Highline Pizzeria

We recently placed a large catering order with Highline Pizza, and I have to say, we are very impressed! The order involved nearly 10 hours of active deliveries, but Nestor was nothing short of amazing. From the start, he was incredibly communicative, keeping us updated every step of the way. His efficiency made the whole process smooth and stress-free.The pizzas themselves were awesome--personal-sized, and even better, they were heart-shaped! Such a fun touch that definitely added a unique flair to our event. Not to mention, the taste was on point. Every single pizza was fresh, flavorful, and exactly what we were hoping for.From the easy ordering process to the timely deliveries and perfect pizzas, we couldn't have asked for a better experience. Highly recommend Highline Pizza for any catering needs. They nailed it!

I did not try the pizza here but the Garlic knots were mini but tasty! The staff working here were nice and friendly. This pizza shop is very small but when you walk in the smell of pizza just is soo good! Ifyou are in the area I would stop in for a slice!

Solid pizza choice near the high line! We tried a selection: white pizza, pepperoni roll, grandma pizza, and plain. Not the most amazing pizza in my entire life, but everything was very solid. Staff was very friendly and food came up quickly. There were a handful of seats and a small counter outside where we ate. If you're in the area, not a bad stop if you're craving some pizza!

We came here after seeing Sleep No More and needed some food and needed it fast! We ordered pepperoni, cheese and meat lovers. I enjoyed the pepperoni pizza! The sauce wasn't sweet, which I liked. Pepperonis were those normal sized ones but still good. I needed the salt after the work out at Sleep No More. There's some front seating to enjoy the pizza.

Gluten free pizza not good :( Disappointed with the crust. The sauce and cheese were delish.

Pretty good pizza, especially for this part of town where pizza parlors are scarce. About $5 on average per slice. Cheese is on par with Joe's, I think. But the chicken parm was pretty damn good. Love the crispy crust from the 're-bake'. And they have some seats out front (none inside).

Pizza used to be good here. Must be new owners the pizza is not even edible. Crust was rock hard. $1 slice spots serve better pizza. You have been warned

I needed a snack one day when I was in the area and grabbed a slice here at Highline. The place is super tiny and cramped, so don't expect to sit down and enjoy a relaxing time. I'd strictly expect to get your slices to go at this pizza joint. I did enjoy seeing painted art along the edges of the walls calling back to the nearby Highline.I ordered a slice with mushrooms on it. Service was good. The guys behind the counter took my order quickly and they had the slice in the oven in moments. I paid, grabbed my slice and headed out. The slice was good. A solid B-, but nothing extraordinary. I wouldn't go out of my way to go there but if I was in the area I wouldn't mind grabbing a slice here either.

Excellent food and even though there wasn't a place to sit inside, they had a place outside and it was fabulous! My cheese pizza was definitely worth the walk from Penn Station and we will be going back!

Highline Pizzeria services hot delicious pizza, Staff is busy, yet friendly.The Highline is my favorite place in NYC, Pizzeria is a great high-light!