Made in New York Pizza

Cute interior, a nice mix of regular and standing tables, friendly service, and EXCELLENT pizza! Seriously, I am in love with this place. The grandma slice crust is perfectly crisp and not too thick, the cheese is soft and flavorful, and their house-made, slow-cooked sauce is a thing of beauty. I will definitely try to make it through all of their slices.

I am a born and raised New Yorker that loves pizza.That being said this place is not it.I ordered the vodka roni square, and it was flavorless. I went to buy a water too it was $3.25!! A bottle of water costing half the price of the slice? No thank you. Square was about $6.50.The guy at the counter kind of rude, told me to put the water back if I didn't want it.It wasn't the worst pizza but there are so many better options taste and price wise in the city and the neighborhood.Also the place is super hot inside, couldn't bare more than 2 minutes in there.

I really feel like this place does not get the hype it deserves. Stumbled in here one night after a few drinks because it was nearby and open. I can't remember the exact names of the slices, but check out the photo to see which ones I recommend. The crust is crispy and sturdy (none of that mushy/bendy crap) and the sauce was fresh and flavourful. Highly recommend.

My husband liked the spicy pepperoni pizza here but I was not a fan. It was $11 for two square pizzas and $2.75 for a bottle of Poland spring water. The texture of the dough was okay but it was too spicy for me and the pepperoni wasn't as good as some other places (eg Prince Street and Village Square) - some pieces did not curl up. Also the service was lackluster - only one guy was working the whole time and he was pretty slow to take anyone's order. I did appreciate they had two high top tables and a couple stools so we could eat inside. Overall, was a bit disappointed given the rave reviews. Walk a few blocks more over to Village Square!

Had to grab a slice (or two) of pizza here after leaving a tequila pop up not too long ago while strolling by in the neighborhood. Was so hungry and eager to gobble up all those bigger-than-my-face slices of pizza in front of me since the prior event hardly served any bites. This is mostly a grab-to-go instead of a sit-down kind of place but does have several bar height tables and bar stools made out of metal. Some tables can be wobbly and uneven but customers usually don't mind since this place is mostly for quick bites. You get the food, you eat and then you leave. Simple as that. Pretty fast and friendly service from the staff as they pop the pre-made slides into the oven to toast and heat them up. Sorry, mate....no restroom there. They accept cash and/or credit/debit card as forms of payment. Your food will be ready in less than 5 minutes. I think this spot would be a good option as hangover food because they open pretty late until 2am on some nights. As I've mentioned before, these pizza are bigger-than-my-face kind of slices. It would've been fun to see if I could actually hide behind them. But, I didn't want the oil to drip onto my face and become a real grease ball lol. Ambiance wise is pretty cool with a NY History themed collage/wall displaying colorful posters, Broadway playbills, and stickers plus a huge mural with graffiti covering the floor to give off more personality, more style and more creativity to the place. The atmosphere and vibes are stunning for the visuals, reminding me of hip hop culture in a way. The decor makes me feel welcoming since it doesn't just look like your typical/local pizzeria, it actually stands out from the rest solely of that main reason! Now onto the mushroom and sausage slices, they're both bigger (size wise) in comparison to my face of course. I normally don't order two slices but didn't come all the way from Queens either just to eat a plain slice.....that's for sure! Besides, I was super hungry on that day. The sausage slice was still crispy even though I'd already finished 2/3 of it. As for the mushroom, I was slightly disappointed by the texture because it became pretty soggy from having all the mushroom slices spread out on the pizza. Couldn't withstand the hold while being held like a normal slice.....became a messy blob of sogginess and then fell apart altogether in the end.On a side note, I was trying to see what the place was called and didn't know/realize until seeing the huge "Made In New York Pizza" logo from the display window when I was getting ready to leave. I only thought they were just advertising that their pizza is made in NYC lol. Basically, it pretty much didn't hit me until I was actually standing to take pics of the entire storefront. So, I thought that was kinda funny.- My Conclusion:Not the best pizza I've had eaten but certainly not the worst either. Would go back again if I happen to be in the West Village area next time.

A new-ish little hole in the wall in the west village. There were lots of choices for slices. I got a white slice. Nice that they really served the slices hot hot. I would have preferred a little less garlic on my slice, but still, it hit the spot.

Always tasty, always reliable. My favorite is the big pepperoni slice. Only limited standing tables.

The spicy pepperoni square slice was a good bite. The crust was good and crunchy and the cup pepperoni had a good bite to it. Could have been reheated a bit more and could also have gotten a little better scald on that pepperoni. Still a good spicy piece of pizza. The plain slice, on the other hand, was just kind of meh. Nothing objectionable but certainly would just stick with the spicy pepperoni square and call it a day. There are a few better options for this in the city but it is still pretty good.

Great late night pizza spot in the west village! I came here on a Saturday night and thankfully it wasn't a long wait and the pizza came out hot and delicious. I got a pepperoni slice and it was very filling and felt fresh and a perfect temp. Highly recommend if you're looking for a quick spot for a good slice of pizza on a night out.

Best service and pizza in the area. Much more flavorful than John's pizza. Sicilian is soooo good. Spicy grandmas is very tasty.