Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

In town for the big holiday week we had Angelos on our list due to one prolific social media maven. We all know the rules and in this case he marked Angelo's in the 9s which is unheard of for him. (9.3 iirc).So we went and we were fortunate to get seats right away. The place looks decent inside with movie pictures of pizza joints (e g. Do the Right Thing and Groundhog Day) on the walls.We sorted through the menu and found a few other options. The service was fine with one waitress, a little more abrupt with another assisting. But on the whole no complaints there.We got a basket of complimentary bread to try with olive oil, Parmesan and pepper as desired. They were little diamonds of bread, tasty but nothing too extraordinary.We ordered the sciciliano [sp?] and ceasar salads which were more than enough for the five of us - as opposed to locking into a larger, more expensive, family salad which would have been just one of those choices.The pizza came, half cheese and half pepperoni and it was, indeed, pretty damn good. We were really hungry so it wouldn't have mattered much. Is it the best NY style pizza? Maybe up there, but NY pizza isn't my favorite anyway. So we're gonna say it was really good.I found the fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, which we shared, to be really great too. The overall price tag for the meal was actually reasonable for NY too. So a 4.6 earns a 5 for Angelo's.

There was a long line waiting to get in and we were hesitating to wait but their host was doing an amazing job, he said it'd take about 20min but he'd try to make it faster. We got to watch how he was organizing the tables and have everyone on line to be seated in order and took exactly 20min to have us seated, even though the store was so busy. It was very impressive.The place looked small but I believe they have 2nd floor. They might have outdoor seating when it gets warmer.Their pizza was worth waiting, and their Pappardelle Alla Bolognese pasta was great as well. If I ever crave pizza, I'd love to go back.

The pizza here never fails! When my in-laws were visiting, they were staying at an Air BNB across the street. It was very cold one night and we couldn't get a table at Pazza Notte but we had pizza on the mind, so we popped into Angelo's and were able to snag a table. We started with tasty calamari (which was likely frozen but still tasted okay) and then had some great pizza. The tables were a bit tight but the food was great and the service was fast and friendly. I will note that Angelo's pizzas are best when you eat them in....because the crust is thin and crisp, they don't travel well. They are still good, don't get me wrong, but they can get a little soggy from the steam so my recommendation is to order and eat on site.

Found this place via Yelp since my friend and I were in the mood for pizza. Came here late afternoon on a Saturday and was able to get seated right away. The place has two floors for dining. Started with the fried calamari ($18) which was solid. Ordered a large Roni (pepperoni) pie ($28.95) and it was really good. By the time we left, there was a pretty long line to get seated. I would recommend this place if your in the mood for good pizza * Restroom on second floor* Bar available

Really excellent pizza. Came here with my brother based on a recommendation he got, and it was definitely worth it. We wanted to be health conscious (a relative term), but we wanted to try a couple of the pizzas. We were able to get half and half on a single pizza, and big shoutout to the staff for making that possible for us. We got half white pie, half regular with pepperoni. They were the good kind of pepperoni, the cuppy kind! Both sides of the pizza were great, the bottom was nice and well done, and the toppings were perfectly flavored and balanced. I could've eaten the whole pizza myself. The atmosphere is very cozy with the tables being pretty tight up against each other. The staff was super helpful and efficient, helping us get out with time to get onto our next activity. Overall great experience. Highly recommend!

I've been to Angelos a few times and the food is always delicious!The restaurant vibe is good and the staff is also very friendly and welcoming.From pizza to pasta to salads to appetisers everything is delicious!If you find yourself craving some really good Italian fare Angelos the place to go! You will NOT be disappointed.SALUT A TUTTI! Che piatto fantastico! Grazie Mile Angelo's

Saw this little place and decided to give it a try and we were not disappointed food was good and service was really good even though it was packed . Our server and helper were always attentive and never let us run out of water . The pizza is why we came and it was very delicious and had that New York Pizza taste Right on Point !! It was perfect for us because we stayed at West 57th Hilton Club. Give this place a try you won't be disappointed .

We were visiting NYC staying across the street. Just wanted to get a couple pizzas and a salad to take out. I had a Peroni at the bar. Great friendly staff. Great service. Nice vibe. Lots of regulars here. So you know it's great. One vegan (just sauce and veggies) and one sausage pepperoni and anchovies. Outstanding. Crisp chewy slightly charred crust. Large salads. We had Caesar. A perfect place for fast high quality pizza and sides. Will be back.

Amazing pizza! In one word, delicious!! Highly recommend. The flavor and coal oven make this crust and the sauce is on point.

Excellent service and delicious food!!! Attentive and friendly servers without being intrusive. A great find for us occasional tourists