Sunny John Pizzeria
Sunny John Pizzeria
Dry stuffed shells. Where's the sauce?
Dry ziti with Alfredo sauce. Once again, Where's the sauce?
Burnt garlic knots. I understand they baked in an over, but to totally burn a bottom & singe 3 is not great.
CAMPBELLS CANNED VEGETARIAN VEGETABLE SOUP, being PASSED OFF as minestrone!!!
a pizza box
two slices of pizza on a paper plate
Just to show you how thin it is but still can taste the pizza dough.
Grandma pizza
Everything pie with olives instead of mushrooms...
Everything Pie
interior
pizza, food
A well done square with everything, it was amazing!
food, pizza
Grandma square slice with pepperoni and lasagna
Baked Ziti craving!!!
food, pasta dish, pasta
Zeppole
Never returning.
outside, pizza
interior
Spinach, olive and mushroom pizza. Tasty, but kinda pricy at $22.50
The best grandma's pie in Brooklyn, hands down!
The way to go
Anthony B.
Dec 1, 2024
Local hole in the wall pizza place. Grandma pie is great. It's good to eat it right there as it's super thin. If you get it for take out, it's ice cold by the time your home.
Read More
Jihan B.
Dec 20, 2022
My favorite neighborhood pizzeria. Anytime the house wants pizza we drive over and get one regular and one extra cheese. The other night my husband wanted pizza and wings and we were shocked that there's actually delivery now so we tried it out. Everything arrived hot, fresh, and in one piece.
Read More
Rona D.
Jul 29, 2022
I have been to Sunny John's many times but decided to order via Grubhub+ today. I was so happy that the order actually came early! The order was stuffed shells, veal parmagiana with spaghetti (extra sauce & extra cheese), ziti with alfredo sauce & garlic knots. My hubby loved the veal. It was saucy and hot. I had the stuffed shells. To say my stuffed shells were a disappointment is an understatement. Talk about overcooked, slightly burnt & DRY! I had this before many times & it's always been perfect. This wasn't even during peak business hours. This order was placed around 2:30 PM. The garlic knots were burnt in several places. Someone wasn't manning the oven or something. I could even understand if it was during school & they were busy serving kids slices & forgot. I don't think I will order anymore. In person has always been great. Also, my daughter's ziti with Alfredo doesn't look like it has much Alfredo sauce. She hasn't eaten it yet. We'll see what she thinks I Will probably have to eat something else later being I only ate 2 dry shells & peeled the burnt bottom & top off of 2 garlic knots & ate them.This order was pricey! I expected more from Sunny John's.Very disappointed. Will think twice about ordering again.
Read More
Stephanie L.
Mar 11, 2021
Their grandma pizza is my favorite, it's cheese on the bottom and Tomato sauce on top, it's thin but still has a chewy texture which I like, I don't really like thin crust pizza because it's like eating a potato chip. I want to taste some of the dough if I'm eating pizza. I also like their lasagna and I've tried many places I still go back to this one. Their spinach and chicken rolls are good as well. Oh, did I mention they have zeppoles (not many pizzerias make them) and they are good too!
Read More
Ms P.
Mar 19, 2019
Ordered delivery with Slice. Expensive but good. Delivery on time and Courier very friendly plus a little funny. Ordered:*Grandma Square 4 slices with pepperoni*Lasagna with extra sauceGrandma Slice hit the spot and lasagna was very good. Wish the lasagna portion was bigger.Will definitely order again but pockets will have to be right.
Read More
Ken F.
Jul 14, 2022
Just got a shrimp parmagian hero and a pepperoni roll. Both were hot, fresh, and delicious. I ordered online and it was ready right on time or a little early. And they were friendly, too. A+
Read More
Ismail L.
Jun 13, 2024
Been coming here for years they treat the customers very nicely and I love the bbq slice
Read More
Tara N.
May 4, 2023
The pizza, wings, calzone and Cesar salad are amazing! We've never had a bad meal from here.
Read More
Unknown E.
Jan 6, 2024
they are alway serving hot pizza slices when I tell them not to hot all the cheese n sauce dripping from the slice making a mess it's maybe because I'm a proud black person eating here not recommended
Read More
Melissa B.
Nov 2, 2023
The pizza is great, they make the pie to my liking, well done but not burnt, delivery is fast, and now they are open on Sundays. They have a lot in back if you can't find parking in front. The only problem is there is no way in through the back and so you have to walk around to the front
Read More
