Percy's Pizza

I can see why this place stays in business. Hole in the wall? Pizzas out the wazoo? Cheap slices? ($3) In the middle of drunken college student nirvana needing a quick refuel? Ding ding we have a winner?I'm from NJ, so I have some serious pizza trust issues as it is. And this may just need be the best damn slice of pizza I've found. Sweeeett

Have been going to Percy's for years, since it was only $1 for a cheese slice... which was until the pandemic. It always had amazing pizza... not the 99¢/$1 junk slices elsewhere. The quality continues. Percy's makes an excellent classic New York slice with the right crispy crust and great cheese. Now, the price has just inched up from $2 to $3. (My wish - they return to the great deal of $2, but it's unlikely because they painted the price on the awning.) If you want a topping it's only an extra buck, but my preference is keeping to the basic cheese! If you're in the neighborhood, definitely check Percy's out.

It's cheap pizza and it tastes like cheap pizza. Really, my cheese slice tasted like nothing; super plain. The staff are friendly here.There's not much room to eat inside, but they have some tables out at the curb.

$2 slice. Can't beat it. Staple in the area and reliable. Pizza has a good sauce/cheese/crust ratio. Close to lots of other spots in the area, so a nice place to hit up after a bar. Would definitely come back.

Soooo good! Can't help but stop by for a slice when I'm around the area. Its thin and has the ultimate crisp throughout the whole slice. Highly recommend!!!

I have always loved Percy's and I am happy to report that it's made it through the pandemic with a very similar price point!! Before the pandemic they were cash only - they now take card! What I have always appreciated is their full bar of pizza toppings. Percy is (almost) always there with a smile. The best pizza in the village.

Pretty good casual pizza spot in a high traffic area. Inexpensive slices. Some indoor seating but a very narrow space.

ordered one mushroom pizza $4 mixed veggie pizza $5 extra cheese x 2 $2 service is good. Friendly, and only one person is running at this place. located on Bleeker st x macdougal st It's very small store but there's a place to sit down but no bathroom. The store is open door so you might feel very cold during autumn and winter time.

Stopped in on my way from Boston to Battery Park. Needed a slice and they were close to where I parked. Don't let the hole in the wall design fool or mislead you; minimalist decor is not reflective of the flavor of their pizza. I had a Sicilian and my son had a regular slice - both had perfectly crispy crust, sauce dripping with flavor, and cheese and pepperoni that were very fresh. Great spot for a quick slice!

By far the best inexpensive pizza in New York City. Friendly owner and enjoyed the experience.