Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - 35th St

I found this place on a whim through social media -Took one look at the shakes and said we need to try this place! Our server was super nice and very patient with us while we combed through the menu. He even helped explain a few things. We didn't have a reservation and we were able to get a table right away. I imagine that in the summertime that's not the case based on what other people have said in other reviews. I ordered the cheeseburger salad and the beef was so juicy, cooked just the way I like it! The shakes- whoa- totally blew my mind! We should have waited to order our shakes but since we ordered it with our food, they came out before our meals. The ambiance was maybe modern hipster if that's even a thing- but the vibe was spot on! We will definitely come back when we are in town again!

After work, our team visited Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer on 35th Street, and it was an exceptional experience. From the moment we stepped in, Rebecca the hostess greeted us with a big smile and accommodated us right away! We were seated in the back, where a wall adorned with cassettes immediately caught our eye, giving the dining room a nostalgic 90's vibe that we loved.The menu offered so many delicious choices and we ordered right away! The onion rings were crispy and flavorful, and I thoroughly enjoyed the Wagyu Steakhouse Burger, which was cooked to perfection. Each one of us ordered different burgers, and every dish was delicious.To top it off, we shared a Cookies and Cream CrazyShake, and Philip, the General Manager, generously treated us to an additional Cheesecake CrazyShake. Both disappeared quickly lol Our server was attentive and knowledgeable.Thank you, Philip, and your team, for providing such a great experience. We will be back soon.

My friend was visiting from IL with her son and had read about Black Tap as a "must eat" while in NYC. We were a total of 3 adults and 3 kids and walked in on a freezing Saturday evening around 5:30pm. Unfortunately, they did not have a table available for us until 7:30pm, but they were able to accommodate us with random bar seating (we sat separately, but near one another).It worked out as the three kids sat at the low-bar seating with low stools and the three of us sat at the high tables.The service was quite good for how busy they were, and even though there were discrepancies in our order once it arrived, they were quick to fix it and even took one of the dishes off the bill as a courtesy since the mistake was on their end. The food was what you'd expect from a burgers and shake place - so good! I loved that it was kid-friendly, but elevated for adults. We ordered the following, and honestly - I would recommend everything!Fried pickles, hotGuac and chipsMexico City Burger with Falafel pattyCrispy chicken sandwichHot chicken sandwichOnion RingsFriesBrooklyn Blackout ShakeVanilla ShakeEspresso Martini

The burgers at Black Tap are delicious and well exceeded my expectations!! I loved the Texan burger and the wagu steakhouse burger! The milkshakes are perfect if you have a big sweet tooth! The drink selection and ambiance left me wanting more, but I would definitely return!

Stopped by this SoHo hot spot and we not disappointed. Got a table right away, ordered the Guacamole and Chips and the adventure started. Good stuff, our waitress was super friendly and made suggestions which I really like. Ordered the Frita Cubana, the Tenessee Burger, the Chicken Sandwich and a Wagyu Burger. All had excellent flavor and cooked like we ordered. Great spot.

Used to like this place but was very disappointed the last time I went. First of all, came in as a group with some more people coming in later. The restaurant was mostly empty but they insisted on the entire party being present before getting seated. The issue was the others were going to be very late and we just wanted to sit and eat. I'd understand if the place was full, but it was basically empty. The way the female host spoke to us was also very rude.Next, they messed up our orders. First my milkshake order didn't get recorded and then my friends' orders got mixed up and as a result it ended up taking a long time for their food to come out.Food was still decent but the bad service really ruined the experience. The tablet tip was also annoying where they watched as you tipped to pressure you to tip more despite the horrendous service. Probably won't be coming back or recommending this place any more.

The milkshake was interesting. I appreciate the presentation but it tasted very average, like regular strawberry ice cream. Nothing special about the sandwich or burger.It's a popular spot, people kept filtering in and out so the service isn't best either. The ambience is what you'd expect from a busy burger joint, loud.

Ole reliable. Second visit to this sure thing spot. Jenna provided outstanding service. Served dinner with a smile. Amazing burger selection...there is no wrong choice. Always a hit!If you have a sweet tooth, wait until you try one of the amazing shakes. Quite creative. Music is on point. Hard to not enjoy the music while devouring your meal. Ambiance is cool for all ages.

Friendly staff, great environment. Recommend indoor dining experience with friends, family, co-workers, and others. I'd pass on the fried pickles as the batter falls off the pickles and doesnt have a crunch to it. Brussel sprouts were semi burnt enhancing the bitter flavor, and mozzarella sticks were not stringy. The buns of the burger were soggy from the moisture of the toppings and quite salty.

Amazing food presentation I didn't get the chance to take a picture to the falafel burguer but it was delicious, waiters are also very nice and fast.The place has such a nice vibes in general.Totally recommend and I would come back for sure.