The Most Delicious Pizza in New York

My Pie Pizzeria Romana

★★★★☆ 4.4 (955) • $$

"Came to NYC for vacation and pizza, having tried several of the trendy names, I was beginning to get disappointed until I tried My Pie Pizzeria Romana. Plenty of options for different toppings. Thin and crunchy crust that can support plenty of toppings and just really good pizza. Seating is limited, but it's pizzaWould I Go Out of My Way to Try? YesWould I Return? YesAmbiance- 6/10Food Taste- 9/10Service- 8/10Value- 8/10"

Emporio

★★★★☆ 4.1 (944) • $$$

"I've been living in Manhattan for the last 10 years and Emporio has become my ALL TIME FAVORITE restaurant in the city. My wife and I frequent this location 2-3 times per month, usually on our sole date night each week and no matter how many times we come, the food always hits, the service is consistently excellent and the experience is spectacular. By now we've tried pretty much everything on the menu and it's refreshing to see that they keep changing up the specials based on seasonal availability of ingredients. We've seen so many delicious additions like lamb loin carpaccio, seared diver scallops, lobster risotto, clam pasta (similar to vongole) and even boar chops. We also noticed certain menu items might get tweaked, for example the crab on the squid ink spaghetti may get switched with shrimp. Or the charred octopus once was switched for jumbo shrimp in garlic and chili. No matter what though, every dish is very well balanced, seasoned perfectly and made with high quality ingredients. I don't have a gluten intolerance, but it's worth noting that this restaurant also offers gluten free pizza and pasta. Appetizers: Our go-to here is the Tuscan Kale salad - now I don't even like kale, but this salad is shredded and dressed in a delicious blend of pistachio pesto you can barely tell it's made of kale and brussels. I taste some acid from either mustard or vinegar and it's finished with pecorino shavings. My wife is obsessed with this dish. We also always get the Charred Octopus which comes with an earthy eggplant puree, made like a hummus and paired with grilled peppers - incredible flavor. I would also recommend the Focaccia & Ricotta, it's simple but tastes super fresh with a nice drizzle of honey.Pasta: The Pappardelle Bolognese is second to none in the city. It is hands down my single favorite dish on the menu. The ragu is made with pork and veal and has a deep richness from the fat that complements the light tomato flavor of the sauce. The Spaghetti Squid Ink is probably my second favorite. It has a really pleasant seafood flavor that gets cut by the acidity of the cherry tomatoes and chili. We eat these two pastas often. Pizza: Emporio's pizzas are absolutely sublime. They have an open kitchen concept with the oven facing the dining room. I don't know how they do it, but you get this perfect light char on the outside of the crust and the bottom is crispy without drying out the toppings. Their dough is rolled out super thin, even thinner than your typical NY slice - and the toppings are generous with a narrow crust. This is a Roman-style pizza and is usually what I prefer vs thick doughy pizzas or even Neapolitans. I'm a sucker for sopressata, so the Spicy Sopressata is an obvious winner for me. They also use a very mild mozzarella that doesn't impart so much cheesiness that it overpowers the ingredients or the sauce. Mains: While not the same as what you would find at a NY steakhouse, the NY Strip Tagliata is a well-executed dish on its own. It comes with roasted garlic and caramelized onion and is sliced for sharing. I demolish this even after crushing apps, pizza and pasta, it's that good. The Branzino Fillet was also nice, but a smaller portion than the steak. Dessert: Finally, I always have room for dessert given my sweet tooth. The Nutella Calzone is a pastry of the gods, just decadent and chocolatey with a chewy dough covering. Meanwhile the Panna Cotta is also excellent if you want to lighter. And the Tiramisu is the best in the city. Generous portion with soaked lady fingers and mouthfuls of mascarpone and cocoa powder. Yes, I have a major sweet tooth. Honorable Mention: I almost exclusively drink Aperol Spritz's when I'm out for dinner (how basic I know). Emporio has a slightly different take on this classic drink. Instead of Aperol, they use Cappalletti, which is also an Italian aperitif but is slightly less sweet/drier, has more of an amber/orange color and an addictive citrus finish. It goes well with all the dishes mentioned above and I had to order my own bottles for home once I found out the name of it! All in all, Emporio is an 11 out of 10. It's the best of the best. I wake up on Mondays looking forward to eating there on the weekend and I dream about gorging on pizza and pasta from my favorite restaurant in NYC. Can't recommend this place enough!!!"

