Carnegie Pizza
Carnegie Pizza
Mixed Greens, Cucumbers, Carrots, Peppers, Red Onions, and Pepperoncini
Poland Spring Water
Must be 21 to Purchase
Must be 21 to Purchase
Must be 21 to Purchase
One slice
One slice
3 small Cannolis with chocolate chip filling
Garlic knots
White Pizza Slice
Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
Picture perfect
5 Garlic Knots
the interior of the restaurant
a slice of pepperoni pizza
a man sitting at a table in a restaurant
food, pizza
Spicy pepperoni
food, pancakes
pizza, food
interior
pizza, food
pizza, food
Sausage pepperoni slice
food
food, pizza
food
Pepperoni Pizza Pie
food, pizza
Kelsey R.
Jan 4, 2025
A solid NY pizza. It is what you expect to eat here, and it was not a terrible price. Came back here twice during our trip. Staff was delightful. Not a long line. Only - was that there's not much space to sit and eat your pizza. However that's the beauty of a pizza slice. Take it and eat on the go!
Read More
Adina S.
Feb 13, 2025
Any time I'm visiting New York City, you can bet I'm going to want some pizza. I have my go to spots, but this time I deviated, deciding to try out Carnegie Pizza instead. I went with the square pepperoni slice and it hit the spot! However, it was pretty greasy.Not much to note in terms of service or ambiance. This is really your typical pizza spot. Bring your appetite and grab a slice (or two)!
Read More
Vi G.
Feb 1, 2025
There's just something at NY pizza. The crisp dough. The size. The quick, ready to go pizza. Only downfall...so much grease. Yet so delicious. One slice, will do you good.
Read More
Sheila K.
Jan 27, 2025
Between this place or Joe's... go with Carnegie! Both a short walk from Times Square. Me and my boyfriend walked passed this place multiple times before we finally decided to try it... especially after the shameful experience at Joe's, why not right? They weren't as busy as Joe's. That's a plus for us (no line), not so much for them. They should be busier! Once we walked in we were greeted with smiles and got our order taken right away. When we got our pizza slices, they were nice and hot! Just how it should be! It's a small little pizza parlor, limited seating, clean. Only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is simply because they aren't the best I've ever had but they definitely deserve to be acknowledged a lot more than Joe's. Keep it up!
Read More
Andrea C.
Dec 26, 2024
Was going to another pizza place and after seeing the LINE... We ended up here and boy were we satisfied! Im so glad we ended up at this little pizza place. Theres barely any seating inside but... its new york what are we expecting? The service is fast and efficient, the food is delicious, the ambiance is good vibes!The choices of pizza are endless and the garlic buns are delish! I definitely recommend stopping by here for a little lunch vibe during your stroll in NYC.
Read More
Thomson X.
Jan 22, 2025
Stopped by here while touring New York. When people used to tell me NY Pizza is really good, I never really believed it until I tried the pizza here. The dough was really crispy and light. Sauce and cheese was also perfectly matched. Now I really understood the NY Pizza hype. There was a line when I went but it tends to go quickly. Since Joe's is super packed, I highly recommend going here instead.
Read More
Jose P.
Sep 14, 2024
Enjoyed another delicious lunch at Carnegie Pizza. I really enjoy the cleanliness of this pizzeria, the brightness of the lighting, and the many options of slices. Today's selections were onion/pepper/mushroom and Grandma slices. Both were crispy, fresh, at the perfect temperature, and VERY GOOD. Carnegie Pizza will be my top 3 lunch options and I hope you make time to enjoy their menu.TIP: If you pay cash, you'll save on the 3.5% credit card usage charge.
Read More
Chris G.
Nov 19, 2024
I stopped here while in New York and was looking for a good pizza nearby and was pleasantly surprised there was a small line but employees were really fast and was able to get through quick. I ended up getting a Hawaiian slice and pepperoni slice both which were good and big slices as well definitely would eat here again and if you see long lines at other places I would definitely recommend coming here and giving it a try as they have quite a few items ready to go.
Read More
Tika L.
Feb 13, 2025
We had the Pepperoni Sicilian slices. It was delicious! Lots of pepperoni, good savory sauce & the crust was crunchy but not too hard. Also, good customer service. I would definitely recommend
Read More
Raymond A.
Aug 9, 2024
It's ok a little expensive for a slice + tax. They have seating for dining. It's ok compared to other pizzeria in the area. It's clean and the staff is friendly.
Read More
