Hilltop Tavern

I love love Hamilton so I couldn't wait to try Hilltop Tavern the next time I was home. Such a cute and cozy vibe. I love the rectory benches. We tried the brunch menu. Delicious! The corned beef hash was flavorful, not salty and the kind of comfort food that will keep you coming back. The poached egg hollandaise with smoked salmon is another winner in my book. They don't serve spirits but they are so creative with the cocktail menu! If you're in the area, definitely add this place to your brunch bucket list! The staff is also welcoming and helpful!

A great addition to the neighborhood! I was pleasantly surprised when I tried this new spot the other night. We had one dish from the menu (shrimp & grits) and a special (cod)--both of which were delicious! Perfectly prepared, with nicely matched sides. The price is very reasonable, and the quality is top-notch.We had a couple of drinks (cock- and mock-tails) and both were good. Wine by the glass was not overpriced. They don't have full liquor due to the church across the street (!)Welcome to the neighborhood, HT, we're happy you're here.

My latest favorite discovery! I live near one of their other restaurants (Hamiltons) and eat there pretty regularly and was happy to discover that some of the same amazing staff are now at Hilltop Tavern. The menu has some of the same items as Hamiltons (shout-out to my favorite crispy artichoke and arugula salad) but also some amazing additions that I wish Hamiltons would have (because sometimes I'm too lazy to walk 20 minutes). The brook trout almandine, roasted cauliflower, crispy artichokes and burrata all stood out. Excited to return to try the brunch.

Good food service was great . Friendly staff . We had a very good brunch - the fried artichokes were fantastic

Came here for dinner with my family and we enjoyed it quite a bit. They have built in outdoor dining around the restaurant so you're not outside on the street eating car fumes. The inside is pretty cozy but can still accommodate a bigger group but definitely call ahead and make a reservation for that. We had the crispy artichoke for appetizer and it was delicious! Lightly fried without any batter you really get the artichoke taste. I had the trout that was served with cauliflower rice and it was really good. The trout was cooked well and flaky. My husband had the braised lamb shank over polenta which was very tender and flavorful. Although I'm not a big fan of the polenta. My daughter had the kids pasta with burrata and loved her meal as well. The cocktails were a hit or miss for me but the waitress was an absolute sweetheart and very attentive and ended up making me another drink. FYI: I did NOT complain about my drink the lavendar royale. She asked me what I thought and if I liked it and I told her it's not what I thought it would be even though it had all the ingredients that I loved. I guess it just didn't go well together. The 2nd drink she made me, the hamilton royale was delicious. Will definitely go back and try their brunch menu.

This was a great place for early dinner with the family. Happy hour prices for drinks and appetizers go until 6 and there is a kids menu and some good desserts. Because they are across the street from a church all drinks are wine or soju based. We will be back for another meal.

Hilltop is a hidden gem. Start your meal with the crispy artichokes and you can't go wrong. The steak frites and the shrimp and grits are delightful. For fans of cassis, I love the kir royale. For dessert- having the "blind" date cake for the first time is like discovering the love of your life. It's that good.

We stumbled across a gem while walking around Prospect Park, Brooklyn. The food (Burger, Fries and Wings) were AWESOME!! Graham our server was fantastic as well. The ambience is quaint and refreshingly quick enough for conversation. Kudos to the chef for the food and many thanks to Graham.

Best restaurant in Windsor Terrace. The food is fantastic. Shrimp and grits and spinach ravioli in brown butter are standouts.

This meal was delish! I went to Hilltop Tavern for a bday celebration. Servers and wait staff couldn't have been nicer, even when we accidentally broke a glass. Food was really good! I recommend the Swiss breakfast which had poached eggs & salmon on top of potato pancakes, yum! I don't remember what my friends had but they loved their meals, too. So glad to have a new restaurant to go to. We'll definitely go back.