Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn

From start to finish, one of the best Italian spots in Brooklyn perhaps even in NY. I'm sure every menu item is fantastic and there really are no wrong choices. From the apps to the pizzas to the desserts, all were amazing. Caracalla pizza and pistachio pinsa/tiramisu.The back space is perfect for a large family event and it was very baby friendly so definitely a plus. Quick attentive service. Nothing more you can ask for.

Cozy and full of charm, Montesacro is the perfect spot to gather with friends or a date. Don't be fooled by the small space when you first walk in, the garden space in the back is just as charming and beautiful as the front. The staff was attentive, friendly and helpful. We got the lattuga romana, carbonara, branzino, tiramisu, and hazelnut gelato. For drinks, we got the portia, farmacista, and a cappuccino. Everything was delicious. Some favorite bites/moments:- The depth of flavors and textures from the crunchy khorabi, the nicely charred artichoke and the lentils paired beautifully with the grilled branzino. 10/10! Highly recommend! - Shoutout to our server for asking if we wanted bread to soak up the leftover sauce from our carbonara. My love language! - The bits of hazelnut in hazelnut gelato. Next time I definitely want to try the salted caramel gelato. - The tiramisu - because coffee! It was light, not too sweet and had great coffee flavor. If montesacro isn't already on your list it needs to be. It's a whole mood. And if nothing else, get the branzino and the tiramisu, you wont regret it!

Ambiance is lovely; the garden seating in the back is covered and had a great vibe. Our wine was chosen for us and both options were perfect for each of us. We had the squash to start; I loved the honey but my friend found it too sweet. We had the beef tartare as well which was absolutely delicious. For mains we shared the recommended pizza (also had honey) and the carbonara. The pizza crust is light, sweet and delicious. Definitely memorable. Service was very attentive at the beginning of the meal and less so towards the end. We barely touched the carbonara and it still ended up on the bill.

My husband and I had an amazing dinner here! The pizza was absolutely delicious--fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. We'll definitely be back!

This is a great restaurant! If you get the avocado toast definitely add on the smoked salmon. It was delicious! I also had a margarita pizza that was well made and delicious. Ambience in the back or what they call the "garden" was really nice. Service was great.

Montesacro serves up some really good pizza in a cozy, vibey spot. It's perfect for date nights or an intimate dinner. Just know that the space is pretty tight, so expect to be close to your neighbors.The ambiance is super dark and moody, which adds to the charm, but it's definitely not the place for a big, loud group.Overall, great vibes and great pizza--would definitely recommend!

I went here for Valentine's Day with my boyfriend. It was decent - we never had pinseria style pizza before and it was very light and airy. I probably prefer regular Neapolitan style pizza but it was nice to try something new. We also had the Cacio e Pepe which was tasty. The portions were honestly a little small for the price. They had fun cocktails too, which we enjoyed The inside seating was super cool though. We were seated in the back and it felt like we were in a greenhouse - we really loved it. Also the service was very nice and quick. It was a good place to try and I had a good experience but maybe it wouldn't be my first choice to come back to.

Great atmosphere.Montesacro is really conveniently located by the subway station. Walking in, there's plenty of seating inside but also a beautiful outside area that feels like you're dining and drinking in a garden. The menu is a good size , so there's plenty to order from without feeling too overwhelmed. What I love about Montesacro is the quality of the ingredients - the pasta is house made drawn durum-wheat and the pizza is proofed for 72 hours.We ordered a variety of dishes from the menu from steak to octopus to salad to pasta and pizza. The food came pretty quickly and everything was well seasoned. Some dishes are bigger than others but in general the portions are a good size.The atmosphere is great for any setting so I'll definitely be back to check it out again.

unbelievable experience. the overall experience from the guest service to the quality of the food was outstanding. We each got a pasta and split the pizza (pinsa) - for the pizza we got the Casal Bertone. It was phenomenal and we will be returning just for that! Perfect balance of salty with the kick of sweetness of honey. Pasta was flavorful, and ending the night with the affogato dessert. will be coming back!

Stumbled upon this spot while in Brooklyn, really enjoyed it! Excellent atmosphere, attentive service and fantastic food. The menu is varied and we enjoyed that the vegan and vegetarian options are clearly shown. Would absolutely come back!