New York Prime

A wonderful place for catching up with friends and a delicious meal.The drinks are top notch - I had a perfect Martini, the appetizers were a hit - order the rib, and the mains are why you come - my filet was perfect! The sides are a good compliment however I chose to focus more on my filet after filling up on appetizers so order accordingly.The staff were great here and very helpful to accommodate my colleague's dietary needs.The establishment was very laid back and you never felt rushed enjoying yourself. This was my first visit and the vibe was chill.So if you are in the area this is a great spot to check out and the valet service is a nice touch.

I visited New York Prime with my large family. We had an unforgettable experience of great flavored food and service on a weeknight. Service: We were met by a flexible staff who accommodated our large party for a late night dinner. Initially, they were going to seat us at two different tables. We explained that this would not be ideal and we were hoping to sit all together and they made it happen without difficulty. Food and drinks were brought to our table timely and our waiter very enthusiastically checked on us regularly and showed great personality! The music was a lot of fun-80s rock and pop. Food: The Crab cakes, Steak, and Lamb were all cooked to perfection and juicy with a traditional grilled flavor. I did not have to add salt. All sides are family style, served hot. We ordered the creamed spinach (very rich and creamy- too rich for my liking), fries (colossal fried potato wedges), fettuccine Alfredo, seafood bisque, broccolini, and salad. Great wine list and cocktails to complement. I left very full and would gladly come back!

Hubby and I went on our date night, and completely enjoyed our dining experience. We got the absolute best service from Colton. He was so delightful and accommodating, and just a joyful presence. The food, oh my word. We are on a journey to find the best steakhouse in ATL, and oh my, the running is tight! We've had some phenomenal steaks & NY Prime did not disappoint!! All things considered, it was reasonably priced too...!!!

I've lived in Atlanta for many years and never had the opportunity to try this place. Last night, I went with my family and friends and had the most amazing dinner. We ordered the crab cakes as an appetizer and they were absolutely delicious. For our entrées, we ordered several different cuts of the steak. I personally have the New York prime steak, but Oscar style. That is when they put crab meat, asparagus, and hollandaise sauce with your steak. It was absolutely delicious. My dad was the only one who didn't order a steak, And instead, he had the Seabass. He is still talking about the Seabass 24 hours later. Safe to say we will be back soon. Our waiter's name was Leo and he was so nice to my family. The place is expensive, but the quality matches the price.

I had the best 40th birthday dinner here the other night. Genuinely had a great server named Jeff and was catered to like I was a celebrity. He knew his cuts of meat to the T. My husband is selective and Jeff really explained how the different meats are cut and broiled and cooked. Start with the shellfish bisque. It's heavy but oh so delicious. Also had the wedge salad and I have to say it's one of the best I've ever had. It's huge too. My main course was the seabass. Portion size is more than generous but the flavor is unreal. We also did a one pound loaded baked potato and it was MY FAVORITE PART! It was to die for amazing! For dessert Jeff brought out a cookie and some ice cream which was delicious. I honestly wish I ordered the key lime pie to go because I've been dreaming of it since. Do yourself a favor because you won't regret it, go there to dine! Asparagus is delicious and my champagne was so crisp! Ambience is delightful and cozy. Ask for Jeff!

I'm speaking only on the chocolate cake which is a must get either for a dessert only or to take home. It's a massive slice and comes with ice cream. So filling and flavorful.

Where do i begin. The food was to DIE FOR. We had oysters Rockefeller, Caesar salad, lamb chops, delmonico steak, cheesy mashed potatoes & Brussel sprouts. Service from Aidan was impeccable. House margarita was thirst quenching. And let me tell you about the butter cake. It was mouth watering. We will definitely be back.

New York Prime is my favorite steak house in Atlanta, hands down. It's tucked away in a little corner of Buckhead, but it boasts a big presence with its ambiance and delicious food. The service is above average with exceptional attention to detail. While every waiter we've had has literally served us with perfection, Leo always takes care of us and we know that dining with him means a truly beautiful evening. I don't really want to write a review because I don't want to give up the best kept secret --- but don't waste your time with any other steakhouse! You can't go wrong with this classic choice.

This was my first time at NY Prime Minister the staff was friendly. Cracking jokes and making everyone feel comfortable. I am usually hesitant to take suggestions when it comes to the menu, but the waiter hit it out of the park with the stone crabs to start and the tomahawk to share.

Wow the food was really good. They recommend their steaks be done with this Pittsburgh Crust? It's a good recommendation. Very juicy. The service staff were so nice. Loved them. They also recommended the drink, which I liked. Can't quite remember the name (the fuzzy lemon, or fuzzy wuzzy). Loved it. And of course the ambiance was wonderful. It was a nice birthday dinner for my friend.