Rosie O'Grady's

Location: 148 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019Service: pretty good. Shoutout to Julianne he is the best. Took care of us well. Ambiance: plenty of seats. We took the booth. Clean restrooms. Food: everything we've tried so far is okay. Except for the spinach gorgonzola salad. It really stood out. Made me google the recipe cause cant wait to make them. This place is worth the try. And oh the vanilla ice cream with cake too. It was perfff! Loved it.

We have frequented the old location for many years. We decided to try the new spot. Although more modern, it lacks the vibe of the original. The service is solid and friendly. We ate in the bar much like we used to. It is nice you can get the full menu. The food overall was underwhelming. We ordered fried calamari 3/5 (it seemed a bit under). A special crab stuffed cod 3.5/5, and the grilled salmon 3/5. Full bar in addition good beer and wine selections.

Walked in to get some steak for lunch. A big party was booked for the bar area as that was the only TV. Stood around and really wanted a place there with TV for college football. The host was super nice and tried helping out by sending us to another place with TVs, we walked out then decided to come back because the food looked better here. Then he worked some magic and was able to sit us at a table in the TV area. Amazing! Food ordered were all good except the chicken was overcooked. Steak was cooked very well. Definitely a bit more rare if you want medium (i had no issues with it) came with mashed potatoes. Burger was great. Fries regular. Chicken burger minus the buns. I asked for more lettuce instead but guess it's a rare request. No big deal since the portions were big. Ordered spicy margaritas which were great. All in all, it was a good place. Yelp reviews are definitely subpar compared to their google review. I appreciate the staff were attentive and had a good experience. We went for lunch. Bathroom is past the wine cellar and down to the right. Only suggestion there is handless knobs, because you know some people do not wash their hands!

Didn't need a reservation on a Saturday evening. Very nice place with good service. A bit pricey but hey everything in NYC is pricey. Drinks were about $18. Spacious inside. The burger were well made and juicy, calamari was fresh and made perfect. Drinks were tasty and mixed well.

I went to Rosie O'Grady's with a group of drunk crime writers on a Saturday night. I was one of the drunk crime writers, fresh off a conference banquet where I'd had a small salad, a piece of meat, and an indeterminate amount of wine. There was a pre-party and an afterparty, but it was only 11:30 and we were all going home the next day. Someone said "Rosie O'Grady's" and we went.I guess the place is actually a restaurant, but it pulled a good late shift as a chill pub/sports bar with fast bar service and plenty of seating. I think I behaved myself and stuck to a beer, possibly two. I don't remember what I ordered, but it was something they had on tap, and I was happy with it.I'd recommend Rosie O'Grady's if you're looking for a calm place to drink near Times Square. It's not the most exciting spot in New York, but it served our needs quite well.

We walked in on a whim before a show and was pleasantly surprised to see the fab new decor. Our lunch was YUMMY and service was great. I will DEF be back! Thanks Rosie's!

Was very surprise the reviews weren't 4.5 or higher because the atmosphere was nice and relaxing. Food was delicious and cooked perfectly! Our waiter, Julian was very knowledgeable and made great suggestions! SO good!!

We've been coming here for over ten years. It moved to its current location less than a year ago. We would say this place is more of a bar that happens to serve food as an afterthought. The dining room was incredibly understaffed and many diners were unhappy and complaining amongst themselves. Most waitstaff weren't veteran employees but seemed green and unable to keep up with the needs of the patrons. Service was mediocre at best. While meal and cocktails were decent, dessert was awful. I ordered "hot" apple pie ala mode(specifically asked the waiter if it would be warmed). The pie was room temperature and the top and bottom crust were mushy(like it was way past its Use By date). Ice cream was equally old and not fresh and had ice crystals in it like it'd defrosted and been re-frozen. Why would the chef allow such subpar food to be served to diners? We decided it's time to find a different place to eat when we come into the city.

Food was a little slow to come, but well worth the wait for our Thanksgiving dinner. Would definitely go back.

Sat outside so I'm not sure how the ambiance was inside. Food was fresh when it arrived. My chicken piccata was way too lemony. The children's fries were way too salty. Overall, it was terrible. We were hungry & stumbled upon this place last minute.