Sushi 456

Had the omakase during lunch and it did not disappoint! Sat at the bar, service was wonderful. Sushi was fresh and delicious. Clean restaurant. Would definitely come back!

Amazing experience! It was like a whole show - this made our evening! Taste, presentation, ambience- everything was great. Thank you Chef! We will be coming back every time we are in NYC

Sushi 456 is my favorite spot for authentic Japanese, and I genuinely believe it offers the best combination of quality and affordability. Specifically for Japanese cuisine, I would even go as far as to suggest that this is a gem in NYC. The atmosphere is intimate and cozy, the lighting and sounds are always up to standard, and the menu is simple, just as Japanese should be.

Prototypical neighborhood omakase place. Easy to get a reservation, quiet, huge selection of excellent fish at budget prices.

Really enjoyed the omakase at this former hotpot place which is a pretty good omakase deal, and the ease of getting a table surprisingly on a Saturday night. Fresh, top-of-the-line fish and such a straightforward menu which I love. Not rushing back as it wasn't wildly creative or interesting, but definitely a delicious, reliable, well-priced sushi meal in the best neighborhood

Delicious!! So fresh. We happened upon it while visiting from California and felt incredibly lucky. We sat at the bar and let the chef recommend and choose for us. A real treat!

Amazing. Amazing. Amazing. So glad we found this place! Did the 15 piece Omakase for $100 and then ordered an extra piece of CA uni (omakase came with Maine Uni), which blew my mind away, and then a spicy scallop hand roll (omakase came with a tuna hand roll, which was delicious), which was also delicious and had a nice crunch to it. Especially loved that it was BYOB! $10 corkage fee per person. Also was impressed by the wood of the sushi bar.Will definitely be coming back here frequently! Highly recommend.

I love a good omakase and we walked past this place randomly one night and it looked so cute inside so we very easily booked a reservation for 8 pm that Saturday (they literally had every single time slot open). We were seated right away and were offered a table at the side of the restaurant or seats at the sushi bar. My regret of the evening was not sitting at the sushi bar counter, I think that takes the experience from good to great being able to see the chefs create each piece and put each bite in front of you. Instead our 15 piece omakase ($100) was served in two "courses" and made it a little bit less special. I was also a little disappointed the meal didn't come with dessert or anything to sort of "finish it off" the way I've had at other omakase places. For $100 a person I do want to feel like it is a really special experience, which i think this place lacked. The other reason I knocked a star was the unbelievably obnoxious table of men next to us who were screaming the entire evening, being rude, making crude comments, and not once did the staff say anything to them. It sort of ruined our experience unfortunately. I will likely come back to give this place another try.

If you want a casual experience with ok sushi, this place is not bad. Ingredients are fresh and service is good. $70 for the Omakase Nigiri (10 piece + 1 hand roll) is considered relatively affordable for omakase. The sushi are served in 2 plates of 5 pieces each - this is NOT your typical Omakase experience. I wasn't impressed by the sushi. They are uneven in size and some pieces are tiny. The rice is a bit hard / potentially undercooked. And too much soy sauce makes the sushi taste salty.For me the cheaper price point doesn't justify coming here again. There are plenty of good restaurants that offer under $100 omakase experience and high quality sushi. This is not one of them.

I cannot say enough good things about my family's experience at Sushi 456! It was my family's first omakase experience and Lin, the owner and our chef at the bar was amazing. We sat next to two different groups of regulars that clearly return here because of the hospitality and intimacy. He toasted with us for my birthday and was so kind!!We did the 10 piece omakase which was so fresh and delicious. Every bite was simple but so tasty! All of the fish melted in my mouth and it was impossible to choose a favorite. We will definitely be returning for the service and coziness of the restaurant!