Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen

The staff here was so friendly! They had great recommendations The salad was delicious but the kale did come in giant chunks which was confusing. Had to chop it up a bunch ourselves. The pizza is what you come here for! It was outstanding. Crispy edges and a doughy center with quality red sauce and cheese. Can't wait to come back and try more The restaurant itself was cute and had ample seating good for big groups even

Before heading to a concert, my girlfriend and I decided to grab some pizza and chose Emmy's Squared Pizza for a change since square pizza isn't that common in NYC. We made a reservation, and when we arrived, we noticed it wasn't packed, so we were seated right away. The ambiance was nice, with a darker theme that I really liked. We requested still water and were given that. We wanted fries on the side but felt the 1lb seasoned fries would be too much, so we opted for regular fries instead. For our pizza, we ordered a regular pie with caramelized onions, bell peppers, and grilled chicken.The pizza was pretty good, but my girlfriend thought the chicken was a bit overcooked and hard. As for the fries, they were decent but could have used a bit more seasoning, though the waiter did inform us it would only be salted. Overall, we enjoyed the meal and the nice atmosphere, and I would recommend Emmy's Squared Pizza for anyone looking to try a different style of pizza in the city.

Loved it here!I had wanted to try this place for awhile. I was staying in the area, and it was conveniently located on the same block.I stopped in for dinner on a week night. There were other people dining, but there was no wait.We ordered pizza and the salad. The food was incredible! I was pleasantly surprised, even though I had read other great reviews on Emmy's food.I can't wait to stop back in and try more of their food options.If I'm in the area again, I'll definitely stop back in.I highly recommend this spot!

Pillar is amazing!!!! Best service in Hells Kitchen!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm hooked on Emmy Squared. Each location I've gone to has a different touch but still provides great service and food. I always go with different versions of bacon, chicken and basil and I'm never disappointed. The drinks are also great.

I love Emmy squared! The pizza is amazing (thick crust Detroit style) and their burger is so good, I could go and not even order pizza if I was craving a burger. This location is nice because it's very close to all the Broadway shows so easy to go over after or before for a meal. The restaurant itself is narrow but with a reservation you could get a decent group size in. There's also seating at the bar for a quick service.

I'll start by saying this review is for delivery so unfortunately I'm unable to comment on the ambiance or what the location is like in-person, but I did have an issue with the app I ordered through (Toast Takeout, the service you are redirected to when you click order for takeout or delivery on their website) and tried calling the location directly twice and got forwarded to voicemail after the phone rang and rang each time so my impression of the service isn't great given they couldn't be bothered to simply pick up the phone.That issue aside, the food that was delivered to me was a bit hit or miss. The pizza was out of this world good! Seriously, amazing flavor and texture- crisp crunchy edges and fluffy interior, the Big Hawaiian had just the right amount of heat and sweet to tantalize the taste buds! The pizza itself is small and so are the individual slices, but half of it fills you up quick so it's perfect to split with a friend or save for another meal. I completely get the hype now!The Chopped Italian Salad was a real let down. There were barely any toppings, it was essentially just a box full of chopped romaine with 3 grape tomatoes sliced in half, a handful of chickpeas, a few slivers of roasted red bell peppers, some flavorless pieces of provolone, and chunks of soppressata that personally I did not enjoy the taste of one bit. For a salad that costs $22 I genuinely expected something fresher, higher in quality, better in taste, and just far more than what I received, I'm genuinely astounded they would let this go out the door. For a salad this simple you, either do it well or don't do it at all.Overall, I'm torn. The pizza was hands down some of the best I've had and I'm looking forward to having it again, but I'd probably never order anything else off the menu so I think takeout might be the way to go so you can fix your own sides at home.

Unique pizza, accommodating staff, family friendly ambiance. Good pizza, would try other pizza slices next time.

So gooood ive never had detroit style before. The gourd and mvp were scrumptious. I want to go back

Emma was the best server that I've had in a long while!! She's perfectly attentive providing just the right amount of timely service. She is so friendly and was great at interacting with the whole table, including all ages. Her recommendations were wonderful and delicious. The Ceaser salad was fresh and perfect for sharing. The Miranda pizza had just the right amount of spice with fresh dough and arrived hot and delicious. I would give her and this place a 10 out of 10!!!