Amore Pizza Cafe
Amore Pizza Cafe
6. Supreme Pizza
Cheese Slice Pizza
10. Shrimp Parmigiana
Menu
Margarita Pizza
Menu
menu and prices
Inside
a man standing in front of the counter
Classic Cheese Pizza
menu and prices
Slice of Regular Cheese Pizza
menu and prices
Menu
Inside - menu
Menu
Pepperoni Pizza Roll
Beef Patties
interior
food, pizza
Inside
Greasy. Tasteless. Did not care for the "steak" meat.
interior
Beef patty
Anthony H.
Dec 8, 2024
I was in the area and wanted a slice of pizza because how do you go to New York and not; so I stopped in after reading other reviews. The restaurant is what you'd expect from a pizzeria and the atmosphere is average energy, nothing loud or quiet about it. The service was quick, just like NYC and the prices were on par with what you'd expect. I will admit that after I ate my slice, I did get another because damn it was good. When you've been to so many restaurants in New York, it's hard for a restaurant to stand out but pizza wise but Amore Pizza Cafe does. They're menu has a lot of items on it so you should take your time. However, I believe no matter what you get, it's going to be great. I would definitely recommend Amore Pizza Cafe for the food, the atmosphere and the reasonable priced food.
Read More
Margaret S.
Sep 23, 2024
I like this pizza spot. It's conveniently located on the corner of 58th and 9th ave.I always order on seamless it's just easier for me and I'm always in and out.So far I've enjoyed their mozzarella sticks, garlic bread, beef patties and their slices with pepperoni and extra cheese. Everything was perfect.The mozzarella sticks were large and cheesy, the garlic bread was garlicky, the beef patty was meaty, and the slices were so big and extra cheesy; just the way I like them.I definitely try to come here at least once a week to get my carb fix.See you soon Amore Pizza!
Read More
Rosanna V.
Sep 10, 2024
10 out of 10 . Buffalo hot wings are delicious.Prices are reasonable.It's a nice walk from Columbus Circle and Central Park.
Read More
Vanessa F.
Jan 30, 2025
This place gave me food poisoning; called months ago to make sure their bolognese sauce wasn't cooked with cheese (allergy) and it wasn't. All of a sudden, after the last two recent orders I was crazy sick - I called to ask again, and the guy who answered said yes, they're made with Parmesan. When I told him what happened, he put me on hold and then said they're not made with cheese. Yeah, right.Also, this is the only pizza place in NYC that doesn't serve vegan options. What's the opposite of Amore?
Read More
Randall M.
Jan 27, 2025
I popped into Amore Pizza Cafe to grab a late night snack. I ordered two Grandma slices, and then I grabbed a seat. The slices were very fresh, and very tasty. My bill with a bottle of Stewarts was $14.18. I'll be back!
Read More
Veronica V.
Aug 4, 2024
I used to go to school around here some years ago and didn't remember this spot being here but I'm glad it's here now. I was super hungry after the ballet and wanted something quick preferably pizza. I found this spot on Yelp thank goodness and it was open late. I got a margarita pizza and they prepared it quick. Wow what a slice and the price was right thank goodness there are still some reasonably priced places in manhattan. There was plenty of seating too. If you're in the area check them out
Read More
Amit M.
Mar 3, 2024
Small shop that sells pizza, sandwiches, and pasta. The pizza is decent pizza here, you can grab by the slice.
Read More
Bruce M.
Sep 20, 2024
Good pizza and Italian food. They always make you feel welcomed there. Try their Chicken Parmigiana Vodka Sauce Sub.
Read More
Jooky D.
Dec 20, 2024
The Good: A large selection of delicious pizzaThe Bad: A huge menu of other things no-one orders The Ugly: My wife eating pizza with a fork and knifeWe were going to go to Bleeker Street Pizza because it is supposed to be the "best pizza in town" but an Uber ride would have cost more than the dinner. So we ended up at this place not too far from our hotel at Lincoln Center. A classic "pizza by the slice" restaurant that you see on every street corner. Pick your slices and wait a few minutes for them get re-heated. I you dare to venture away from the many varieties of pizza available they can accommodate you. This place is on a busy corner so if you like people watching this is a good place for that.
Read More
Bernard U.
Oct 24, 2024
The price of a slice of Pizza is absurdly expensive The people working are ok but cannot understand English
Read More
