My bf and I got the more expensive set since it was my birthday and let me tell you it was worth it - that Hokkaido uni was so good! We also both got a Big Mac since that is their specialty. It is really good but honestly you would be fine without it. I would only get it on special occasions bc it's expensive $25 for one piece of sushi! Highlight was when they turned off the lights played birthday song and gave me a delicious piece with a candle!Also chef M is so fun! He gave us a ton of sake as our table seating was one of the last of the night. Def will be back!

I finally got around to trying omakase in nyc! Took a lil bit to get settled in a new city but I'm so glad this was first here. I'm a huge fan of omakase and I'm pleasantly surprised by how much cheaper it is here than in CA (which averages $200 for not that many pieces). They took such good care of me here! Thank you to all the waitresses who made sure I was having a good time. I wanted to treat myself to my recent accomplishments in life so I went on my own. I know dining alone can be intimidating for some people but you will definitely not feel alone here! I highly recommend getting the $100 set. It's really filling and the fancier nigiri options are so worth it.

I love omakase and decided to check out one of their locations. We booked a table ahead of time and was seated right away when arrived. This is the most thoroughly explained omakase I have been to. The chef explained every piece as it came out and told us how to eat each one. The staff was friendly and we were full by the end which normally doesn't happen at omakase.

This was my first omakase experience and it was a treat for my group of 4! We made a reservation for the countertop and we're really happy we did. Our chef was attentive, funny, engaging, and overall made the experience 5 stars. We opted for the 12 piece course and a bottle of sake and it was the perfect amount. The fish was fresh and I especially liked items that were torched, it gave a smoky profile to the delicate fish. The chef observed the way we picked up the pieces and positioned it precisely to everyone's preferred direction. He also listened and saw we were big lovers of brain numbing wasabi and added on more as well as provided us with a side of wasabi to use, the attention to detail! It was also cool to see that reason behind the M, there specialty pieces that were named after McDonald items! While there, we saw single diners, friends, couples; it was a casual but classy spot. Definitely would recommend for a night out!

10/10. Yet another amazing dining experience that will forever live rent free in my mind. Flawless execution from start to finish. My favorite omakase to date. Lovely cozy clean ambiance, warm fun engaging top notch service, and every single course was spectacular. I have no complaints or critiques whatsoever. Highly recommend and will not hesitate to return to Sushi by M the next time I'm in NYC. I cannot say enough positive things about this establishment. The chef even gave us free sake towards the end. All of the other positive yelp reviews are true! I hope they stay in business forever. A million stars for this meal!

Haven't even gone in yet. Had a 10p reservation and it's 10:24 and the prior seating hasn't even left yet. Have to edit. They apologized and it was one of the best experiences ever