J's Pizza

Haven't been to J's in over 20 years, mostly because its slices were OK compared to my go-to excellent pizza places in town. Am happy to see this "old school" place still in business considering how many places have been pushed out due to increasing commercial rent.Decided to go for a plain slice for my "reunion" with this pizzeria. It was a tad still chewy for my tastes, with not as flavorful as those 5-star places elsewhere in town - I need that thin crispy crust on a Neapolitan slice. However, if you're in the neighborhood requiring a reasonably priced slice after a few or more drinks, then J's likely meets your job requirements!Given the great pizza options available all over, as a native New Yorker pizza person, while it beats the $1/$1.50 junk slice places it'll be some time until I return there for any pizza. That being said, I might try out J's another time when passing by and hungry - however for something other than their pizza like a Hero, Stromboli or Calzone. Lmk if you have recommendations.

Great pizza, lots of choices. No frills, but good stuff. People were cool and the price was right.

Very good pizza. Ask for it extra crispy if you want to fold it. Garlic knots were ok, did not have a lot of the garlic and butter sauce but pizza was excellent

I really liked their NY Slice Pizza, What truly sets them apart is their mastery of the perfect slice - crispy crust, cheese, and a tangy sauce and the best part? No flop in sight! Each bite is a delight, with no soggy disappointments. NY Slice Pizza has won me over, and I can't wait to go back for more.

I dropped by here late on a Saturday evening to grab a snack. Ordering was quick and easy as it wasn't busy and there was someone at the counter. I ordered a spinach cheese roll and a cheese slice. Both items were cheesy goodness. Everything was reheated in about 5 minutes. I would definitely come back when in the area.

Mind the three-quarters eaten Cheese Slice because I was so hungry and past desperate for something that fit my budget, yet filling enough to get me home on my one and a half hour commute without feeling hungry again. I found the place quick on Apple Maps. Sorry not sorry Yelp. I did look up the photos, menu, and reviews on Yelp though. Oh, as for the pizza slice? It is delicious! I love the texture and thickness; crispy and not too doughy and not too thin. I'm feeling awake enough to now go enjoy the rest of my evening today. I'm one Happy pizza lover!

A local's spot with good prices. Very thin crust. Cheap meats. Depressing lack of variety for dinner. Among the worst variety I've seen. Almost walked out but I gave it a shot and it was decent. Accepts cards.

Great slice. Not too greasy. They grate their own cheese which means something. Feels like NYC.

Pizza is always fresh and fast service! Our go-to place in the west village. They also have good garlic knots.

the pizza is great. The service is excellent. I always get the cheese slice. It's warm and delicious