a slice of pizza on a paper plate
pizza, food
interior
Square pizza
Square pizza
Wings
Looks new and interesting
pizza, food
spicy honey pepperoni
Square pizza
Annalise F.
Dec 27, 2024
Great quick pizza spot in the Garment District. I believe the dough is like a focaccia - thick and crispy. The garlic knots are some of the best I've ever had. We didn't have to wait very long at all. There's maybe 2-3 seats inside, so plan to take this for the road. Very close to several hotels in the area.
Read MoreYoonki N.
Nov 27, 2023
Something quick and easy dinner. Budget friendly, flavor was good only reasons giving three star was due to their chicken texture. It felt like chicken nugget that fall in water and died.
Read MoreAdamme M.
Jun 7, 2022
Tried a Sicilian slice. Looked like it had sat out a while but tried anyway due to the other reviews. Puddles of oil. Crust was crispy but when I took a bite the sauce and cheese taste was so bad I had to spit it out. Waste of $5.45.
Read MoreJoe O.
Dec 25, 2022
I had the spicy honey pepperoni pizza. It was excellent. Simple and delicious. Went back several times and also got the pineapple ham pizza. The service was great and they open late at night. Will definitely go back when we visit NYC again.
Read MoreValeria H.
Jul 29, 2022
phenomenal pizza at a great price. we came here on a recent trip to NYC and this place was across from our hotel. the place just has a great energy and we went back multiple times while we visited. 10/10 recommend the spicy honey pepperoni pizza - it's probably the best pizza i've ever had and i'm not generally a fan.
Read MoreElizabeth R.
Mar 18, 2022
Honestly surprised at how good this pizza was. I got a vegan slice and my dog had a ricotta one. I was so impressed with the vegan slice. It was perfect. The staff was very nice. Highly recommend.
Read MoreAmanda C.
Feb 14, 2025
First time having New York pizza and Square Pizza did not disappoint!! The ingredients were fresh and the pizza had just the right amount of crunch.
Read MoreCrystal L.
Oct 25, 2024
Unfortunately, I did not take a pic of our pizza. We went a few times and this place is way under rated. The staff is very nice. It's a cute small place with fast service. I would definitely recommend checking it out. They also had a ton of different options to pick from.
Read MoreBaba L.
May 24, 2024
We recently spent a weekend in New York City and Square Pizza was across the street from our hotel. So we went here totally by chance. The place is tiny, but the pizza is great! We ordered a whole pizza to go and it was made right in front of us and done in good time. The friendly pizza chef was so very pleasant to deal with and happily packaged salt, pepper, grated cheese, oregano, ground garlic and crushed pepper for us to use at the hotel. We also purchased a half dozen garlic knots that were very delicious. This is not a place you go for looks or comfort as I said it was tiny and there were only about 4 or 5 chairs and a small counter available. However, it is and excellent place to takeout. I recommend it most highly!
Read MoreAmir M.
Oct 26, 2023
Amazing pizza out of this little shop. The sauce is a bit sweet which compliments flavors very well. The thin dough is tender and melts in your mouth even after being reheated. The cupping pepperoni was excellent with little aftertaste. Hard to ask for more.
Read More