Angelo's Pizza
Angelo's Pizza
Grilled Salmon
Margherita with pepperoni.
Old-Fashioned Margherita Pizza with sausage and onion
a slice of pizza on a plate
food, pizza
a slice of pepperoni pizza
a slice of pepperoni pizza
a slice of pepperoni pizza
a person holding a half eaten sandwich
a slice of chocolate cake on a plate
a patio with tables and chairs
salads, outside
food, grilled fish
Outdoor Dining
Old-Fashioned Margherita Pizza
Outside
Outdoor seating
food, pizza
sushi and sashimi, interior
Old Fashioned Margherita
food
Christy C.
Nov 8, 2024
We had a quick dinner (30 minutes) before a Broadway show.It was perfect, fast, delicious and authentic.We ordered the individual margarita and white pies to share between 3 of us. It was perfect because we were hungry. Service was nice, the ambiance is a typical Italian pizza spot. Definitely check this place out if you need something rest but tasty before a show!
Read More
Miranda M.
Sep 15, 2024
My family and I dined here last night after seeing a show on Broadway and I was pleasantly surprised at how hot and fresh the food was!We shared a Salmon Tartare, the Eggplant Rollatini and a 17" Margherita Pizza, all of which were great. The crust was ok, but the sauce and cheese were wonderful. I loved the eggplant dish which had a generous amount of sauce. We shared a pitcher of sangria, which quickly watered itself down and I can't say I'd recommend getting that drink.I'd come here again after a show on Broadway - perfect for a late night bite!
Read More
H E.
Feb 8, 2025
I really do hate leaving a bad review. Place was clean. Service lovely. Mixed salad was great. But the pizza was not good at all. It needed spices. It looked good but wasn't crisp in the center. Lacked salt. The sauce tasted like nothing. Should have kept walked after seeing three stars. I really wanted to like it, but would not come back.
Read More
Pete M.
Dec 22, 2024
Walked by, immediately ran in. The smells...amazing. The ambiance...buzzy, the service....quick and attentive!!! The food was great and full of flavor:!!I would highly recommend giving Angelos and try. I'm from Arizona, and we don't have this quality of Italian cuisine back home!!!
Read More
Jason F.
Dec 6, 2024
Food was rather tasty and quick once the order was in. Pasta e Fagioli with bacon was interestingly and deliciously creamy. The salad was fresh and the dressing was unique. Service was polite, but a little slower than I would have preferred, water guy was on point though. Nice cozy warm space to enjoy a fine Italian meal.
Read More
Raymond S.
Nov 17, 2024
Good pie, nice restaurant. Service was a little slow. Coal fired ovens. It looks small from the street and when you first enter but there is a large dining room up the stairs.
Read More
Oscar Daniel R.
Nov 5, 2024
Came here after a night out and definitely did not regret it. Thank you Nick for being friendly. The wait time wasn't too bad and my pasta was divine and enjoyed every bite. Ambiance was very casual and great for groups or alone.
Read More
Nicki M.
Oct 16, 2024
Loved the margherita pizza! Crust was nice a crisp with a soft inside. Fresh toppings and plenty of basil! The crème brûlée was a bit odd. It was covered in mushy berries instead of the classic torched sugar topping that I love. I would order the pizza again and not the dessert. The service was good. I love the vibe, downstairs is small and charming with nice street views to people watch and upstairs had lots of room. I will say they did a great job of making sure we were out in time for our show too!
Read More
Matthew W.
Jun 25, 2024
Not the best pizza I've ever had, especially in NY, but definitely not bad either. Tried a split pie of sausage and pepperoni; I think Angelo's does a great job balancing the amount of cheese, meat, and bread in every slice. Their sauce is also rather tasty too.Overall, I wouldn't seek this place out, but if I'm in the area, I'd go back.
Read More
Billy F.
Dec 16, 2024
We came here after seeing a show. The service was great and the pizzas were really tasty. The music was a little bit too loud though. We were a table of seven and it was difficult to hear over the music. Another thing, no free refills on the sodas... Overall, it was close to the theaters and great for what we needed it for.
Read More
