Mabel's Ice Cream Shop

Stopped in to this cute ice cream shop in Bayport that I've been eyeing for quite some time. The place is so adorable and right on the main drag. You can order inside or come up to the window on three outside and order. I opted to check out the inside of the shop. I ordered 1 scoop of the caramel collision in a cup. It was sooooo delish that I'll definitely be back. It tasted like a rolo and had even mini rolos inside the ice cream. YUM! I can't wait to come back to try other flavors. Another cool feature at this shop is that every ice cream flavor is noted if it has gluten and/or nuts which is helpful for those with allergies.

The outside of the shop is very cool, and includes some picture opportunities. It would be a fun summer stop. You have to try Mabel's! The service was pretty standard. They offered to let me try a few flavors because I was having trouble deciding, which was nice. The waffle cones/cups made-in-house really made the ice cream feel like a special treat. The cone was warm, crisp with a slightly sweet flavor. I tried the pistachio and caramel ices cream- both were on the sweeter side. I liked the real nuts and crunch in the pistachio ice cream.

It's a very family friendly place and it's my first time so I tried their best seller which is a Kottemann in waffle corn. Both my wife and I were fighting over who's going to eat it. It was so good. There were more kids here than adults. Mainly with their parents. I wanted to have the cold brew decaf but they did not have decaf.They allowed me and my wife to taste the flavor before we bought it. Nice grassy shady area to sit outside for at least 30 people.Six dedicated parking spots , plenty of street parking and it seems people are parking next to the church and it looks like the Almighty and the pastor do not mind ... hallelujah.

The service is always good and friendly. The ice cream is always delicious and prices are fair for how much you get. They have a nice little seating area inside and nice outside seating too if you want some sun. I love going here with my partner to get outside and enjoy each other's company.

This is a very nice classic type ice cream shop with a big selection of flavors.The next time you're in the mood for ice cream, don't fight the crowds and the traffic in Stillwater. Mabel's is a short 10 minutes away, right on the main drag in Bayport. They're located in a historic building that used to be a private home.They serve Cedar Crest Ice Cream. We had 24 flavors to choose from. They also have multiple types of cones, including waffle cones and waffle cups they make on-site. When we walked in, the entire building had the sweet smell of fresh waffles - yum!The young woman behind the counter was VERY nice. (I"m sorry that I didn't ask her name.) She was very patient and let us try lots of flavors. I've done over 500 reviews and she's only the SECOND person that ever agreed to have her photo taken for my Yelp review! (I have to say, she's very photogenic.)The historic house is pretty cool too. It's in perfect condition and painted beautifully with crisp vibrant colors. There are placards on the wall that outline some of the history - interesting and worth checking out.If you don't want to sit inside, there's a large seating area in the backyard with picnic tables. And it you have kids, you have to checkout the giant cow placard (with head cutouts) so you can put your face in a dairy cow head and take some goofy photos.Mable's is a nice place and I rate them a solid 4. I'm pretty stingy about handing out 5 star reviews. If they went to the trouble to make their own ice cream, I'd probably bump them up to 5 stars. They're great and definitely worth the stop.Thumbs up!-Daddy Maxx Retro

The ice cream was delicious, good serving size. Many different flavors to choose from. The young ladies working were very friendly.

If you are looking for a fun and delicious Ice Cream Shop this a great place! Nothing better than getting ice cream so definitely try out this place for family day/night or even date day/night!

Very cute spot and delicious ice cream, lots of flavors to try! The food is also very good for the little shop.

Wow!! what a truly amazing company!!! I am so in awe of how amazing they are. Four brunette girls were responsible for the best customer service I have ever experienced in my lifetime. Keep up the good work!!!!!!!!!!

Ice Cream! This place is small, quaint, and fun. Games in the back yard, outdoor tables, and decent parking. Don't forget to get a "Pup Cup" for your four-legged pals.