Paradise Lost

Walked into Paradise Lost only knowing it was a tiki bar. Had no expectations. But even if I had, they would have been blown away.It took awhile to get inside and to our table. We were taken to a standing high top first. The decor is super fun. So many things to look at!Service was great! Our server explained the menu to us and was super helpful. Every drink was fantastic! Almost each drink came in a unique glass with fun lil decorations.Definitely will return to order a behemoth!

Since I work around the corner I've been wanting to check out Paradise Lost for a damn year and I was off today...So, I got to try it out! Was NOT disappointed!!We started with the Tarman (I love ROTLD) and one of the mezcal drinks (I forgot the name ) was quite strong but not pouring from behind your own ping pong table strong. Was still balanced if that makes sense??Joey took care of us at the bar and was awesome! I'm definitely glad it lived up to my hopes and dreams and cannot wait to come back for a nightcap once I get off work!! The vibe definitely speaks for itself and it's AMAZING! Two thumbs up

There's a super cool vibe in this highly creative bar serving really fun cocktails. The four of us sat for an hour or two admiring the kitchy decor like kids on a movie set where 1950s tiki culture meets 1960s Attack of The 50-foot Woman.Some sweet and spicy drinks were shared along with a mini pyrotechnic show. Even reading the drink descriptions was entertaining. This place is a home run for date night or happy hour after work (but only if you work with really cool people).Someone put a lot of heart and creative soul into this place. We will be back!

I am a total tiki obsessive, and am always on the lookout for a place with authentic tiki cocktails. Well, Manhattan's fabulous tiki bar Paradise Lost was right up my alley. This place was killer! Incredible atmosphere, fabulous tiki drink menu, cool munchies and groovy music. I loved everything about it. I had the Cobra's Fang (amazing!) and The Greenfuz (non-alcoholic! what a bonus to be able to enjoy a second cocktail and still drive home); my wife enjoyed the Pearl Diver. We will be back. Good thing we don't live in NYC, we'd be there every single night!

My girlfriend and I stopped in for a couple of drinks after a show on a Tuesday night. The service was great, especially because it was kind of empty in the bar. Our waiter Ricky was very kind and answered all of our questions about the menu. To start, he recommended I try the Beelz's Road Soda, which ended up my favourite drink of the night. It had an almost cinnamon tasting finish that I loved. I also ordered a Pina Colada, which was pretty standard. Not bad, but not great. My girlfriend had the Demerara Dry Float and the Attack of the Banantulas, both of which she loved. We also snacked on the Damned Dumplings. The sauce that comes with them was the star of the plate but the dumplings themselves were pretty good. We would definitely come back so we can try some more of the menu! .

If you're someone that gets overstimulated easy, this is not the place for you lol. BUT if you're looking for a fun tiki bar - you'll love it here. I love that there was a non alcoholic drink menu and the waitstaff and person managing entry to the bar were very nice! I got a pina colada and was honestly disappointed because it tasted a bit off, I think if I got something else I would be happier though because you can tell there was a lot of time put into curating the drink menu. If you want a fun place to bring friends to look cool, this is your place!

We are frequent flyers at Paradise Lost for several reasons but last night we had a phenomenal experience that I felt I must write about! We were seated at a banquet and within a minute our server stopped by to greet us and begin the experience. We had the absolute pleasure of being served by Brian, who is not only superb at his job but also just such a charismatic person. We typically prefer to sit at the bar but if Brian is there we will undoubtedly sit elsewhere! Last night we were able to try some of their new "seasonal" concoctions, the "3 dots + a dash" is a tiki classic that Paradise Lost does amazingly! They also brought back their "Khali Coffee Grog" which my wife LOVES. Overall, Paradise Lost once again did not disappoint, if you're contemplating going here, stop contemplating and GO!

Best bar in NYC. I loved every drink here! Tiki bar vibes. Speakeasy down a long hallway. Interesting decor... Would definitely come back and bring all my friends here.

solid tiki cocktails, really fun atmosphere, service was great, the fire show is fun (for the larger cocktails)

Wow such a fun tiki bar. The drinks were all quite good. Its walk in only so might be a wait sometimes.