My Pie Pizzeria Romana
My Pie Pizzeria Romana
Weekly imported Buffalo cheese from Salerno, Italy, organic Italian tomato sauce, virgin olive oil, fresh basil and cherry tomato.
Organic Italian tomato sauce, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic, Parmesan cheese and Italian virgin olive oil.
Organic Italian tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Home-made beef lasagna, ricotta cheese, part-skim mozzarella, organic tomato sauce, Parmesan and parsley.
Homemade beef lasagna, ricotta cheese, part-skim mozzarella, organic tomato sauce, Parmesan and parsley.
Olive oil, ricotta cheese, Parmesan cheese, part skim mozzarella , garlic and parsley.
Flor di latte cheese, part skim mozzarella, fresh tomato, oregano and extra virgin olive oil.
Flor de latte cheese, part skim mozzarella, fresh tomato, oregano and extra virgin olive oil.
Part skim mozzarella cheese and organic Italian tomato sauce.
Italian virgin olive oil with truffle. fresh mushrooms and part-skim mozzarella.
Marinated chicken, Alfredo sauce and part skim mozzarella cheese. Add jalapenos for an additional charge.
Marinated chicken with spicy Buffalo sauce and ranch, part-skim mozzarella cheese and chopped parsley.
Fresh mushroom, part-skim mozzarella and Italian virgin olive oil.
Part-skim mozzarella cheese, fresh diced tomato, caramelized onion, feta cheese, mushroom and garlic sauce.
Part-skim mozzarella and caramelized onions. Add Gorgonzola cheese for an additional charge
Potato, Italian virgin olive oil, rosemary and part-skim mozzarella.
Organic tomato sauce, part skim mozzarella and pepperoni.
Organic tomato sauce, part-skim mozzarella and imported hot dry Italian sausage.
Ham. Proscuitto cotto imported from part-Italy and part-skim mozzarella cheese.
Eggplant, organic Italian tomao sauce, Parmesan cheese part-skim mozzarella, chopped basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Fresh baby arugula, Parmesan cheese, organic Italian tomato sauce, cherry tomato and extra virgin olive oil.
No cheese. Organic Italian tomato sauce, fresh diced tomato, mushroom, oregano and garlic.
No cheese. Organic Italian tomato sauce, mushrooms, oregano, garlic and seasonal veggies.
Vegan cheese. Organic Italian tomato sauce, mushrooms, oregano, garlic and seasonal veggies.
Part skim mozzarella and Gorgonzola cheese with our no sugar added natural Italian flour pizza.
Organic tomato sauce, part skim mozzarella with our no sugar added natural Italian flour pizza dough.
No cheese. Organic Italian tomato sauce, mushrooms, oregano, garlic and eggplant with our no sugar added natural Italian flour pizza dough.
Vegan cheese. Organic Italian tomato sauce, mushrooms, oregano, garlic and seasonal veggies.
Pesto sauce (nut free), part skim mozzarella, chopped tomato, Parmesan cheese.
Made with berries.
Your choice of flavor.
Your choice of flavor.
Baby arugula, spinach, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, artichokes, mushroom and vinegar balsamic olive oil on the side.
Too much pizza for three person! Each slice is cut into half.
Dry Italian Sausage slice. $4.95 + tax + tip
Dry Italian Sausage slice. $4.95 + tax + tip
Exterior
Outdoor seating
Exterior
Ambiance
a woman behind the counter
Eggplant Parmesan Pizza, Sun-dried Tomato Pizza Slice Four slices total, they are cut in halves and bigger than this picture does justice.
Restaurant
food, pizza
Truffle Oil & Mushroom Pizza
Mozzarella di Buffalo Cheese Pizza
outside
Truffle Oil & Mushroom Pizza
Outdoor seating very limited
Ambiance
Chicken Buffalo Pizza
Vegan pies
Truffle Oil & Mushroom Pizza
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Zalika S.
Sep 6, 2024
the shortest review that you'll ever see! JUST GO! RUN the pizza here is sooo good and fresh it actually made me like pizza, and one of the first times I properly enjoyed a pizza in New York! The service was so great! The girly worker is literally the absolute sweetest! There's a couple of seats the vibe here is also really nice! I had the potato one and chicken buffalo omggg sooo good! Also tried my friends' pesto tomato one heavennnn run runnn!!maybe I lied this isn't the shortest review 10/10 would recommend going here for your lunch break or with friends!!! Can't wait to try the other types
Read More
William L.
