Made In New York Pizza
Made In New York Pizza
Spicy Pepperoni Square and Cheese Slice
Cheese Slice and Spicy Pepperoni Square
pizza, food
Do The Right Thing
Sicilian Eggplant
M.I.N.Y. Pizza
Wall Menu
NY History Wall
It was actually banging that supreme slice is everything
Pizza To Go
Classic Margherita Pie
Pizza Slice Selection
White & Hawaiian.
Made In New York Pizza
Buffalo chicken slice
Eggplant Square etc...
pizza, food
pizza, interior
Made in New York!
Sicilian etc...
Inside
White Slice
Pepperoni slice
Sabrina S.
Sep 21, 2024
Tasty! Visiting NY and needed some pizza door dashed to the hotel. Can't comment on the actual restaurant, ambiance or service but the food is what counts the most. I loved how I could get ALL slices so we could taste many kinds. The bacon ranch was my favorite but the pepperoni with burrata was also amazing. Excellent pizza and big slices.
Read More
Sabrina C.
Jan 23, 2025
These two were definitely a great combo. I had to get pizza because I was on my way back home to VA. They don't make pizza like NY does. Took off a star because I told him I wanted it well toasted twice. Both slices still came out a little warm and still on the cold side. He literally popped it in the oven for less than 2minutes. Other than that, both slices were amazing !!
Read More
Steph Y.
Jun 23, 2024
Made in Pizza NYC is a must-visit for a delicious slice of pizza. Their thin, crispy crust sets them apart from other spots in the city, and the cleanliness is top-notch. During this heatwave, the air conditioning that they provide is a nice relief. The service is quick, and there are plenty of tables to sit and enjoy your meal. I usually opt for the pepperoni, but the buffalo chicken caught my eye this time. I'm glad I tried it because it was very delicious and hit the spot.
Read More
Daniel Y.
May 27, 2024
Walk in to see the large selection of ready made pies on display, don't see it just ask they keep some underneath the display.Choose you slices and they heated them up in the oven.It's a tiny place but they do some great NY style pizza There is no frills but just good pizza fast.Delicious! This was a great find.
Read More
Zach C.
May 10, 2024
Excellent pizza in the Times Square vicinity. We got the buffalo chicken, vodka and sausage slices. Service was standard and there was a small dining room.
Read More
Veronica G.
Feb 27, 2024
The crust was crispy. The slices were large. I tried the "salad" pizza which had onions, lettuce, tomatoes, bell peppers, and olives with a little bit of sauce and a little bit of cheese. The slice was served with a packet of Italian dressing. It was really good! I also tried the ham and pineapple slice. My colleague had a slice of the pepperoni sausage and she said it was kind of dry.The service was quick. The restaurant was clean. I enjoyed the aroma of garlic, pepperoni, and the pizza oven. I would eat here again.
Read More
Jo W.
Jan 3, 2024
Stopped by in here for a quick lunch and taking a break from shopping and walking around in garment district hunting for fabrics, and also to escape the rainstorm that came pouring down. I got a chicken roll and veggie pizza. When I asked for water, what I meant was a complimentary cup to drink water. Instead, they charged me for a water bottle, which was NOT what I wanted. It was empty when I came in, and it became PACKED after I ordered and while I was eating my lunch.
Read More
Lynne S.
Dec 25, 2023
Absolutely outstanding !!! YUMMY PIZZA, cool spot and great service!! Loved the ambience too with the old school music pumping in the background! I had the BBQ chicken slice and it was SOOOOO GOOD!!! So worth the $5.50 for a slice ! The pepperoni slice looked amazing too and was so good too!!!
Read More
Tracy C.
Nov 2, 2023
Super loud club music at 11 am and I was all for it as I was on vacation. I asked if I could get a slice or a pie and I got such a NY answer, "sure, we can do whatever you want".The pizza was AMAZINGCrispy crust and tasty sauce with fresh, I mean FRESH, basil leaves on top, all toasted up to perfection.Seriously a top notch place.Did not see bathrooms, so can't comment on those.
Read More
Judith T.
Nov 30, 2024
We passed by and the smell brought us in. Had the Buffalo chicken pizza while my friends had the pepperoni slice and the spicy pepperoni square. We all thoroughly enjoyed the pizza which was flavorful and the crust was crunchy.
Read More
