Bay Ridge Fish Bar

- haven't had a bad meal yet- I love the garlic linguine Shrimp, scallop, lobster, you name it- I love the crab cakes - I loved the shrimp tacos - I love all the soups- the menu is quite expansive - free coffee is a plus- I loved the fries, although I haven't had the vinegar - very friendly service

Oh my gosh the shrimp rice balls and the lobster roll and the calamari were absolutely amazing. I could not stop raving about the shrimp rice balls. The texture and fresh flavor for everything you can possibly order here is perfection. The lobster rolls are filled- they absolutely do not skimp out on the lobster!The service was great and Mo was very kind. Will be back for the seafood pasta and the fish!

Discover the rich flavors of expertly selected and fresh seafood. The service is good.

Right as you walk in there's fresh seafood waiting for you. I was greeted immediately with a friendly face. Because I follow them on Instagram I ordered their special they highlighted for that Sunday: a shrimp burrito. Hubs got the lobster roll and we grabbed a seat outside in the back. We regretted the decision only because it was colder than we thought and my sweater was not doing its job. My guy kept us updated on our food and apologized for the wait but it was so understandable cuz there was a cute (birthday?) party and the kitchen was hustling to get their orders in. It's a small-ish space; party table in the back for about 6, table in front for 2, bar stools by the register for 4, and outdoor seating could be for about 10. But when we wanted to move, they made sure to clear the table and have it ready. Service is so attentive and kind that it felt rare. Okay, the FOOD: that lobster roll was at capacity and the fries were perfect. The shrimp burrito had shrimp in nearly every bite. The size was enough where I could finish but also feel stuffed but also could walk. We couldn't stop there. We had to take home some appetizers that they have prepared in the fridge. While their homemade hummus looked gorgeous, we opted for mac and cheese and the crab empanadas. I also had some pieces of salmon broiled. All this seafood and a couple of drinks came out to be under $100. I'll definitely be back!

Really nice place and a welcome addition to Bay Ridge. I ordered the crab cakes to go and requested they cook them for me, which they did. I love me some crab cakes and I hardly ever see them anywhere. These did not disappoint. They were absolutely scrumptious and I will definitely order them again. The owner was very nice and the place was immaculate. Also to note they have a lovely garden for outdoor dining. Highly recommend!

Incredible hot lobster roll!! Finally found a good one in Brooklyn. Just like the ones from New Smyrna Beach, but even MORE lobster- i devoured it. Great service too. Started off browsing the fresh seafood, but then the young lady read my mind and gave me a menu. Beautiful decor . A great new addition to 3rd Ave!

I revisited the Bay ridge Fishbar. I was craving their Fried Shrimp & Calamari Platter. This time i got it with Taboula. Sooo good. Fresh, flavorful and filling!

Flavor is fab.with fish cooked to order. It's a cute spot with a nice variety of seafood plus chowders and bisque. I sat in their lovely backyard and had a feast. I ordered mahi mahi and I think it was sautéed not grilled. They have a mufaletta sauce I put on top plus roasted broccoli with garlic & oil.Very delicious but missing some nice bread to sop it up. Total: $23.67 & would eat with bread when they have it. PS Plastic cups in 2023 are a no- no.

Hit or Miss? Succulent lobster rolls, beautifully charred octopus, great service. Need I say more? I say this place is a hit.

I found an interesting seafood bisque recipe that we decided to make for New Year's Eve. Definitely a splurge for two senior citizens.My husband bought all the fish at this place. He asked if they had any seafood stock and was excited to hear that they had their own fish stock. The only liquid in the bisque was the seafood stock. There was no salt called for. So my husband spent a few hours slicing and dicing, and the bisque was so incredibly salty that it was inedible! So it was a really crappy way to start the new year by spending $80 on fish and ingredients and then to wind up eating tuna fish on crackers for New Year's Eve.If this place is going to sell their own stock, they should make sure that it's good stock because as anyone knows, bad stock can ruin an entire recipe.