Scarr's Pizza

Decent pizza spot. I came here on a Sunday evening and there was a small wait. The spot has two sections: a sit-down, restaurant section and a to-go, by-the-slice spot with only bar (aka, you would have to stand and eat your pizza). I got a mushroom pizza and a jalapeno/pepperoni pizza and both were pretty solid. They're both on the thinner side and the toppings were pretty solid. I just wish that they had a bit more options and variety in their by-the-slice orders. Nonetheless, it was pretty standard pizza (loved how they added a hot oil to the jalapeno/pepperoni pizza though!).

Two great things about New York:1. Pizza2. How on a random weeknight you can walk into a pizza shop at 10pm and feel an atmosphere and buzz about the place. Veered away from NY thin crust to try the Sicilian Pepperoni and did not regret it. I haven't had a pizza slice this thick that absolutely melts in my mouth before. Great ratio of toppings, cheese, sauce, crust with high quality ingredients and flavors. Store front was packed out at 10pm which shows its popularity.

Stopped in while running errands around the LES! Scarr's has been on my list since moving to NYC and there's always been a long line each time I've tried to go, but NOT today. Got the beef pepperoni slice with hot honey and a Mexican Coke to wash it down. Did not realize how spacious it was inside! Plenty of space to sit and catch your breath from wandering the city. Friendly service and tasty pizza, will be back!

Solid spot for that quintessential New York slice.Scarr's serves classic pizza in big, hearty slices. I loved the usual Pepperoni Pizza and how cheesy and slightly crunchy it was.They also have a selection of local beers on tap, which is great for visitors looking to try new brews.Do note that seating here is limited in the evenings, as you do need to buy a whole pie if you want to be seated. During the day, it's more lax and you can be seated if just ordering slices. Service is pretty solid and the venue is charming. Definitely a spot to try for those looking for good pizza.

Visited because of the hype on tiktok! And Scarr's pizza did not disappoint!!!!We opted to get the hot boi slice which comes with hot honey, pepperoni and jalapenos! This quickly became my favorite bites as the crust was perfectly crispy/burnt and had the perfect amount of sweetness and spice. Service was fast and friendly, there wasn't a huge line around 8pm. The store itself is small but there is seating in the back! I truly think about this slice frequently..

I've continued to have mediocre pizza almost every time I venture into the city. Not this last time. Scarr's pizza was great!Service (5/5):The lady taking my order was pleasant and efficient. The people working there seemed to enjoy working there.Ambience (5/5):The place gave traditional pizza shop vibes with some 50's diner aesthetic. The restaurant actually has two parts. The front is a pizza shop/ stand where you can point and choose which pizza slice you want. The back part is a restaurant and bar with arcade games.Food (5/5):I opted for a simple cheese slice and asked for some hot honey on top. Fresh. Tasty. Quality. What more can you ask for? Now when people visit me and want a New York slice, I'll take them here!

TL:DR- Yummy pizza, worth the wait for the slicesFood: 5/5 Hot honey pizza Service: 5/5 Nice and attentiveAmbiance: 4/5Nothing special, had to wait in line per usual but ate outside on the street

Finally made my way here and I liked it! We got the Hot Boi and the Sicilian slices to try out. The Hot Boi is indeed hot and finished with hot honey. The Sicilian slice has a nice crunchy/pillowy soft dough. Good cheese and sauce. This was good too! Will return for sure.

Another spot serving up classic New York style pizza, and it's a popular with locals. The pizza here is thin, crispy, and undeniably good. I went with the classic pepperoni and cheese and it was great. While I'm not sure if it's the best pizza in New York, it's definitely a solid choice.The restaurant has seating and a bar, making it a great place to take a break from walking the city. The space is dimly lit, with rap music adding a lively vibe to the atmosphere. It's worth stopping by for a slice if you are in the area.

Great pizza and the best ambience! Staff is so great and create such a vibe. We go every time we are in New York and there are always tons of locals.