Garvey's Irish Pub

This is a cute pub located right in the theater district. I came for dinner right before Redwood and it was great. There's live music and the singer was lovely. I got the fried chicken sandwich which came with fries and a pickle. The fries were great and the sandwich was good, but I though the chicken was a tad dry. Service was good although it did take a while for us to get the check despite asking a few times, I guess they were busy that night. Also, if you show the waiter your Broadway ticket you get a small discount!

I had the opportunity to pop in to Garveys again for dinner with my daughter. This visit both of us got the chicken sandwich. It was out of this world. Cooked perfectly and I don't know what the sauce was but it was delicious. There was a singer called Georgia (I think that was her name) and she had a beautiful voice. I will definitely be coming back with friends so I can stay longer for drinks and enjoy the music.

One of the most crisp Guinness in NYC. Poured just right and the moment my cup was ready for a refill, a new one (with a shamrock ) was slid my direction! The food was incredible, had the half roasted chicken. I was told it would take about a half hour to be ready, so the expectation was set. The chicken was juicy and flavorful, veggies were tender but still had a bit of a bite and the mash was creamy and delicious. All of this was, somehow, outshined but the epic tunes of Allen Gogarty. Allan's music was uplifting and invigorating. What a time!! 10/10 will be back; most likely on another night Allen is playing!

We stoped at Garvey's for a late night drink and snack as it was only a few doors down from our hotel. Conveniently located in Time Square, greeted by a friendly bartender and Guinness on tap. We were hoping for live music but there wasn't any on the night we went. They also have a great selection of wine and whiskey. Full menu available, but we only had a pretzel and it was okay, definitely didn't taste like. NY fresh pretzel. It was served with cheese, but the table mustard was much better for dipping. We would definitely stop by again to enjoy the drinks, music, easy going atmosphere and the location. Cheers!

The pub is rather new here. We arrived about 6:30PM. We were greeted when we walked in, and we're directly seated. Our server came to our table and asked for our drink order. He was very disinterested. It took a few minutes for our draft Guinness to arrive. And the server left without saying a word. He later came back and ask for our dinner order. My wife asked for the Shepherds Pie, and I the Bacon Spinach salad. Again the server left without another word or question. The place was extremely loud with the recorded music very loud. All the patrons were forced to shout to communicate!! And nothing at all suggested an Irish pub!! Our food came again without a word. But the food was delicious!! The pie was great! Very tasteful and perfectly seasoned. The salad was huge and so much bacon. Truly fantastic!!All and all it was good, not not at all like an Irish pub!

Stopped here for a few beers before seeing Tommy next door at the Nederlander theatre. Good old school Irish music was cranking, bartenders were very friendly and attentive, I ordered the Chicken club sandwich which was very good. Big crowds came in before the show, great energy, everyone enjoying themselves. Really, what more could you ask for ????

If you want to get ignored then cursed out and yelled at in a bar full of people at 5pm just ask this bartender or even better the manager who thinks its funny and disregards it . The male manager has been intrusive sevaral times so ive avoided going when hes on shift but today i had the pleasure of being verbally assaulted by thus big guy , because i asked him if he was ignoring me after i asked for a beer 3-4 times

Sitting In this bar you would never think you are right smack in touristy times Sq. This bar feels like a neighborhood bar with kind bartenders , great music and great beers on Tap. Oliver is the best!!! He is so sweet and made my night with his friendly conversation on a colds winter night. The musician playing was singing the right songs. I will be back to see Oliver!!

This was my wife and I's first visit to NY City together. I won't lie. We were on our way to pizza and happened upon Garvey's Pub and decided to push pizza to lunch the next day and go in for fish and chips (this review is limited to that menu item but really that's the constant at Irish Pubs that really tell me the status of the place). In a word - delicious and satisfying. I paired it with a Montauk IPA (okay 2) but left filling full and with a card should I ever be in NY City again. The food was good, the tunes were good, the service was great and it has an authentic vibe. Do not ask the girl at the desk to the right if it's self seating. She works for the hotel next door and will give you blank stares. Go straight to the bar and you'll find a friendly greeting that is a wonderful precursor to good food and a great experience!

Granted it was Christmas day, but we ordered 4 different types of beer and everyone was incredibly flat.