Milky Way
The 14" Yetti Tracks pizza
the front of the restaurant
a whole pizza on a table
Hot Marmot
Neat poster available for $5-by a local artist!
Hiking theme
A drink while I wait For my pizza
Diablo Picante
Cape Blanco pizza (olive oil, ricotta, mozzarella, pecorino, herbs, fresh garlic, cracked pepper, and sausage)
Divine garlic bread with homemade balsamic dipper (creme fraiche ranch also optional) made in/house
Fully vegetarian
Scarecrow Boogie Pizza
Hogsack Pizza
Wyeast
Special - ramps, pecorino, and smoked Gouda
IPA
interior
food, pizza
pizza, food
Original Portland food truck before opening their building location on the edge of ''Tosa.
Hot Marmot pepperoni, fresh garlic, Mama Lil's sweet hot peppers
Cool view of the pizza oven
Cape Blanco
Randy M.
Oct 9, 2024
They make the most yummy margarita pizza in Milwaukee and the price isn't to bad either. If you want the kind of pizza they have in Italy this is the place!!
Read More
Ryan H.
Nov 5, 2024
Critic Rating: 4.05Scores:- Food: 5.0 * 30% = 1.50- Service: 5.0 * 20% = 1.00- Value for Money: 4.0 * 20% = 0.80- Ambiance: 2.0 * 15% = 0.30- Uniqueness: 3.0 * 15% = 0.45___________________________________________Here's a formula that expresses the quality of a restaurant on a 1-5 scale, considering key factors. Each factor is rated from 1-5, and then weighted according to its importance. Formula: Q = wf*F + ws*S + wa*A + wv*V + wu*U Where:- Q = Overall Restaurant Quality- F = Food Quality: The taste, freshness, presentation of dish.- S = Service: How attentive, friendly, & informed the staff is.- A = Ambiance: Atmosphere, cleanliness, decor, and feel.- V = Value for Money: Balance of price, quantity, & quality.- U = Uniqueness: Novelty of concept, menu, & experience. Weights (w):- wf = Weight of Food Quality (30%)- ws = Weight of Service (20%)- wv = Weight of Value for Money (20%)- wa = Weight of Ambiance (15%)- wu = Weight of Uniqueness (10%)___________________________________________Comments:Best pizza in town. Tiny spot. I get it to-go, so unfortunately the Ambiance gets dinged. Also, pizza is a tough category for Uniqueness.
Read More
Adrienne D.
Nov 3, 2023
I came to Wy'east Pizza after seeing that a few of my classmates had gone to this spot. I was very intrigued by the types of pizza offered. I ordered a glass of IPA and the Diablo Picante with crickets on the side. The pizza is overall pretty good. The candied jalapeños made the pizza a little too sweet for my taste. I think the pizza would've been fine with just plain jalapeños. The pizza came out very hot. The presentation of the pizza was good. I had two very solid cheese pulls when I went for my slices. Service was excellent. Very attentive. The only thing is that the drink menu wasn't the most up-to-date. I was hoping to get one of the beers that ended up not being available. I'll definitely be back to try some other pizzas.
Read More
Nabila M.
Jan 28, 2024
Finally decided to come here for dinner after taking this spot off my list due to the "rules" of picking up pizza or placing orders etc... so we never came. So now that we can dine in and place reservations online we finally made it and i am so happy we came! First it's a very small space so reservations are a must and you must specify qty of pizzas ordering ahead of time. Pizza can take a while but its worth it. Order some appetizers and drinks during the wait. You can't substitute their signature pies so you'll have to build your own with only 3 topping options. So we ordered a pizza with roasted mushrooms, sausage and green olives. This pizza made it to my number one spot. Wow was it delicious. The crust was so crispy and those roasted mushrooms were my favorite. I ordered the pear cider (will have again) and my bf had a cherry IPA beer which was super good. Just beware they dont have any canned soda besides sprecher products or la croix. We will be coming back and i definitely will want to try the focaccia bread appetizer. Staff is very attentive and friendly. Thank you for such a wonderful experience at wyeast!
Read More
Alison M.
May 29, 2024
I love Wy'east!!! When I lived in the Washington Heights neighborhood we would order take out regularly, and now I'm sad to have to drive across the city to pick up. The service is always great - the owners are lovely people. My favorite pizzas are the Hot Marmot and some of the seasonal specials. I'm also obsessed with the focaccia bread! It's amazing with their balsamic sauce. I haven't actually eaten in the restaurant, but from what I've heard, the pizza tastes even better when eaten in house!
Read More
Alyssa F.
Jan 5, 2023
I'll start with the high points. Incredibly nice people. I think our server was one of the owners. Very unique pizza names and ingredient combinations. Small space and uncluttered but has a definite vibe--call it low key hiking lover hipster? If you want to dine-in, it's reservations only. We made an online reservation about 10 days in advance and had zero issues getting a table. Your reservation is only for 60 mins. Not sure if you get the boot then but we were in and out in about 50 mins. They also had super rad posters for their specialty pizzas available for $5. Yes, we bought one. How could we not? It was drawn by a local artist AND was for the pizza we decided to try. Score! Now, as for the pizza. We didn't like it. Mainly because it was SO greasy. It was dripping in grease and honestly just the upper half of the pizza was enjoyable. Flavors were bold and earthy but the grease took away from it all. Good crust-nice and chewy and you could tell it was fresh. They serve up wood fire pizza here and have specialty pizzas they swap out from time to time. Since we ordered a specialty pizza we could only order a 14" pizza which was a bit too big for two people but not impossible to get through most of it. Drinks like Sprechers root beer is available along with beer and wine. They offer 20% off wines on Wednesday! I think we will be back but before we order definitely will mention that we aren't fans of grease dripping pizza.
Read More
Emily D.
Sep 17, 2023
The pizza here is amazing. The crust is crispy, the toppings are fresh, the sauce is delicious. I cannot say enough about how much I love this pizza. The restaurant is super cute and you feel at home there! There's a nice patio outside and a few tables for indoor seating. Our service was excellent and we really enjoyed it. This is one of my parents' favorites so I was excited to try, it did not disappoint!
Read More
Chloe C.
Jan 26, 2024
Love the creative pizza, the charming space, and the friendly service at Wy'East! We've been a few times (always with an online reservation, since the space is so small) and it's always been a delight. Everyone who works there is so kind and its a very casual, cozy place. They have great specials and a nice variety of pizzas. Also, they are right up the road from the Times Cinema, so I highly recommend both for a charming night out.
Read More
Deshawn G.
Mar 9, 2024
Great place, cozy atmosphere. The service was quick. Had a beer while I waited..This is a very small place so call ahead or make reservations if you want to dine in. This place has great wood fired pizza.
Read More
Pat D.
Jan 17, 2024
Outstanding pizza and great beer selection highlight this neighborhood gem. Friendly service and great value top it off. They rotate their pizzas so you'll get different flavors throughout the year. Making it always interesting to check them out.
Read More