Made In New York Pizza

This pizza spot is bomb!I came here for lunch yesterday and the slice with extra cheese and pepperoni that I had with the garlic knots were everything!This spot is massive and they have all types of pizza. The staff is also so friendly and helpful.My slice was large, they didn't go cheap on the extra cheese and the garlic knots were simply perfect!We paid 17.15$ for two slices and a an order of garlic knots.I would definitely come back to try a Sicilian slice.Thank you Made in New York Pizza!See you soon.

This Made in New York pizza on Amsterdam Avenue is cozy and friendly. I had a malfunction with my credit card, and a cashier named Miguel was patient enough to assist me. His kindness is an example of great customer service. The pizza had a very sharp cheese taste; whatever blend my pepperoni slice had, it was good. The pizza was crispy and well-cooked. And for five dollars, it is quite good.

While exploring New York City, we stumbled upon what I can confidently call one of the best spots for New York-style pizza, located just a short walk from Central Park. The place offers both round and square pizzas, catering to every craving with variety and depth in flavor. I couldn't resist buying a few different slices, and each one had its unique charm and perfect execution. I tried classic Pepperoni, earthy Mushroom, fresh Margherita, spicy Buffalo Chicken, a traditional Grandma, and an Eggplant Sicilian slice. Each had its own character, from the crisp crust to the gooey cheese and perfectly balanced sauce. The eggplant one is truly an innovative one! Never had one before! This place even offers gluten-free personal pies.The combination of cheese and sauce on these pizzas was phenomenal, making every bite feel like a burst of flavors. The staffs behind the counter was friendly, engaging, and shared great conversation, adding a personal touch to the experience. Another big plus is their fast-paced service. Their efficiency was impressive, given how busy the spot was.Finding a table was a challenge, as the place was absolutely packed - a testament to its popularity and quality. If you're lucky enough to snag a seat, it's the perfect place to sit back and soak in the bustling New York vibe over a slice or two. This pizza haven has now become a must-visit in my book, and I'd gladly return on my next trip to NYC. If you're in the area, I highly recommend it for a truly authentic New York pizza experience that captures the city's spirit in every slice!

This pizza spot was walking distance to our hotel (the Lucerne) and had delicious pizza. We had the Roma, pepperoni & my husband was in love with the upside down pizza. The service was fast and it was a small shop for a quick in and out bite to eat. I definitely recommend if you are in the area.

Really really good pizza here. Get a slice in no time. Highly recommend the spicy pepperoni but plain cheese slaps too. Close to the Museum of Natural History and Central Park.

Hands down the best pizza I've ever had. A short walk from the Museum of Natural History, and long line, but it moves quickly. The pepperoni was by far our favorite, but we also loved the white spinach pizza, the chicken buffalo, and the margherita.

Yummy and quick! The square pepperoni had quite a bit of spicy peps on it and it was a bit thicker than we are used to but my husband still enjoyed it. The buffalo chicken slice was the perfect amount of buffalo and ranch. If you're looking for a quick bite not too far from Times Square then this is the place!

Good pizza. It was billed as New York style pizza, which I have no way of verifying. :) we thought the pizza was tasty. It was very greasy so be forewarned if that's something you don't care for. The restaurant was very crowded, and they did a good job of serving people quickly and moving them through the line. The food and atmosphere are family friendly. My kids enjoyed their meal, and I could see a lot of other families enjoying themselves. They didn't mind the weight because it was fun looking at the pizza through the window.

Very good pizza. It's a casual place and they also have outdoor seating. I really enjoyed my meal. They also sell alcoholic beverages.

I ordered a large two-topping pizza from Made in New York Pizza through Slice for $41. When I arrived at the scheduled pickup time, the restaurant claimed they never received my order.I contacted Slice, who told me the money goes directly to Made in New York Pizza, meaning Slice can't issue a refund--only the restaurant can. However, despite Slice confirming that the money was sent, Made in New York Pizza refused to refund me, insisting they never received it. So, in the end, I paid $41 for nothing, with both parties refusing to take responsibility.This feels like a scam, and I'd strongly advise against ordering from here (or using Slice) unless you want to risk paying for a pizza you'll never get.