Charlie's Sandwich Shop

#4 roast beef is duper gooooodmachine sliced thin. roast beef and bread was very soft. sandwich was flavorful without being over powering one month prior:the other roast beef with mozzerella. that hand sliced one was super good. 2 for 2 on the roastbeefs

I've been here a couple of times now and they haven't let me down. It's a small shop; not really a place to sit down and eat. In the display are delicious home cooked meals and sides. The sandwiches are carefully made and I knew this so I ordered ahead of time and waited 15 minutes before heading over. My L'americano had the perfect amount of balsamic. Simple flavors but so so good. The roast beef went on forever. The sanitation special was the hubs and he thoroughly enjoyed. I tried asking for flavor notes so I can write about it but he was busy eating The service is always lovely. Tips: have cash ready and order ahead!

I am a resident of Staten Island, and as such, I like to attend many fund raisers in SI, especially for veterans. I went to a U.S.I.V.O. fundraiser on 10/26/2024, and I participated in some raffles. At the end of the evening, I was lucky enough to win a 25.00 Gift Card for Charlies Sandwich shop, the address said "130 Lincoln avenue" in SI. but when my husband went to get a sandwich on 10/29/24, they were closed. I called the number on the menu, (for Brooklyn), and they told me that they had sold this location 3 months prior. They also notified me that this gift card would be no good in the Brooklyn location. I think it is wrong not to honor the gift card. Please be aware that this sandwish shop does not do right by their customer. Thank you

I saw many great reviews for Charlie's, with tons of amazing photos and I wanted to get in on the experience. From the reviews it seems like they are killing it in this neighborhood. The ambiance: it's a very small sandwich shop, looked very clean, the woman at the counter was very friendly and very nice and greeted me as I walked through the door. When I came home with the sandwiches they smelled wonderful. however when I opened them up they were really skimp with the meat. It didn't reflect the photos that I've seen on Yelp/Google. My Giuseppe tasted amazing, but didn't seem like it was worth $15 - not enough meat and was still hungry after eating.Apologies, but I've seen more sausage on a slice of pizza than what was on the whole Wednesday sausage sandwich for 15$. My BF was disappointed with his meal and was also still hungry. I will say that the bread is really fresh and tasty. That was the highlight of my meal.Wanted to love this place, but maybe I came on a off day?

My partner and I ordered the Don Giuseppe and the Menny special, made to order fresh and delicious sandwiches. The service was friendly and warm. The space is small, but has two tables, one indoor & one outdoor. It's clean as well. Great Sicilian memorabilia as decor. Will definitely come back when I'm in the area

Charlie's has been on my list for a while!- great location- local small business- great service - friendly and attentive- tons of sandwich options- thin sliced meats- fresh bread- small so limited seatsThe sandwiches come toasted and the ones we tried were delicious! I'd definitely come back and try the other ones. They are also perfectly sized- I could almost finish one whole one but I'm so full.

I've ordered from Charlie's about half-a-dozen times, but never got around to doing a review, because sometimes restaurants are so legit that they don't need to have a review on their resumé to attract customers. That's Charlie's; They're THAT good.Today, I ordered the "Papa Sal Sandwich", which was a new one, for me. A warm sammich served on a hero, with Chicken Parm topped with slices of breaded, fried eggplant. So... Think... If Chicken Parm & Eggplant Parm had a baby... That's what The "Papa Sal Sandwich" tastes like. They've salted the eggplant prior to breading and frying, because there is absolutely NO bitterness at all. The Chicken Breast was tender. Plenty of sauce, plenty of Mozz'; Let me put it this way... While I ate this sammich, I did a little dance in my seat out of pure flavorfully-induced ecstasy. Subway is fine, if you want just a plain ol' sammich... A "no-big-deal" sammich. Charlie's is where you need to go for a REAL, RESTAURANT-QUALITY sammich.

Great tasting amazing sandwichesFast serviceFresh ingredients I highly recommend Charlie's sandwich shop

I was finished with a day of work with my supervisor in our Bay Ridge neighborhood and when she offered to buy lunch I was not going to argue. She wanted to try Charlie's Sandwich Shop and despite my living close by I have not been in there yet so I was game for this. While I don't remember the name of our sandwiches, we got the same thing which was chicken cutlet, mozzarella cheese and bacon. She asked for that kind of cheese instead of the one on the menu and I just said "same" to make sure there was no margin for error and having the wrong item in my bag and in hers. As we asked for the sandwiches toasted there was a little bit of a wait and when we arrived there were already people waiting on orders so it was a busy day for the small shop. I like seeing this in the post pandemic times since so many businesses suffered. Now spatially speaking this place is very small, so you'll walk in and order and probably prefer to stand outside and wait for it as otherwise other customers will be on top of you. This is something I no longer enjoy myself, so elbow room or a couple of feet space keeps me happy. Once I was home I anxiously opened the sandwich and it was super tasty. I added some hot sauce on the top of it since I do that with almost everything these days. As I finished the whole thing I didn't need to eat for the rest of the day and for sure some lengthy walking was going to be on the schedule. Pricewise the sandwiches run from about $13-$15 which isn't all that bad in today's skyrocketing inflation economy.

Homemade style Italian sandwich shop with portions you'll appreciate.These sandwiches were certainly made with "Charlie's Love" as we had to patiently wait fifteen minutes for them to be crafted. The Calabrese(hot homemade Sopressata, melted French cheese, olive oil and oregano) was served hot and flavorful. The Che Si Dici(Prosciutto di Parma, sweet Sopressata, imported provolone, sun-dried tomato and oil balsamic.) had enough meat for two sandwiches. The crispy toasted sesame bread was icing on the cake.Charlie's only accepts cash, and also, the prices on the menu does not include sales tax. The dining area is cozy and decorated with Italia decor. The sandwich quality here is a notch above the chain places nearby, but it comes with a price. Simply, Charlie's isn't a quick bite for lunch but a meal to savor when you are in a ravenous mood.