Montague Diner

Really excellent. The grilled cheese and tomato soup were so great, and the pancakes were perfect for our kids. (One order was more than enough for them.) We also loved the latkes.Probably a bit behind S&P on the new-ish diner list for me, but this was excellent in its own right.

You want nostalgia, good food, great service, and just a general vibe: come to Montague Diner.Drinks were refreshing to wash down some delicious diner classics. Also shoutout to whoever was on the AUX, unreal playlist that set the base to a lovely dining experience.

Honestly 10/10. I don't totally get the complaints about it not being a diner. I mean it's NYC, but it's also a much better / higher quality so it's expensive for a typical diner. But to me it definitely still has diner vibes. And standard things like a bacon, egg and cheese is cheap at $9 so you can get a cheaper meal if you want. The host is fantastic - calm, well organized, kind! And was like that with everyone we watched him interact with after we sat down. I don't know I feel like thats rare in NYC so wanted to mention! We waited 30 mins for 2 people on Sunday morning at 10am without a reservation. As we were eating and leaving, I heard the host saying two people would be closer to 45 mins without a reservation. As a heads up, we couldn't order the dinner menu at 10:30am which like may be assumed lol but my fiance wanted the giant grilled cheese so if you're going for that viral grilled cheese, can't get at breakfast. We split banana pancakes and the syrup was really good! I got the steak and eggs per another yelp review and honestly the steak was really fricken good!! Seasoned and marinated soooo well! My fiance got the smoked salmon plate which came with a good amount of salmon and very satisfying! Overall we really enjoyed it and can't wait to go back for lunch / dinner!

Very cool traditional diner vibe with a modern twist. I only got their hot chocolate to escape the biting cold that day. Unfortunately I paid 7 dollars for a very disappointing cup. I would come back to try their food.

Very charming throwback with booths ", vintage music & chef cred.Ate:Cup of tomato soupSide of veggies Total $15/lunchThey didn't have the hippie Sandy sadly or I would've ordered that. The soup & veggies were delectable and I will be back for the dinner specials.PS toilet sink should be repaired or replaced and paper towels were overflowing from garbage a restaurant turn off.

We made a rezzy for brunch Saturday at noon and our table was ready without any delay. The restaurant itself is sort of an updated, retro diner vibe, spacious, not super cramped, with small booths along one side and countertop seating on the other.The menu is stocked with standard diner dishes, and the ones we got were delicious. I got two eggs over easy with turkey, bacon, home fries, and toast while my husband got the steak and eggs with chimichurri sauce.My food was all cooked and seasoned well (some actually over easy eggs for once!) while my husband's steak was cooked perfectly and very well seasoned too. One of the best chimmichuri sauces I've had in a long time. His eggs were also exactly to order. Service was super efficient and friendly. I would absolutely visit again for another meal and look forward to doing so.

The pancakes are amazing!!! Really fluffy w a slight crisp. So delicious. Wld skip the cold brew - just drip over ice and quite watered down for me

Fantastic f**king cheeseburger. One of the best I've had in NYC since I've moved out here. I got the Montague Burger and I've been thinking about it for about a week now. The cook they got on my burger was quite impressive. Perfectly medium rare in the center with a perfectly seared crust on the outside. Cheese was perfectly melted, and the bacon was unreal. Fries were hot and crispy, but they are your standard battered fries. Still not bad at all, and I loved that they bundle the burgers with fries. For $22, it was a fantastic value. It's about the same price as the burger at Clark's down the road, but Montague has better hours and feels more like a trendy cocktail bar at night than a diner. I can't wait to try other menu items, but right now, I'm fixated on that burger.

I never write reviews,ever but I felt compelled to do so. I walked in and ordered something to take out. I was sitting at the counter for about 14 minutes when I noticed my order was in the kitchen window, the young vibrant staff was talking amongst themselves with a packed house about their weekends and the current series on TV they were watching didn't even offer me a glass of water, but I had to let them know that my order was sitting in the kitchen window waiting for me to take it. I don't know why I was treated this way. It was like I was invisible, but they certainly all knew that I was waiting there. They were way too cool to help me I guess. It looks like a great place, and would have liked to actually sat down for a meal at some point .

Outstanding customer service, cool atmosphere and gluten free options! glad we came across it and would come again!