Ribalta Pizza

★★★★☆ 4 (896) • $$

"If you're in Union Sq and need affordable eats without a reservation, Ribalta's got the space and menu to satisfy your needs.We enjoyed a quick, hearty dinner here before watching Wicked. The Madrilena was one of the better "white" 'zas I've tried, and the classic Margherita Rossa didn't skimp on sauce or basil. My Mafaldine Al Ragù Napoletano was perfectly cooked and chock full of hearty red meat. I rarely see mafaldine paired with ragu in the city, so get this dish for the novelty alone."

Nizza

★★★★☆ 3.7 (990) • $$

"We wanted to get a drink before our dinner reservations at 7:45 around the corner. Great little spot. Love the ambiance. Drinks were strong and great. Definitely recommend"

Piacere

★★★★☆ 4.2 (762) • $$

"A great real Italian restaurant. Food is amazing (spaghetti with clams spectacular, pizza amazing, tiramisu excellent and also the tagliata very good). The place has a great vibe, the service is very attentive, genuinely caring of all the guests and well prepared. Highly recommendedPS: also the prices are very competitive for the amazing quality of the food."

Vinnie's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.1 (788) • $

"From local New Yorkers, this pizza slaps! Love the energy & service provided by the staff Don't second guess it, give it a shot, you won't regret it"

Totonno's

★★★★☆ 3.9 (870) • $$

"My bf and I won the Joey special (2 pizzas!) at a FRIENDS-themed event in my hometown, and got Totonno's pizzas delivered all the way to CA. So this review is only based on the taste and quality of the food. The pepperoni pizza wasn't too heavy on the cheese, and it balanced nicely with the sweet tomato sauce and tasty slices of pepperoni. Even the crust had good flavor, a noticeable difference compared to other pizzerias. It was so good, we devoured an entire Large pie in less than 15 minutes, barely talking to each other cuz we were too busy stuffing our faces :D It's not the best pizza I've ever had (there's just way too much competition), but it was still pretty damn good."

Emmy Squared Pizza - Williamsburg

★★★★☆ 3.9 (835) • $$

"Emmy squared pizza hits all the time. This time, I went with some friends after a night out. We tried a few pies, fries, and drinks, all of which were amazing."

Patsy's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4.3 (671) • $$

"Overall this is a small intimate place across from Berkeley Center. Great customer service was super friendly. Husband thought the pizza had no magic dust no frills especially being across from Barkley center where most stbof the players go to get a slice service was excellent tho good conversation fun spot ."

Vic's

★★★★☆ 4.3 (635) • $$$

"My friend and I snagged a last minute reservation here last Friday. I'm so glad that we did! We had to wait a bit to be seated, but they were great about transferring our bar tab to our table once we were seated. I loved the Milano cocktail! Not too sweet and full of flavorTo start, we shared the crudo, per our server's recommendation. It was delicious! So tender, light, and flavorful. I went with the cacio e pepe for my entree and it was classic and delicious! The pasta was perfectly al dente and the sauce had that intense peppery flavor you need in a good cacio e pepe. For the area and quality of the food, I found it to be very well priced. I would definitely come back here! I want to try the pizzas next time!"

Little Italy Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (692) • $

"Mama mía!! Call The Godfather and recommend this place for pizza. Highly recommend. The white, pepperoni and eggplant pizzas were amazing."

MAMA'S TOO!

★★★★☆ 3.6 (881) • $$

"Got lucky and beat the line over the weekend. People began waiting about 20 minutes before open. Line does more pretty quick though.Limited seating on the inside so be prepared to scout out a seat or face eating the messy food outside.Food was out pretty quick. I did have to wait longer for the sandwich since they bake the bread there or something like that. Over all SO YUMMY I will be back!!"

