Classic Lobster Newberg
Wedge Salad. Best prosciutto in the world! Crispy! Amazing!
Restaurant Week 2024- Bacon appetizer. OK
Seating
Brussel sprouts
Dining room
Medium filet mignon and cream spinach
Entry
Yellow tail
Lobster Newberg.
1867 Classic Baked Alaska
Oysters
pasta, food
Interior
salads, salad, food
bbq ribs, ribs, food
Bread. Good
Delmonico Table Setting.
Kumamoto Oysters
Restaurant Week 2024- Caesar 1. Excellent
Old Fashioned
Rachel G.
Feb 16, 2025
We made a reservation for New Year's Eve dinner since we've never been before. The restaurant was packed when we arrived. They have a dress code, so be sure to dress appropriately.We were seated in the side room next to the bar room. We had to order the classics. Shrimp cocktail, ribeyes, creamed spinach, asparagus and the famous baked Alaska. Every dish was cooked perfectly and was the quintessential steakhouse meal. The ribeye was nicely charred and the star of the meal. The baked Alaska was a great way to end the meal. Not too sweet and a good size for sharing. Even though we were full, we couldn't help finishing the dessert. We'll be back to try the menu served at the bar room!
Read MoreAngelo B.
Feb 22, 2025
I've been here a few times now and always leaving feeling like the meal was just okay. The steak is decent but really not that different to what I can prepare myself. Other ny steak houses have better flavor in my opinion. On the positive side they have served a perfect medium rare each time. Service below average for steak house. Front desk seemed disorganized, and waited seemed rushed. Pretty lively during a weekend dinner.
Read MoreJackie H.
Feb 11, 2025
Service and ambiance was nice. Although we had reservations, it was quite a wait so be prepared for that. The appetizer burrata was yummy and delicious and served on a piece of bread which was interesting. The yellowtail crudo was yummy esp with the crunchy pearls on top. The brussels sprouts were cooked nicely charred but had a wasabi taste that wasn't my favorite. The restaurant week deal online indicated the Eye of Delmonico to be 12 oz but note in person menu showed 5 oz and indeed it was that. Medium rare but kinda tough/dry. A bit disappointing. The dessert was amazing. Loved the chocolate cake as it was super rich.
Read MoreJulisa H.
Feb 20, 2025
I went for lunch yesterday and I liked it! The atmosphere and decor is classic, the staff is courteous and it has a very relaxed vibe. I ordered at the bar with Mark who was excellent. I had the burger and fries with a gypsy rose cocktail. The cocktail was light, sweet and fruity not very alcohol forward. The burger (medium) juicy with solid flavor. Fries are more like a steak cut, crispy, hot and filling. All and all it was a cool experience at a classic, historical restaurant and it ran me about $70With tax before gratuity.
Read MoreNicole M.
Feb 6, 2025
We've been dying to try Delmonico's for such a long time and finally made it during Restaurant Week! We found a spot at the bar to hang out while waiting for the rest of our party to arrive. I had the Green Gatsby (very refreshing but one was enough as it reminded me of spa water) and my girlfriend ordered the Never Say Never. Service was top notch! Our waiter offered for a sommelier to come to our table and help us select the right wine based off our taste preferences.The restaurant week menu is a great deal if you're trying out a restaurant for the first time - we each had an app, entree and dessert for $60! I had the yellowtail crudo, eye of Delmonico (5oz) and the Baked Alaska. Portions are smaller during restaurant week but still worthy nonetheless.Of course I had a bite of everyone else's apps - sharing is caring after all. The bacon app, Caesar salad and Crab cake with potato were all so good. I'll definitely be sure to order during my next visit. For dessert, try the Baked Alaska! It's walnut cake, apricot jam and banana gelato with meringue. This was definitely a 5 star dinner!
Read MoreTamika G.
Jan 30, 2025
Top notch steakhouse experience during resturant week. The food and service exceeded expectations. From drinks at the bar to coat check, table sevice..everything was well taken care of smiles. We did the resturant week menu, tried the crabcak which was fresh, hot and pretty you almost didn't want to taste it. The cesar salad was delicious. The steak here was cooked to perfection. Chef kiss. Paired it with creamed spinach and pomme purre...Will return
Read MoreTessa R.
Feb 4, 2025
What an amazing dinning experience, this place is run so smoothly. The employees really take pride in working here and it shows.The building itself is stunning both inside and outside. Walking in feels as though you've been taken back in time. It is elegant and classy, an experience I won't forget. It is filled with a rich history.We sat in the bar area as it was a Saturday night and did not have reservations. There were a few spot available but filled up quickly after we sat down. We ordered from the bar menu and had a few drinks. The food came out and it was perfection. Everything was incredible. We ordered the wedge salad, Cesar salad, steak and burger with fries. Not a single complaint. Our server was friendly and professional. We truly had a magical time. This restaurant will always bring a smile to my face when I think of NYC. If you have a chance, I highly suggest you make your way over here! Even if you go to the bar and have a drink, just being in the restaurant is a treat.
Read MoreCindy Z.
Jan 1, 2025
As the first fine dining restaurant in America, there's so much history with a classic feel here like many steakhouses. We arrived early for our reservations, so we went for a drink at the bar. I had the Never Say Never ($25) cocktail, which was a bit too sour for me. Once our table was ready, we brought our drinks over to the table as well. So multiple rooms including a downstairs, so the space feels cozy while also being so spacious.After we placed our orders, a basket of bread was brought out. The bread was a sourdough with soft butter, which was really good. I wanted to eat more of this, but didn't want to overstuff myself. For the main entree, I ordered the Lobster Newberg ($59). This dish comes with a beautifully cooked lobster tail with its claw meat over this nice sauce. On the side, it also comes with a brick of crispy rice over a miso sauce. It's an interesting combo, but I enjoyed this. Also tried some of the Hashbrown ($18), which was huge. This was more of a skillet mashed potato than a hashbrown, in my opinion though. The creme fraiche complimented this well though. My fiancé's steak was a bit more rare than he ordered, so it was a bit chewy.To finish off, we had some scoops of ice cream ($6) and cheesecake ($17). The cheesecake was so soft and silky, though quite a small piece. Overall, it's a pricey meal, but fit for a special occasion. We all ended up pretty full and satisfied. The service was attentive from some but less so from others, so a bit of a mixed review for that.
Read MoreKisbel F.
Feb 23, 2025
Snagged a reservation for Restaurant Week and enjoyed it. Located in the FiDi district, it's just a classic. The restaurant was beautiful inside. Service was above and beyond. The salmon portion was teeny so hope you're not hungry. For sides we ordered the asparagus and their potatoes which I wasn't a fan of. They reminded me of hash browns made in a skillet and had a seasoning I didn't like. The desserts though were delicious! We got the cheesecake and chocolate cake.
Read MoreL. Eliza C.
Dec 24, 2024
This review is from the perceptive of someone who has not been to Delmonicos since 2018 (Pre-Pandemic).The place still has that classy ambiance. I am glad there is coat service as I brought a big bag of gifts and lots of layers. We came here for holiday cheers and noticed that the menu has changed and added a vegetarian friendly risotto, some salads (though one has to remove the ham off the place and if you have a big group, there is always someone you can give them too). Food:I had the wedge salad, risotto, double expresso and a scoop of hazelnut. My side came out to $120. My friends had flesh dishes and they paid on average between $150 to $250 each. I always rememered the Baked Alaska and used to indulge on them back in the day. I am glad I didnt order it as the size was very small for $24. I liked the elegance of this place and seeing so many big groups and couples. I recommend either asking for separate checks or one person paying all. Otherwise it is a production at the end.
Read More