Il Tinello

We wanted to find a nice Italian restaurant near the hotel and this looked really good.It was great seeing the staff dressed formally, and it set the tone for the terrific service that ensued. We had the Caesar salad prepared at table, and also a calamari appetizer. Both were excellent. The calamari didn't have that typical rubber taste and texture, and it tasted more breaded than fried.The Caesar salad dressing was excellent, and it wasn't too garlicky.I had a lobster ravioli special, which was excellent, and my trusty companion had the gnocchi. For dessert, we had the pistachio cheesecake and the tartufo.Everything was fantastic and next time I'm in this part of the city, I would definitely stop back again. It's a nice intimate setting.

I've been to many Italian restaurants around the world and never had a waiter so annoyed at us, for seemingly no reason. While the rest of the staff was incredibly kind, including a gentleman who I assume was the owner, the main waiter here on this particular Thursday night was extremely cold and terribly rude. I ordered the Il Tinello soup and said happily, "Oh, it's named after the restaurant!" and he stared just stared at me, as if to say "Who cares?" We ordered that soup, the (50 dollar) Caesar for two, coffee, drinks and he said "....And your entree?" When we said that's all we wanted, he said "You HAVE to ORDER AN ENTRE," like he was reprimanding us. I almost walked out. I said, "But that's all we want," and he repeated that, as if I was a naughty child. I said, "We can just leave." He said, let me check with the owner and walked away. The coffee came but we turned it away, we didn't know if we were about to be kicked out. He eventually came back, said it was fine and we never saw him for the rest of the night. Having said that, the food was incredible.

The service was 11/10The food was absolutely delicious.The Burrata was what we ordered for an appetizer. It was so creamy and that night it's came with sweet pineapple slices. That mixture of sweet and cream truly made it unique and spectacular. The vibe is classy. Great for anything from a family dinner, date night, or dinner with clients. The Cacio e Pepe was made in front of you and was a 9/10

This is the best Neighborhood Restaurant a true hidden jewels in midtown .You are lucky if you find a table. I recommend calling and making reservation for dinner for 2 or more.Food is delicius and service is even better the owner very welcoming and friendly .The bartender made my night special form my birthday .

I got recommended from a friend and been to this restaurant 4 times over a month. I tried different appetizers, entrees and everything is delicious. The service was excellent from bartender to waiters. Great spot to bring a date or family. As soon as you walk in the door you get greeted by the owner Benny feeling like you're family and home. Always taking care of the customers. This restaurant is must try. Excellent restaurant Benny!

At my friend's request for a long overdue catch up at an Italian restaurant, I recommend that we visit Il Tinello since it was on my to visit list. I made a reservation on the website, arrived at exactly 6:30pm, was well greeted and quickly sat down at our table.Within few minutes the waiter was at the table taking our drink order and brought us fresh bread, on the house a portion of bruschetta and a plate of marinated eggplant & hot peppers.The place is quaint, modern, clean and fairly classic Italian decor. The atmosphere was quiet which was nice to talk but it did get lost as the night went on (almost too loud).My friend & I decided to share everything because we wanted the table made cacio e pepe pasta but also protein which we ended deciding on veal parm. The atmosphere was vibrant and we just enjoyed our conversation as we watch the waiter prepare our pasta then served us. I would admit that it is not your typical cacio e pepe, it has a lot more ingredients and richer than your typical version, but very tasty and creamy. The veal parm was up to the standard! Very tender and light. I do confess that I had to add salt and ask for black pepper to add more flavor.All in all, a very delightful and delicious experience. Definitely would go back!

One of the best kept secrets in midtown. Delicious food and service is on point. The owner makes you feel like family. The cacio e Pepe and shrimp arrabbiata are off the charts. Definitely coming back.

Had a great dinner here this evening! Appetizers included bruschetta and some peppers (which were quite spicy but good). Got the carpaccio and it was great - loved the simple lemon flavor with the arugula and cheese. I got the rigatoni, and thought it was great!! It's like an eggplant parmesan flavor but in pasta form, 7.5/10 (just wish there was more!). My partner got the mushroom risotto and also loved it, rating it 8/10. Ambiance was great, service was amazing! House Montepulciano was great, and they make good cocktails too!

You'll never be disappointed here. 10/10 meal, 10/10 staff & fabulous vibes.Don't forget to order amazing wine... & I'm obsessed with all their pasta dishes!

I was so looking forward to a beautiful birthday dinner there. Unfortunately it started out very stressful, when I was locked inside the stall of the bathroom. Yes first time ever. The lock was jammed, and no one else was inside and I did not have my cell phone. I reported it to the restaurant owner as I didn't want anyone else to experience it.We both ordered the same dish, the special lobster fra diavalo, salad and mushroom soup. The lobster dish was very substandard on both plates. The mushroom soup wasn't too flavorful either. We accepted our fate, and didn't want to complain after the bathroom incident. The owner offered an after dinner drink.The waiter was as nice as could be. There are enough Italian restaurants in the city beside this one to choose.