Luigi's Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.3 (607) • $

"When you think of a Brooklyn slice, this is it. I am transplanted NYer living in California, and when I visit NY area, I always have to try essential pizza joints I never experienced when living in NY. Luigi's was one of them. I'm glad I did! I ordered a regular slice and a corner square. Both really excellent. The crisp and chew of both was extremely satisfying the quality of the cheese and taste of the sauce filled with nostalgia. Very even handed, and not salty or greasy. I very much enjoyed both, I would say the square slice needed a bit more cheese to my liking. The interior has great old school time machines vibes. Love it. If i would make one change, honestly it would have nothing to do with the pizza itself, but from the exterior sidewalk. There is a concrete step up/riser pad right outside the front door. I almost tripped going into the shop and leaving, Lol. Perhaps my fault. but I saw someone else do the same thing. I think it needs a painted border or tape or a 'watch your step' stencil before someone has a bad day."

Limelight Coal Brick Oven Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 3.6 (863) • $$

"If you're looking for good pizza, look no further. Their pizza is outstanding! The ingredients are fresh, the tomato sauce is delicious - not overly sour nor overly sweet, the cheese is excellent, and the crust is very good! The staff are always friendly and polite. Service is fast and regular. You can sit at their small bar near the entrance or opt for table sitting which is provided both inside and outside (covered patio area). The interior is decorated with New York memorabilia and oftentimes you'll hear Dean Martin or Frank Sinatra music playing in the background. It's a very comfortable place to relax and enjoy a great meal. I signed up to be a Rewards Member several visits ago. Once a member, then you provide your Member ID before payment with every dine-in or carry-out order to earn points towards rewards and exclusive member offers. Excellent food, exemplary service, and competitive pricing makes Grimaldi's a 5 Star dining experience."

Loring Place

★★★★☆ 4.3 (601) • $$$

"The Loring place served as the perfect dinner spot for guests of all tastes. They had something on the menu for all tastes and you can just tell the quality and source of the food was high. The ambience was great as well and served as the perfect date spot or just an evening of catching up with friends. You can't go wrong with any of their pizzas and the shaved Brussels were delicious. Definitely will be going back to try more menu items next time I'm back in the city."

Pennsylvania 6 NYC

★★★★☆ 4 (657) • $$$

"We had tickets for a NY Rangers playoff game and came for dinner. We walked in to find lifesize cutouts of Ranger players when we walked in! Their bar drinks were quite good, and their pub menu was extensive. We started with Middle Eastern hummus, and then the Penn6 burger and margherita pizza, which were very good. Their apple cobbler hit the spot to finish the meal. Overall, good quality food for a reasonable price (for NYC) and their servers were pleasant and helpful. Atmosphere was a little loud, but hey - it's a bar where everyone was going to the game afterwards! Definitely a good spot for pre-game meals, just two blocks from the Garden!"

Lions & Tigers & Squares Detroit Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (592) • $

"I'm a New Yorker through and through, but I have to admit that Detroit-style pizza is a major contender in the pizza game. It might even... perhaps... possibly... surpass the thin crust for me?! Utter blasphemy, I know.I've been to Lions & Tigers & Squares a few times, and it's one of the best around. The white pizzas are great (the mushroom and mustard ones especially, though the latter's too heavy for my palate after a few bites), but my favorites are their red pizzas, especially the Detroiter. Cherry peppers AND pepperoni AND sausage buried under the cheese? Hell yes. I also like the vodka and meatball pies. Again, I've listed pretty much everything I've ever tried here because it's all so tasty.Half a pie is two slices (and each slice is then also cut in half). With the toppings and pure heft of each bite, one slice's worth is usually more than enough to fill me up. I always love mixing and matching flavors and bringing the other half of my pie home."

Emmett's

★★★★☆ 3.9 (650) • $$

"Happy New Year 2025!! Back for our annual visit ..... last year fell on a Monday ( closed ). Still prefer to original on Mcdougall for the intimate/ never modified space."

Oregano

★★★★☆ 4.2 (560) • $$

"Cute place in Williamsburg Awesome decor Outdoor area available Kid friendly Good and friendly service Ambiance is cool for a meet up with friends or day date Drinks could be better mixed and presented My favorite food item was the prosciutto pizza The artichoke dip was clunky and needs more seasoning A suggested addition to the menu would be French fries for the kids Happy we got to try this place"

East Village Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (584) • $

"Was looking for a pizza spot nearby because I was craving pizza and East Village Pizza definitely hit the spot. Ordered a pepperoni slice as it just came out the oven piping hot. The pepperoni had the perfect amount of crisp and the crust was also thin and crispy. It's a small pizza spot with two tables and a few bar seats. The service was quick and friendly. Will definitely stop by if I am craving a new york slice again."

