Margherita NYC
Ham, artichoke, and black olives and a white garlic sauce prosciutto and mushroom
a close up of a pizza
a hand holding a piece of margherita
a person dipping a piece of margherita into a bowl
a close up of a hand holding a fork with a piece of margherita on it
a plate of shrimp and pasta
a variety of seafood dishes
Front of the Margherita restaurant.
a variety of seafood dishes
drink
food
drink
food, pasta, pasta dish
Gnocchi Bolognese - $18...? Over priced under portioned
food, dessert
food, tacos
pizza, food
pizza, food
food, pizza
Pepsi $2.50 San pellegrino $3.50
pasta, pasta dish, food
jake w.
Sep 18, 2024
disappointing food, server with long hair was extremely rude. Left after eating and came back about thirty mins later since we were walking around the area and my wife had to use the restroom ( she's pregnant so we had to stop somewhere quick and decided since we already ate here it wouldn't be a problem ) and he told her she can use the restroom then came around while she was waiting and denied her entry to the restroom.
Read More
Nian Z.
Jun 30, 2019
First burrata experience here! Soo good. Could've easily gone for a second order of that. Very creamy and salty and deliciousSeems to be only one waitress for the entire restaurant that night, so service was pretty slow and inattentive, but at least the food came out alarmingly fast.Overall, pizza toppings were delicious, but the ones with more toppings made the crust more soggy. Crust definitely needs a lot more work to be able to hold everything up better!
Read More
Guido V.
Jun 12, 2018
Came here in November of 17' and didn't review... now in June of 18', after two visits the vote is in - meh to meh -.On this visit - ordered the Regina Margherita pizza and the gnocchi bolognese.The pizza was crust was fine initially with some char and bubble, but the toppings, basil, the cheeses, the cherry tomatoes... totally like they were just thrown on prior to serving - Totally raw, no char, net even close to being melted or cooked. Sent it back for more heat. Fair. Sauce missing acidity... just wet and red with little flavor IMHO. Little flavor in the crust as well.The Gnocchi was over cooked and way mushy and wet. There was very little sauce and it tasted hurried and flat... very saucy tasting, not thick, little meat or sauce at all. It looked like it was tossed in some liquid of the sauce to coat, and then only garnished with a scant spoonful of meatPretty big let down considering the local and home field advantage.
Read More
Nicole P.
Nov 22, 2021
Just across the street from the "Welcome to Little Italy" sign, my mom, daughter and I were looking for a good pizza place for dinner. As we looked at the menu, the owner/manager (he told me his name and I forgot sadly) came up to greet us. "If you don't like it you don't pay" - that's my kind of owner! And there was no way we weren't paying because the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely an authentic little Italy experience for my daughter's first visit to NYC! Highly recommend.
Read More
Nicki K.
Aug 4, 2019
I have a Yelp friend tell me Yelp failed him when he went to visit Philly. I feel the same way as I used Yelp in LIttle Italy.In my mind, I wanted more small eats so I could enjoy the rest of the day and grub and go.Watch your step when you go inside Margherita. It's a little uphill.Service sucks. We never felt welcome. It's more like they were annoyed with us. My friend really likes Italian food so this was her call.For example, the waiter who was "helping" us took our order and left and never came back. No explanation from anyone. My friend's calzone never came out and took forever. She almost wanted to say forget it but they kept insisting that they were still cooking it. Bullcrap. we been finished with our food.I ordered eggplant parmesan and it wasn't even that good, very plain. The calzone wasn't too salty and my friend didn't like. We ended up throwing most of our food away. She did order calamari too and liked it. Cannot go wrong with fried food.I'm just very disappointed with Little Italy in general. And Yelp for giving us false advertisement.165/2019
Read More
Noor Bint J.
Dec 2, 2019
Imagine walking in NYC during a cold, rainy day. You're literally freezing. You pass by a pizza shop and decide to go in. It's cramp but cozy. They sit you by the pizza oven so the warmth is reaching you. You decide to buy a simply Margherita pizza. You can a bite the crust is so soft. The pizza tastes delicious . You eat it within 5 minutes. For desert, you decide to try the Nutella pizza. It's pretty heavy so you end up eating one slice. But each bite of that slice was worth it. Then the bill comes and you're shocked at how reasonable the price is.This was my experience at this amazing pizza joint. Recommend:
Read More
Ashton R.
Oct 6, 2022
In town from Texas for NYCC. Best New York pizza experience yet. Owner was amazing and staff was very friendly!
Read More
Christina C.
Feb 26, 2018
The restaurant itself is really cute and the dim lighting makes it perfect for date night. When we ate here we were the only customers in the place. Our waiter was really nice and the food was brought out so fast. All we tried was the prosciutto and mushroom pie. I really wasn't impressed. The sauce was so watery and the pie itself was very soft/soggy. Kind of disappointing...
Read More
Heather S.
Feb 26, 2020
It's a small place that gets pretty filled real quick but it's worth the wait. You have to come here early or on an off day in order to get a table. Their pizzas are simple but delicious and their sandwich is not like any other sandwich I've ever had. They use their pizza dough as their bread and i was a bit skeptical at first but once I got it (I asked them to add sweet peppers and balsamic), I was on cloud 9. Great place, not touristy - I hope it stays that way!
Read More
Dennis M.
Feb 22, 2023
Great place to eat and spend time with friends. Staff is very friendly and attentive. Drink drinks loved the fig and prosciutto pizza.
Read More