Feb 18, 2024
Came to NYC for vacation and pizza, having tried several of the trendy names, I was beginning to get disappointed until I tried My Pie Pizzeria Romana. Plenty of options for different toppings. Thin and crunchy crust that can support plenty of toppings and just really good pizza. Seating is limited, but it's pizzaWould I Go Out of My Way to Try? YesWould I Return? YesAmbiance- 6/10Food Taste- 9/10Service- 8/10Value- 8/10
Read More
Daniel V.
Dec 9, 2024
To me this was one of my least favorite pizzas in NY! The lasagna/Alfredo didn't really good flavor to it. The pizza was crunchy though.
Read More
Sameh A.
Nov 8, 2024
Wow what a fantastic ice of pizza , I asked for it extra crispy and it was perfect, the sides were perfectly crispy and the bottom was crispy. The pizza was not oily and had a good amount of cheese on it . The price was reasonable and the staff was very friendly. Not many seats available and it's a small spot. I am hoping to come back to try other flavors or have more pepperoni.
Read More
Raquel L.
Nov 19, 2023
Visiting NYC and this place was recommended by the bell desk at our hotel Concordia. It was walking distance and decided we needed to have NYC pizza before leaving for our flight later that day. This location is a small place. There are a few seating but this is mostly for take out. Came during the lunch hour so it was quite busy. When you walk in you will be a display of different unique types of pizza. My a husband is a Pepperoni guy, so he had two slices of that and I had two slices of the Truffle oil mushroom pizza which I was told one of their popular ones with locals. They heated and soon enough we were called when it was ready. This pizza was hand down amazing! The crust was cooked perfectly and every bite you take makes you just want more. So glad the bell desk area recommended this place. It definitely left a lasting impression and now wished we had one in California. Highly recommend this place. You won't be disappointed.
Read More
Joseph T.
Sep 21, 2024
I had a grandma slice. Plump tomatoes in the sauce. Very generous on the Parmesan cheese. It was reheated but didn't quite have that crispness that I look for on a reheated slice. My favorite part was the basil. Quick service. $8 for the slice which they kindly cut in two.
Read More
Alison A.
Mar 14, 2024
Huge slices that are cut in half, making them perfect to share. The chicken Alfredo had a nice crisp to the bottom and plenty of meat. Overall they have many meat heavy and vegetarian options available
Read More
Maggie C.
Jul 30, 2024
My Pie probably has the best thin crusted pizza that is incredibly crispy with a variety of amazing toppings. I've always been hesitant about square pizzas, but when I tried their pesto pizza and pepperoni pizza, I was pleasantly surprised by how good they were. The slices come in two and are about $6.50 (for 2 squares). The interior space is on the smaller end, so not really a sit-down style restaurant, more of a quick bite/grab-and-go experience. The service is pretty quick, got my pizzas within 5 minutes of ordering. Hands down one of my favorite pizza shops in NYC!
Read More
Nando F.
Aug 25, 2023
Italian lady coworker deems this "the best pizza" she has had in NYC (and she has been living here for 40+ yrs). If you are a lover of "think crust" pizza... look no further. This place is it. I personally LOVE their truffle oil mushroom pizza. The place has very limited amount of seats (inside and outside). They claim they import all heir ingredients directly from Italy. The clerks behind the counter are nice enough. I don't give them all 5 stars b/c your experience with their pizza will be different if you are not ordering a fresh whole pie. At work, we have tried it a couple of times. If you walk in and order just a couple of slices... it just isn't as good. My crew at work agrees. It is worth noting that when you order by the slice... "one slice" is two (2) squares.
Read More
Joel S.
Aug 22, 2024
Swung by this hole in the wall Roman style pizzeria for lunch. This style of pizza will be on the upswing, because it can be cooked in a small electric oven. The space was very small with a couple of tables. Obviously designed for take out. The staff were very friendly. I tried a very good chicken harmonics and a disappointing pepperoni slice. I have come to the conclusion that Roman style pizza is my least favorite. This place is solidly OK, but I would greatly prefer Neapolitan or Sicilian pizza. With increased regulation over gas and a lower barrier to entry, places like this will become commonplace.
Read More
