Joe & John's Pizzeria
Joe & John's Pizzeria
White slice
Margherita slice
Regular slice
Crumble sausage over broccoli rabe square
Pepperoni square
Hawaiian square
Cacio e pepe square
Chicken bacon slice
Pizzaaaaaa
Fogliatlelle Pastry with custard & orange zest
Mushroom & caramelized onion square
a variety of pizzas
Kimbo espresso
CAESAR SLICE
Pepperoni square Hot home available upon request
interior
Arancini
a slice of pepperoni pizza
Eggplant parm square
Cacio e pepe
Pepperoni roll
Burger and clams oreganata
Int
Caramelized onion and mushroom
Louis G.
Oct 23, 2024
Display is crystal clear with tons of options.... Customer service always pleasant; ice cold refreshments Coffee and dessert to close the evening....Natural light for the perfect ambience; Enjoy!
Read More
Annie V.
Aug 25, 2024
The Pizzeria That's Turning Heads in the Neighborhood!When a slice of pizza makes you feel like you're biting into a masterpiece, you know you've hit the jackpot. And that's exactly what I found at this newly revamped pizzeria--an absolute gem that's quickly become a neighborhood staple. Here's the lowdown on my recent tasting spree:Cacio e Pepe Slice - Imagine your favorite Cacio e Pepe pasta, but with a perfectly crispy bottom that adds that extra crunch we all crave. It's savory, indulgent, and oh-so-delicious. Now, full disclosure--it did lean a bit on the cheesy side for me, but if you're a cheese enthusiast, this slice might just become your new obsession. Either way, it's a mouthful of yum that's worth every bite.Chicken and Broccoli Slice - Let's talk classics! This slice is your go-to when you're in the mood for something that balances flavor and nutrition. With a generous distribution of chicken cutlet and fresh broccoli, it's a perfect choice if you're looking to satisfy your hunger while sneaking in some protein and veggies. It's simple, it's delicious, and it hits the spot every single time.Chicken Vodka Garlic Bread Sandwich - Now, here's where things get interesting. The first time I sank my teeth into this sandwich, it was a flavor explosion--rich, savory, and downright unforgettable. But, on my latest visit, it fell a bit short. The once-perfect sandwich was disappointingly dry, with barely any vodka sauce and a sparse sprinkle of garlic on top. It's heartbreaking to see a favorite lose its consistency, but I'm hopeful this was just an off day. Fingers crossed for a return to greatness!Overall Vibe - I've got to hand it to Sal and the team--what they've done with this place is nothing short of incredible. The expansion and renovation have transformed it into a beautiful, modern space that feels as good as the food tastes. This pizzeria is doing things right, and despite the occasional hiccup, it's still a top contender in my book. The service is always friendly and expeditious. So, next time you're in the area, swing by and grab a slice (or three).
Read More
Heather M.
Feb 7, 2025
We order from here once a week - usually Fridays when we have pizza and movie night for our boys. Food is always excellent and delivery is fast and accurate. Tonight something went wrong and we got a small pie instead of a large (we did order a second small pie that arrived as ordered). Delivery driver was polite and apologized and when I called the restaurant they were also so nice. The owner personally delivered a replacement pie hot and perfect 10 minutes later. They also let us keep the small pie which was actually delicious. Five stars for food and customer service. Will continue our weekly routine!
Read More
Krista M.
Dec 17, 2023
We decided to enjoy the nice weather yesterday and take a ride to Ridgewood. We started out at Joe and John's Pizza on Myrtle. The place was hopping, a constant flow of people with a lovely welcoming staff. The counter was loaded with a wide variety of pizzas. We opted for 2 square slices, cacio e pepe and caramelized onion with mushrooms plus a regular slice. The cacio e pepe was a surprising delight, unique and delicious. The onion and mushroom was excellent and the regular slice was nice and thin with a great fresh flavor.I was super impressed with the pizza it was all excellent without being overly salty. They are even in the process of expanding into next store to open more of a sit down cafe.I can't t wait to go back and try more items.
Read More
Alma V.
Jul 28, 2024
I ordered directly to the restaurant and I specifically said that I need the driver to come up because I have a baby with me. The driver called and argued with me stating that he couldn't come up because he had other deliveries to drop off. The scampi was scattered all over and the aluminum plate was crushed, and the house salad was completely destroyed. I called to see if i could get a new salad but they refused to send one. I end up throwing the salad out, it looked so gross.
Read More
Lora R.
Apr 15, 2024
Did a drive-by on Saturday after dreaming of eating pizza the night before. Everything looked so delicious but I settled on three slices, two Sicilian and one regular. I asked to have all sliced in half so I could share them with my bestie. The first slice was a Sicilian mushroom and onion slice. The flavors were good, but sort of muted by the overabundance of sautéed onions which also made the sliced kind of greasy. The second slice was also Sicilian with a vodka sauce. Bestie and I enjoyed this one a lot. She informed me that she usually does not enjoy vodka sauce, but this was a good one.Lastly, I indulged in the regular slice, which was authentic, New York pizza and brought back memories from my childhood. It's hard to find a slice that makes me feel like that. Overall, I would return and sample other pizzas, as well as the pastas and that delicious looking chicken vodka Parm sandwich that was on display. The pizzeria is pretty large and open. The staff all had great vibes and I was happy to see that I can order on Uber Eats.
Read More
Edgardo Z.
Dec 6, 2024
So funny enough I stopped here for a slice before heading out to my boy's crib in the area after I got off the train. I hadn't eaten all day so needed something in my stomach before we started drinking. Threw back two solid slices and kept it moving. Got to my boy's spot and did what was planned then after a few hours of drinking and having a good time he decided to order some pizza and of course Joe & John's pizza boxes come in through the door. The look of fulfillment in my eyes couldn't emphasize what I already knew I was getting myself into. About six more slices in, I was good to go and could barely move. I'm sure the alchohol helped the cause but that pizza was solid regardless. Keep in mind I previously had two slices sober so that should mean something lol.
Read More
Prairie P.
Sep 10, 2024
This place is the best. Pizza is so good but dont forget about their pasta dishes! Seriously delicious
Read More
Melissa T.
Jul 19, 2024
I know this place is good but the Italian hero was not really how I pictured it to be. The ingredients say fresh mozzarella but it looks like deli sliced boars head to me... I also didn't ask for it to be toasted and my sandwich came hot. Kinda disappointed. I guess I would've been better off going in person and placing the order to make sure it was going to be made how it was written in the description.
Read More
Daniel F.
Nov 15, 2024
I've ordered from the Joe & John's over the phone for pickup many times in the past and so I figured I'd step in to the pizzeria to physically place an order for the first time. I went to get a slice and a salad and I ended up leaving left empty-handed 50 minutes later. It was around the dinner rush so I get that things get hectic but I checked in with the cashier twice on the status of my order and both times was assured it was on its way. It was only when I went to cancel my order that they finally acknowledged me, resulting in one of the employees asking me to wait a bit longer for them to rush by order. From this experience it seems they prioritize their takeout orders far more than anything/anyone else and as someone who has worked in food service before, after seeing how there were no attempts to go above and beyond to make the situation right and just a half-hearted apology, I won't be giving them my business ever again.
Read More