Masseria dei Vini

★★★★☆ 4.2 (556) • $$$

"I've been dreaming about the veal agnolotti for twenty-four hours. Beautiful place, more romantic (and roomy) than its exterior might suggest, especially when they dim the lights. And, as its name suggests, is THE place for wine lovers. I was also impressed with the staffing in both quantity and quality. There was no waiting for anything. This was a celebration night for my partner and I, and I had carefully read through the reviews and menus of a lot of other Italian restaurants in the area before settling on MdV. I wanted to feel like we'd had an extra special experience and we definitely got that.My only small critique is that I felt like the apple tart didn't live up to the flavor of the other dishes, minus the vanilla ice cream on top. The tart itself was a bit bland and watery. When in doubt, stick with the tiramisu!"

Angelo's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.6 (739) • $$

"Came here after a night out and definitely did not regret it. Thank you Nick for being friendly. The wait time wasn't too bad and my pasta was divine and enjoyed every bite. Ambiance was very casual and great for groups or alone."

La Villa

★★★★☆ 3.9 (625) • $$

"Service was above average to me. I think the bus boys worked very hard and were very attentive. The waiter was equally good, only deduction was that he didn't bring oil for the bread. The restaurant is a family style restaurant, accommodating to all age groups. The food was plentiful and lacked seasoning in my opinion. I found the food to be well prepared but just lacked flavor."

Carmine's Pizzeria

★★★★☆ 4 (577) • $$

"Get the baby pepperoni Sicilian absolute perfection.Cheaper prices for cash payment. Quick service, and lotsssss of choices."

Harry's Italian

★★★★☆ 3.6 (681) • $$

"I continue to patronize and enjoy Harry's Italian on 2 Gold Street. Speaking for myself, I'm guaranteed a good dining experience.My friend and I planned a celebratory birthday dinner--hers in a few days and mine (just last week) and immediately thought of Harry's. The space is large, rustic and cozy and accommodates any occasion. For us, Harry's is like an old friend. An old reliable.Service was attentive including water refill.We skipped appetizers and ordered our main straightaway. I always find myself selecting the Chicken in the Oven with Eggplant. For an additional $6 I included a side of Spaghetti. As you can see from the photo, a huge portion. My friend followed suit only with the Chicken Arrabiata. It looked really good which I tried in the past as well.They don't skimp on portions--my dish included 3 Chicken cutlets. So delicious.A smooth Chianti complemented the meal. I walked out stuffed.From their Fried Calamari and Baked Clams to their Chicken and pasta dishes, Harry's is sure to please. Pizza is good too!Solid."

Osteria Al Doge

★★★★☆ 3.9 (567) • $$$

"Osteria al Doge is one of my favorite NYC restaurants. It has two floors, very nice decor, exceptional service, and.....of course..... a-m-a-z-i-n-g food. Our two entrees were incredible.....Ravioli di Ricotta e Spinaci (homemade ravioli filled with spinach and ricotta cheese, in a butter sage sauce) was so soft, flavorful, and the remaining butter sage sauce was elegantly sponged up with the complimentary buttery bread. The Pollo al Limone (marinated chicken breast with sautéed zucchini and parsley roasted potatoes in a lemon sauce) came with two well seasoned pieces of chicken and I enjoyed how they cut up the zucchini into thin strips, which made it easier to eat. For dessert, we shared the Tortino al Cioccolato (gluten free chocolate cake with moist melting heart and Tahitian vanilla gelato). This was one of the best desserts I've ever had. The cake was M.O.I.S.T., the edges had the ideal crunchiness, and the gelato complemented each bite to complete enjoyment. Please, TRY IT!The Double Espresso, with a side of milk, was the perfect cap to this memorable meal. I cannot recommend Osteria al Doge enough. Come in, in order to be treated like royalty and enjoy a fine meal. Oh, don't forget to make reservations."

