Hill and Bay
Hill and Bay
House Wine
Top: Signature Grill House Burger Bottom: Buffalo Chicken Burger Both $16.95
Kings Peach Mock-tail
a row of beer glasses on a bar
Outside - May 2021
a bar with a brick wall
a bar with a christmas tree on the counter
a menu on a table
outside
Iced Cappuccino
French Onion Soup, Chicken
Shoestring Fries
Outside - May 2021
Happy hour deals
Pan Seared Mahi Mahi was so dry. Don't order.
salads
food
seating
Outside - May 2021
Grilled Mahi Mahi Tacos
menu
Exterior
Maria M.
Nov 28, 2024
5 Stars because their staff especially cook are awesome!!!!We went their pretty late like 4:45pm and they still prepped brunch for us while they were closed for brunch long time and had to prep eggs all from scratch! Reallyyy went out of their way- I was craving for brunch that day and they have literally found new regulars by that act of great customer service :)Brunch was good food too- Defo a must try! Tried their eggs/sausage/French toast and loved every bit of it. Ambiance is great too and you don't have to wait in long lines.
Read More
C G.
Oct 21, 2024
Inappropriate behavior from waiter/bartender. The food is okay however what is distasteful is the way one of the employees Jon treats local customers, particularly those with disabilities or cognitive decline. I went one evening with a client who has memory loss and was in shock at how Jon treated the client. He ignored the client when asked for a drink at the bar and proceeded to yell at him for a simple request to shut the door as he is elderly man who gets cold easily. We visit HillBay frequently, and the other staff are aware of his condition and are very understanding and accommodating. However, Jon publicly belittled and embarrassed him. I don't recommend this place as it is not a safe and no longer going there.
Read More
Christopher C.
Sep 28, 2024
great little spot near nyucd that friends of mine come after lab! There are happy hour deals that I need to try next, but I adored the calm atmosphere-- the staff was friendly and I'd come back for sure!The tacos hit the spot and I'll come back for breakfast soonCheers!
Read More
Morgan B.
Jan 6, 2025
Good brunch/ lunch spot in the neighborhood. Food is a step up from the diners in the neighborhood but nothing fancy either. I have been here twice and both times I was satisfied with my meal. The standouts were the tater tots, perfectly greasy and crunchy! They were also very accommodating of our large brunch party which I was pleasantly surprised by!
Read More
Jennifer L.
Jan 15, 2025
The mahi mahi was so dry and awful. The salsa was dry too. Only the broccoli was good but I can make that at home. Mt friends didn't enjoy their steak or ravioli. Happy hour drink deal was good but the Irish espresso martini was meh. Service was good until we tried to pay for the bill since they didn't come to take our card. Ambiance was good.
Read More
Percy H.
Dec 26, 2023
Hill and Bay is the perfect before or after dinner, movie, or date night spot. You can't go wrong with Hill because it's easy to get off the six lines, plus it is right across the street from Kips Bay AMC. The staff is friendly and will make you feel right at home. In addition, they have a fantastic happy hour, and they always have a unique drink inspired by a popular movie. The options on the menu are extensive, and there is something for everyone. I enjoyed some wings and sweet potato fries during this experience. I hoped for the beer flight, and I must say, each one was delicious. Hill Bay came highly recommended. I'm happy my bestie recommended this restaurant to me, and now I highly recommend it to you.
Read More
Dody E.
Dec 17, 2023
Came here for brunch with two good friends, and was a bit disappointed in the eggs Benedict. The eggs tasted a bit off, and the Benedict in general didn't have much flavor. The hollandaise sauce was very poor :(My friends ordered the waffle and Huevos Rancheros , which they seemed to have enjoyed enough. The interior and service were both very nice, so I was disappointed my plate was a bit underwhelming !
Read More
AJ L.
Feb 28, 2024
I recently came here for dinner and had a pleasant experience.It's a very nice restaurant that's unassumingly much bigger than it appears from the outside. They have a great happy hour menu that runs Mon-Friday until 8pm. I got a flight of beer for $10 which is unheard of for New York.There is a lot of food options ranging from salads to burgers to pasta to fish. The portions are normal size and the food is quite average. The service itself is alright, but they are nice which is always good. Prices are pretty reasonable.
Read More
Sam C.
Jun 4, 2024
Great service, clean location and tasty food. The French onion soup was delicious. The kale Ceasar salad was ok.
Read More
Sofia L.
Mar 12, 2024
came in here for their happy hour right before our movie. great, mellow music and fair prices for their drinks. suuper wide range of food options. place felt very chill. water was served immediately after being seated.
Read More
