Midtown Antique Mall

This shop had a lot of antiques to look at and buy, but the prices were incredibly high for some of the items that we looked at. It was fun to shop around and find some nostalgic items, but we were very unlikely to buy anything because the items were priced at least 3x the amount they went for originally! There were other antique shops in the area that had better priced items than this one.

There is a lot to take in, with multiple levels & tons of filled display cases. I ran out of time. I did spot several things of interest & will hafta make another trek out to finish up. Some items were quite reasonably priced, while others were inexplicably high. For example: I stumbled on an 70d/80s era non-brand-name dress with horribly stained armpit areas. It was priced at $38. Anywho, I went with 3 as an average of the inventory (5), pricing (2), service (3)I'd say it's worth the stop - you may find something you didn't know you need.

We had just left American Gothic in town, so my hopes were pretty high. This place let me down. They have a lot, LOT, of glass cases. Which aren't my fave. This shop has tons of Art Deco, Victorian, vintage toys and primitive items. Not a whole lot of MCM art/glass pieces. They had tons of Fenton, expensive. Same with the anchor hocking. Lamps were up there in price. Pieces were a tad dirty in the non super expensive rooms, but I did find a couple gems in those spaces. I'll just have to clean them. There were sales going on in some of the booths.The people at the front desk were super great too!

I've been to every antique shop in Stillwater -- the Midtown Antique Mall is the best.I usually associate an antique "mall" with 100s of vendors and thousands of little knickknacks. Midtown, indeed, has 100s of vendors and thousands of knickknacks. BUT they're huge, 3 full stories. AND they aren't afraid of big stuff. The top floor is full furniture and other large items.Overall, I was impressed with Midtown. I like the organization, the layout, and the presentation. The whole complex is very well lit. I thought the prices were fair. I also got some primo customer service from the front desk.If you only have time to stop at one antique store in Stillwater, make sure you drop by Midtown.Thanks, Midtown Antique Mall!-Daddy Maxx Retro

Three stories of quality antiques! This place is a collection of the cutest curated collections around! The top floor is full of fantastic vintage furniture- I could spend hours there! The shop attendants are very knowledgeable and helpful too!

Lots and lots of inventory so be prepared to spend some time there, especially if you are looking for specific item! Great selection of furniture in the 3rd floor but pricey-they would move more big inventory if prices weren't so high on these items.

According to my professional opinion, this store is truly remarkable. There are numerous antiquities to choose from! And it seemed there are endless floors to the huge variety of amazing, unique items here. Unlike the shit hole pawn shop down the road Stillwater Antique Mall claiming to be an antique store, Midtown actually had one-of-a-kind pieces. Heck, I'd even sell my first born son for the sake keeping this place alive.

Very Clean and organized for an antique shop. 2 floors of a little bit of everything in good condition. Can be pricey depending on what your looking for. Parking is going to be tricky...good luck.

This one is hard to write. I don't know whether to give a 1 star or 4 star. I love the mall, I enjoyed most of the people, but one bad apple spoiled the whole experience. A woman there was nasty both days we were in there. Why do people who are not friendly put themselves in public situations?

I love this antique mall but I had a STRANGE AND UNCOMFORTABLE EXPERIENCE while in the fitting room. I'm not sure if this person was an employee (although I believe he was) but a older overweight balding/bald gentleman wearing a red and white checkered shirt starting banging on the door and demanding to be let it to "use the bathroom urgently". He was quiet rude and aggressive and did not stop banging after I told him I would be out in a moment through the door. Then when I let him in he was aggressive telling me it took me "long enough". I decided to leave without trying on all the clothing. I love this antique mall but I didn't really like being harassed while using the fitting room. Kind of weird.