Tomaso's Cedarburg

This has been our go-to pizza take out for years!! Located in charming downtown Cedarburg, you'll always find their take out door revolving on Friday and Saturday nights. The call ahead ordering is easy and they give accurate timing on when your order is ready. Make sure to ask for a punch card, as you'll earn a surprise food item once you complete all the punches. Note the pizza has a unique flair, as the sauce is ON TOP of the cheese, so that may throw you off upon your first order, so I always recommend ordering extra cheese! The crust is great, especially if you like your thin Mke style pie!

This is the best pizza I've ever had outside of Italy.Frankly, it stomps all over other highly-rated MKE pizza joints such as Fixture.The crust and sauce are absolutely as good as they get, and they just always seem to get all the proportions just perfect.

Some of my favorite pizza in the Milwaukee area! This place has a lot of character and makes amazing pizza. I've only ever gotten take out. The order is usually ready anywhere between 20-50 minutes depending on weekday vs weekend. Our go-to order is thin pepperoni pizza and deep dish veggie. All of their ingredients are so good. The pepperoni is crispy and delicious. Their crust doesn't have a ton of flavor to it but it goes well with everything else and is perfectly cooked. Pick-up is easy. They have a door to the sitdown restaurant and then a door for pick up only which is a great idea and keeps it quick and easy. Must try!

We absolutely LOVE Tomaso's in Cedarburg. They have my absolute FAVORITE pizza - perfectly crisp thin crust with the perfect proportion of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Their pizza is wonderfully flavorful and I love that the sauce is on top of the cheese. Tomaso's in Cedarburg has a pretty extensive menu. As much as I would like to try other items on their menu when their pizza is your favorite you eat the pizza. We are also partial to their garlic bread and pickle fries; they are very delicious!Tomaso's is a table seating (seat yourself), order at the bar, and pick up your food at the bar establishment. Service is quick. The restaurant is clean. Prices are reasonable. As I stated, we love it here and will continue to frequent it! I highly recommend their pizza!!

Tomasos in Cedarburg has been a staple in this historic German town for decades. The pizza recipe hasn't changed, and either has the inside, but maybe a few updates. This restaurant is hands down our favorite pizza pit. They always carry good seasonal German beer on tap, give friendly service, along with delicious fresh food. A few tips, get here early as there is not a lot of seating. Also, YES, there is cheese on the pizza it is under the sauce. We get the large Italian sausage, and a large comes with a free 10 inch pizza, perfect for kids. I usually order mushrooms and as a topping, and they are fresh, not canned. When we plan activities in Cedarburg, we always make a stop here. We have never been let down.

I've been hearing about this place for so many years thought I'd check it out. Interesting that it's self serve at the bar to order and pick up your own food and bring it to your table. I guess that alleviates paying servers and leaving tips? The pizza was hot and fresh but I felt the toppings were pretty skimpy. Especially for the price. We ordered ham and pineapple and I don't recall getting more than one or two pieces of pineapple and the four pieces that I consumed. (I don't know what happened to the pictures that I took)

Always quality. great pizza, friendly service. A little spice in the sauce, get the extra cheese.

I would literally drive out of the way (WAY out of the way) to get a deep dish pie at Tomaso's!!! Do yourself a favor and make your next Packers/Badgers/Bucks watch party 300% better with a few pizzas from Tomaso's. The dining room is cozy, maybe a little cramped, but also has a small bar to cozy up to. The service is always good.

No cheese! Too saucy for my taste! A little pricey, too!Need more cheese, should have mentioned it when I ordered that they use very light cheese

Best pizza this side of Italy-particularly like the thin crust-lots of sauce and fresh ingredients