Baggios Pizzeria
Baggios Pizzeria
Spaghetti with marinara
One $5 Pepperoni Slice
This is the disgusting mess that was delivered.
Menu
Pizza Margarita - Personal 12"
Finished meal
Sideways pizza?
Pizza!
Pizza
a pepperoni pizza
food, pizza
food, pizza
food, pizza
pizza, food
outside
David P.
Oct 4, 2024
No issues with nut allergies for their standard offerings.I got a slice of pepperoni pizza just to say I had a New York slice while walking by. It was good - excellent texture on the thin crust, sufficient toppings, nice with Parmesan cheese. One slice was definitely not enough for a lunch - I could probably eat 2-3 easily. Was it $5 for a slice good? I wouldn't say so, but that seems on par with other places like Joe's now, and there's minimal wait comparatively. So for NYC prices, it's solid.
Read More
Tiffany H.
Jun 20, 2024
Great addition to the neighborhood Fries are very good crispy and only $5! I had the personal cheese pie $14 w 6 slices. Thin crust. Very good. Very friendly staff.
Read More
Randall M.
Jan 10, 2025
I stopped in to grab some lunch on a very cold day. The Sicilian slices looked good, so I ordered two. The slices were good, not great. $10.90 with a can of soda is a good deal for Manhattan. Thank U next!
Read More
Chloe C.
Sep 19, 2024
Great local pizza joint with authentic NY slices! My favorites were the white and tie die slices, but everything looked amazing. You get a free can of soda with the purchase of any 2 slices which was a nice surprise! The workers were very kind, and the slices were ready quickly. I'll definitely be back!
Read More
Steven S.
May 22, 2024
Saw the excellent reviews and placed a delivery order through their website. What a mistake. The pizza arrived within the time specified by the restaurant. Ordered a custom personal pizza with a few toppings for about $26.00. The pizza was a cold, soggy, inedible mess. The toppings and the cheese fell off the pizza, and was lying on one side of the box, which indicted to me it was tilted during the delivery. I tried to fix it and tasted a slice. It was bland and not worth further effort. I threw the pizza in the garbage and made a sandwich. I live a few blocks from this pizzeria. It doesn't take much to deliver a pizza a few blocks in good condition. Lousy pizza. Lousy service. A colossal waste of money.
Read More
Adeline C.
Mar 8, 2024
OMG! Thin pizza by the slice? Yes please!!! Just walking by but the min I walked up to the counter I see how thin the pizza is and I am sold!! So good!
Read More
Ron A.
Feb 9, 2024
I'll have to eat in to give a proper review, but their delivery came piping hot on a cold day. Very thin crust as other reviews had said; only the tip sagged, so a fairly crisp crust. Their sauce is on the sweet side if that is pertinent to your preferences...a decent ratio of cheese to topping, which is very pertinent to my preferences. The two slices left over were my breakfast the next day, passing the cold pizza test. I look forward to dining in there.
Read More
Angelica T.
Jul 16, 2024
Unassuming but SOLID NY pizza. 2 slices also gets you a free 12 oz soda pop of choice. Thin crust is perfectly crisp and non greasy with the most satisfying crunch to round out the toppings of choice. Slices tried: Margherita and Mushroom for $4-5 a slice? Can't be be beat.Stop scrolling and just do it
Read More
Vanessa S.
Aug 29, 2024
Low key mg husband and I are pizza snobs and I have to say it was Delicious!!! wow better than joes pizza!!! Loved it also amazing spaghetti !!
Read More
charlize s.
Dec 28, 2024
Amazing service! Went above and beyond truly. I highly recommend this restaurant. Pizza is great as well, great pricing.
Read More
