Gotham Pizza

Gotham is great for a quick bite. Good slice, great service. What else can you ask for? :)Favorite slice: cheese, white slice

I purchased sausage pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots were not worth it at all. It didn't taste fresh and was more chewy than I like. The pizza was good. I do not have much to say about it. I do not like the more rough seemingly breadcrumbed crust of the pizza. Personally I prefer more fluffy or smooth crusts. The cheese and sauce were average. The pizza tasted good and maybe I would get it again but there is nothing that makes it stand out

We were looking for an authentic slice of NY pizza for lunch, and Gotham fit the bill! Hot, crispy, tasty and a value at less than $10 for 2 slices and drinks. It was obvious why it stays so busy.

We stumbled upon this pizzeria on our way back to hotel past dinner time. Since we were super hungry, we decided to have some pizza. Surprisingly, the pizza were good! We love the crispy crust with corn meal dust. The filling was good and tasted fresh. We even came back the next day for more slices.- Margherita: the mozzarella tasted fresh and the sauce was good- BBQ chicken: loads of chicken pieces but the bbq sauce was a bit too much- Pepperoni: simple but delicious! Lots of peperoni

Very mid pizza for 4$ a slice. Fine for a quick bite if passing by but at that point just get a 1.50$ slice lol

The pizza was ok. Not the worst and not the best, maybe slightly below average. The best flavor I had here was the pepperoni. Not a fan of the crust here. You must eat this hot or else it don't do too well cold but that is just me.

My bf was right. This pizza was the best. I finally had it after hearing him talking about it for many months. The pizza was thin crusted and super soft. It had the right amount of cheese and tomato sauce. Everything was just right.

Not as big as your typical NY slice. In fact I couldn't recommend buying this pizza by the slice. As a pie I still found it to be a little small. Their largest pie is 16in and comes with about 8 slices. This should be enough to split between 2-4 people. As far as price goes you're gonna pay about the same or slightly less than other NY pizza places. Despite these issues I thought the pizza tasted great. It's a delicious classic NY slice made to near perfection. I was worried how it looked but the taste made it well worth it. It helped that I was able to get a great discount from Door Dash otherwise I might have a different opinion. I'd give it a 3.5 if that was possible but I'll settle for a 4. I can easily recommend this spot and it's possible I may order from here again someday.

I use to love Gotham Pizza and just ordered from the UES and it was 100% terrible horrible full of salt and delivered like a mess.. Want my money back!! O and they are rude!

Get the grandma's pizza! delicious. simple. add basil. StillHot on delivery! Great crust.