Baxter Street Pizza
Baxter Street Pizza
Slice of cheese ($3.50) and pepperoni ($4)
Vodka sauce pizza on the left. Regular cheese pizza on the right. Both fantastic!
The New Yorker and Cheese pizza slices.
The New Yorker and Cheese pizza slices.
Mama Slice
Name up in lights
Margherita & Vodka slices
Spicy rigatoni and chicken bacon ranch
Pizza selections
Outside
Vodka Slice
Slice
Special
Menu
Plain slice
Al H.
Sep 11, 2022
Grand opening pricing at $2 / slice. Nice New York style slices. Crispy and oily with great tasting cheese. What's not to like?Near the Manhattan court houses.
Read More
Jenny Z.
Jul 8, 2022
I was on my way to work one day and I stumbled across this pizza shop on Baxter. So I figured I'd get a small bite before I start my shift. There were so many good choices but I couldn't choose.. A worker recommended the vodka slice and OMG, It did not disappoint at all! Finger licking good! Thank you for the awesome service by the way. I'll definitely come back with my co workers.
Read More
Cervante B.
Oct 10, 2022
A delicious pizza, with great flavor. Highly recommend the New Yorker! Customer service was good as well.
Read More
Walter T.
Aug 26, 2022
Was in da' hood , and figured I give a try here . Pizza looks soo go but I give it a try for slice . I had $3 on cash . But the slice cause about $3.50 pulse tax . They let me slide here so I only paid the $3 . Not to oily but it's also very then . I would say they ok ... I've had better . Very NEW here. Probably be back if there open late new The bars in Da hood.
Read More
Bobby F.
Sep 23, 2022
Happy to have a legitimate NY pizza slice in the Chinatown area! 2 cheese slices + 1 soda is $6.50 for their lunch special. Great deal!
Read More
Leslie W.
Nov 10, 2022
The vodka sauce pizza was amazing! Quick service and food choices to suit and grab a slice (or two).
Read More
Seth R.
Apr 26, 2023
I ordered a plain pie thru the app at 8:00. It said the pizza would be here between 8:29-8:44. Its now 9:10 and no pizza. They're not answering messages or the telephone AND Google says that they're closed now. So they took our money for the pizza & delivery fee & tip & another fee $34+ and then closed up shop without a word.
Read More
Jon O.
Oct 10, 2022
Hidden spot and away from the madness that's on Canal St and Mulberry right next to the park. Great slices and prices. Wouldn't have known this place was here due to the construction across the street but glad to found this spot. A must go.
Read More
Ray A.
Sep 13, 2022
New place on Baxter St by the courthouses. They had a great wall (A/C) unit to keep me sane from the humidity. Slices were piping hot, crust was crisp. Not necessarily a sit down place unless you use the condiment counters on the wall and stand, or the small table. Not sure if the outdoor dining shed is for this place as well.The other pizzas weren't ready yet (came shortly after opening at 11AM), but were being put out when I passed by an hour later.
Read More
Will E.
May 30, 2023
Returned recently and had the Margherita & the Vodka slice. Both tasted very good; they were crispy and well balanced in terms of cheese and sauce. Thumbs up again.
Read More
