Maggie Reillys Restaurant
Maggie Reillys Restaurant
Reilly's Shepards Pie
Guinness beef stew
a fire hydrant on the sidewalk
Espresso martini
Jorge's awesome pork chop
the menu for the restaurant
Specials
Mac and Cheese with Bacon
Traditional Fish and Chips
12 oz. New York Strip Steak
pork chop - special menu
Menu 2022
a man sitting at a table
a pint of guinness and a drink
a can of wild berries
Maggie lager
menu
sushi and sashimi, interior
burgers, burger, food
Bar
The tap!!
drink
Ingrid S.
Jul 30, 2024
It's kind of a cute little Irish pub off the beaten path in Chelsea. Drinks are a few bucks cheaper here than along 7th and 8th avenue. The vibe is nice and neighborly and not grimy like some other dives. Not sure if they have a happy hour but noticed their house ale is only $6 a pint and $18 a pitcher. Most of their fancy cocktails are under $13-14, which is sad that that's a deal these days. Watched some food dishes pass by the kitchen counter window. Their burger, shepherds pie, and mac and cheese looked pretty solid. Would be tempted to try their food some day. Definitely will check the spot out again.
Read More
Sherry W.
Dec 31, 2023
It's a usual hangout spot for the locals. Our colleagues come here weekly and often with some coming every few days after work. Great beers on tap and large section of drinks. Great food too (for a bar). My colleagues took up the entire back corner, pulled various tables together and congulated to the outside area as well. We are a loud happy bunch with some singing involved.
Read More
Maddi K.
Jul 12, 2024
What a 10/10 establishment honestly Excellent staff, great service, drinks - would highly recommend!! Thanks Maddie!!
Read More
Gregg J.
Aug 3, 2023
Buddy and I stopped in here yesterday. We have our favorite spots near MSG but opted for a change. Service - excellent. Marcus behind the bar and his teammates were all awesome! Friendly service - they made us feel like regulars during our first visit. Food - the Cobb salad I had was delicious. Fresh ingredients and my buddy really enjoyed his fish and chips. Thanks for a nice evening! See you soon!
Read More
Elizabeth C.
Nov 20, 2023
What a fun little hole in the wall to stumble upon. We went to the edge and needed crowd pleasing food. This fit the bill. I felt transported back to Europe by the sassy Irish bartender and the hearty food. Perfect ambiance of a pub, even had a jukebox! We had kids and there were no food complaints (parents know what a miracle this is!) Husbands chicken curry was a miss, but still ok. All in all a good spot. Would definitely go again.
Read More
Sarah T.
Jan 15, 2024
Great service and ambiance. Cozy when cold and a small outdoor area out back when warm. It seems to always be full but never packed. Guinness flows and the food is solid. Plus the owner is an absolute genuine and hard working person.
Read More
Shandy M.
Jan 22, 2025
great time - great people drinks and food! if I could give 10 stars I would ! The owner goes above and beyond!
Read More
Andrew M.
Nov 30, 2024
Went here for dinner last weekend.Friendly server. Cheerful place.Good hamburger.Nice and attractive crowd!
Read More
Brittany S.
Jan 10, 2025
Amazing staff, and even better location. Food was great and drinks even better. Loved that is was so near Hudson Yards
Read More
Fuqing S.
Sep 10, 2024
I would never recommend its NY strip steak. I asked for medium, but it's absolutely over cooked with lots of charred parts. But the chef insisted that be the right way. If you use credit card, extra 3% will be charged! Totally Speechless!
Read More