Numero 28 Pizzeria - West Village

★★★★☆ 4 (535) • $$

"Excellent flavor , fresh ingredients, fine presentation, variety , delivery . Good crust, amicable and helpful service ."

Bodrum

★★★★☆ 4 (532) • $$

"My friend and I came here for dinner. There was outdoor seating, but we opted for indoor seating. The interior was mostly blue with yellow accents, along with a relaxed, Mediterranean vibe. We were served complimentary yummy, warm, soft bread with olive oil. I ordered the Pirzola, which were grilled Colorado Lamb Chops ($32.95), served with Turkish rice and veggies. The Lamb Chops were cooked to perfection with nice grill marks. They were melt in your mouth tender, juicy, and well seasoned. The rice was also fluffy and flavorful. Vegetables included tomato, carrots, yellow squash and zucchini. I also got to try the Spinach Pizza, which consisted of cream sauce, mozzarella fior di latte, along with shaved Parmesan cheese. This was delightfully cheesy with well done thin crust, however I'm not really a fan of spinach. Service was good. I thought the prices were very reasonable, especially for the Upper West Side. I would definitely like to return to try the sampling platter of all the appetizers, Roasted Branzino, Moussaka, as well as the Pear and Walnut Pizza."

Sacco Pizza

★★★★☆ 4.1 (504) • $

"Stopped by for a slice in the afternoon. The crust is super crispy and light and the meatball topping was quite generous. Not too thick with cheese either, so didn't feel super heavy eating it. The meatballs were a nice addition for some extra flavor but the star is the crust. I ate it while walking - not soggy at all and very easy to eat on the go. I didn't walk into the dining area in the back, but the front counter area is pretty narrow. Prices are slightly cheaper with cash than credit, though not by much. My slice cost $4.75 - not the cheapest, but quite worth the price for the increased quality."

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

★★★★☆ 4.4 (394) • $

"My first NYC pizza was the best NYC pizza. Great vibes in here too. Go get em! The buffalo chicken smacks"

Zia Maria Little Italy

★★★★☆ 4 (469) • $$

"This restaurant was fantastic!!! Our best food choice was the mushroom risotto. The rigatoni was our 2nd fav. Followed by the bolognese and the fig pizza. Seriously ... we were still full the next day! Hands down.... Their lemoncello was exceptional and we dreamt of it for days on end! The Hugo Spritz is not on the menu but made perfectly!Great service. Crowded so make reservations!!"

Malaparte

★★★★☆ 4.1 (446) • $$

"Malaparte has a strong reputation in the area so figured to give it a go. The place is small and tables are tight but that is nyc. We started with the beet salad and tuna salad app. Both were delicious. The rigatoni pesto and paparedelle bolognese were lovely. Could have been a little more al dente but all good. The pork chop special was a play on milanese style but the pork chop bad a parmesan topping. It was good as well. There were only two desserts that didn't jump out to us so didn't go for it. Wine selection was good too. I would recommend and come back. 4 stars."

Serafina Italian Restaurant Broadway

★★★☆☆ 3.1 (768) • $$

"A true gem for Italian food lovers! The ambiance is lively and inviting, with a perfect balance of casual and chic. The pasta dishes are always good and flavorful. The service is average but friendly. Tried the chicken parm this time. It was good. Didn't really taste chicken compared to sauce and breading. Would come back."

Table 87 - Gowanus

★★★★☆ 4 (459) • $$

"We ordered the sausage Bianco pizza of the day and the margarita pizza. Nice ambience, great condiments, but the pizza is missing something. Specifically the crust doesn't have the right texture. It's flavorless and without chewiness. I make my own pizza at home using natural yeast and 00 flour. The pizza at this establishment tastes like it was made with regular white flour, like the kind you use for saltines. Flat and boring. They should upgrade the flour and let the dough rise to create flavor."

Uncle Paul's Pizza

★★★★☆ 3.8 (500) • $$

"This is why I love my city!!!!! I have not been to Uncle Paul's Pizza for 35 years .... Yes I said 35 years. But I went there today and they didn't disappoint. It was AMAZING!!!! don't sleep on one of the best pizzerias in the city."