Pizza Secret

My girlfriend and I prefer Napoli style pizza. We have a go to restaurant in NJ but this is excellent too. Bufala Pizza is excellent and overall good vibe.

This place was very good circa 2022 but it went way downhill. I picked up a large pizza yesterday and it was a soggy mess. It seemed like it was barely cooked. I don't know if they were busy and trying rush it, but I had to finish cooking it at home. Brooklyn has so many great pizza places. This is not one of them.

We had the caprese pizza was ok. The calamari had absolutely no flavor. They didn't even put black pepper on it. The service was good and the food came out quickly. I guess that's because they didn't season the food.

The sun was out. It was an extremely busy day in Park Slope. Fifth Avenue on a Saturday is extremely busy, Pizza Secret was a welcoming surprise.We were seated quickly in their sidewalk seating. The waitress was fast and gave suggestions. The home made Sangria was fruity. The wine punch served over ice did not disappoint.Americana San Marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, honey spice olive oil, basil, with sausage and pepperoni had all of six slices. The oven crispy fire roasted crust was good, but it was definitely smaller than I expected.The staff was attentive, friendly, and the atmosphere was nice. Televisions and surround sound was everywhere throughout the restaurant, to be at the bar during the NBA finals would definitely make for a great evening. I wish I would've been more selective with my dinner choices. The pizza pie was garnished and seasoned well, but it was small.

We came here with a group of 12 with a toddler for a birthday and overall had a nice time! The place definitely gets crowded and a bit loud, but the staff is nice and the food is good.Had some critics in the group, but everyone enjoyed their food. We got pizzas including the truffle pizza, calamari , mussels, meatballs, olives, bruschetta, prosciutto, truffle cacio e pepe, truffle fries, ragu pasta, Caesar salad, tiramisu, panna cotta and the pillowy desserts with dip. The pizzas were tasty, the sauce had a yummy sweetness and I really enjoyed my pasta Genovese which had like stewed meat and potatoes with homemade pasta. The dessert was really good even without the dip, tiramisu was yummy and the wine was good as well. The Moscato was a bit flat, but good enough.The prices were a little high with portions on the smaller side, but overall it was a nice meal for my husband's 40th. The service was nice, but missed a few marks (i.e. asked if my husband's tiramisu dessert could have the candle or be specialized and they brought out the panna cotta with the sparkly candle which was cool, but in the wron6f dessert and it went out before they got to the table lol...)I did come back the next day for take out to get the pasta Genovese again because it was so good, but at 23+tax, a 30+ min drive and not a full stomach, it will probably not be a regular place for us. Good for groups and child friendly though!

Pizza Secret is incredible! Rosario, the owner, greeted us and Colleen, our waitress, provided exceptional service. The pizza was perfecto! Great food, amazing people!

Normally I enjoy a Neapolitan pizza. A fast cook, chewy crust, and fresher ingredients than what goes into a normal pie. Unfortunately this pizza was expensive and you only get four slices instead of six.The pie I got was also really sweet, sickly so. Maybe other pies work better, but this nearly ruined my palate. The honey was too much. I also felt the crust was way too chewy. The side Arancini is really delicious even though you only get two of them. That was nice.I am mixed because the food has potential but this was just slightly off the mark.

3% Credit Card Fee! I don't believe this was on the menu. I decided to drop by Pizza Secret around 4:45 on a Monday. I was the only person there, but two other parties came by the time I finished eating. They have a decently spaced interior, though the tables near the window are a tighter squeeze. The interior has modern decor around the pizza oven.I ordered a Margherita pizza ($19). I think it is on the pricier side but not outrageous. I enjoyed the pizza; the dough was soft and chewy, the tomato sauce has a nice acidity, and there was no burning or char on the pizza. I wish there was a bit more basil, but the pizza still tasted good. As soon as I sat down, the waitress told me about the most popular pizza, which is the Americana ($22), which I just didn't go for because I'm not the biggest spice fan. Everything else was self-serve; I served myself from the bottle of water, so I cannot speak that much to service. Overall, I enjoyed the pizza and would come back if I needed a fancier bite in the future!

If you are in Brooklyn. It's a must stop in for delicious pizza, pasta, ricotta dip, salad really we tried everything oh and the cocktails. Juan was awesome! Even though it was really busy the food and service was fantastic!

Stopped in real quick to grab a bite to eat after the game. Was greeted by a friendly face and promptly seated. Service was quick and friendly and the pizza was good. Will be back next time I'm in the area.