Tony's Pizza

We ordered to go, so not sure about the dining atmosphere. This pizza was done on time and was very well cooked, the crust was crisp but the cheese was not too brown or burnt. Man, does this place know and understand cheese! This pizza had the best quantity and good quality blend of oozy, gooey goodness! Well cooked, well provided and best of all well enjoyed!

Attention cheese lovers. I moved here about a month ago and like to support local businesses. Pizza is a great moving meal, right? Well, I found Tony's via Google and holy cheesarony! and holy Wisconsin pizza!I I ordered the owners special and had it delivered. It looked and tasted fantastic. The delivery was super fast and the delivery person was courteous. I will not hesitate to call them again. I highly recommend Tony's.

Okay, it tastes fine, not even average tbh though fine.The atmosphere reeks of old tavern and unclean kitchen. The service is weird! You can't ask for service on drinks or condiments, you need to get up and request them? I'm confused.The pizza overall is a hot mess at best. The crust is an uninspired blend of flour and excessive heat. The sauce, honestly, is all but bland and mute of detectable seasoning. The meat and veggie toppings are just fine in general, for you sticklers, the sausages are frozen and heated after placed, not fresh baked. The review is a 2 because of the cheese. This is the highest regarded pizza joint for miles...in Wisconsin. I expect the cheese to be on point. This restaurant uses a high quality locally produced and sourced cheese on their pizzas which is, by itself, an incredible product. They even go as far as to emblazon their walls with (presumably mandatory) advertising for the cheese brand. The issue is the usage, or abuse of, that cheese. It tastes great and hits your palate just as a freshly melted cheese should. However, it is layered on. I mean layered, not stacked or simply overdone on accident. I've eaten their pizza on at least 6 occasions and every time is the same, a heavy brick of cheese on top of uninspired ingredients.If I order again, it'll be with light cheese. Maybe the pizza will be edible lol.

Best Pizza Ever! This family knows their pizza and they know hospitality. You will receive excellent service and find wonderful delectation in the intimate restaurant. Tony and his staff go above and beyond to accommodate special orders as well as delivery requests. This place has been a staple in the Waupun community for generations, and it shows! Everyday, every order, every time the Tony's Pizza experience will NOT disappoint.

Best pizza in the area, no shortage of toppings. Great owner/operators that support the local community.

We started with the cheese bread which was awesome, they use a very high quality cheese. We also had the stuffed pizza which was good but too much for me, next time I'll go with the regular pizza. It's a nice place, I would go again.

Service was good. They were all very friendly. 2 of us had all you can eat fish. It was overcooked and dry. 2 others ordered lasagna, and there was a small amount with a very large amount of sauce son rates it a 2.

We ordered the Tony's special with extra cheese it was I excellent. Service was speedy and waitress was friendly.

It's been my favorite pizza place for years! Great service, friendly staff, and excellent food! My favorite is the stuffed crust pizza & the chicken parm is fantastic!!

Best Pizza ! Generous amount of toppings!Always a must to stop at Tony's pizza when we are in town.. and one to go for tomorrow.We have never been disappointed with anything we have ordered. A must for true authentic Italian food.